Exclusive

'Proportionality does not weigh on numbers', IDF spokesman says of civilian deaths in Israel response to Hamas attack

2 December 2023, 14:26 | Updated: 2 December 2023, 15:00

'Proportionality does not weigh on numbers' IDF spokesperson Lt Col Peter Lerner said
'Proportionality does not weigh on numbers' IDF spokesperson Lt Col Peter Lerner said. Picture: LBC/Getty

By Kit Heren

A spokesman for the Israeli army has told LBC that the "proportionality" of the Israeli response to the Hamas massacre "does not weigh on numbers" of civilian casualties.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Lieutenant Colonel Peter Lerner said that proportionality in warfare was about "military necessity".

Speaking to LBC's Sangita Myska on the second day after Israel resumed its military operations in Gaza after a seven-day truce broke down, Lt Col Lerner said that Israel was committed to rooting out Hamas.

"The operations that we are conducting are in order to dismantle and destroy Hamas, who have embedded themselves deeply, deeply within the civilian population," he said.

Hamas-affiliated health authorities said on Saturday that nearly 200 civilians had been killed since the fighting restarted on Friday morning, with 650 injured.

Read more: Talks to restart Israel-Hamas truce break down, as IDF issues fresh evacuation orders for southern Gaza

Read more: 'Nearly 200 killed' in Gaza since Israel-Hamas war restarted, as IDF pounds south of strip despite fears for civilians

Watch Again: Sangita Myska is joined by Lieutenant Colonel Peter Lerner | 02/12/23

The same officials said that more than 15,000 people have been killed in Gaza overall since Israel launched its response to Hamas' massacre of October 7, when 1,200 were killed in southern Israel and 240 taken hostage.

Some 5,000 Hamas fighters, out of a possible total of between 20,000 and 25,000 have been killed in the fighting in Gaza.

Asked by Sangita if this was proportionate, Lt Col Lerner said: "That was, I think, absolutely a reality on the ground.

"If... 5000 terrorists have been killed, that's successful.

He added: "Proportionality doesn't weigh... on a number, proportionality and warfare weighs on distinction and weighs on military necessity. And that is proportionality. Not some abstract number, which is terrifying."

Residents of Khan Younis in the southern Gaza Strip carry some of their belongings as they flee their homes
Residents of Khan Younis in the southern Gaza Strip carry some of their belongings as they flee their homes. Picture: Getty

Lt Col Lerner added that every time he sees images of the civilian casualties of the war on television "they are heartbreaking".

But he added: "It doesn't change the fact that Hamas have to go.

"Hamas has to leave the arena for everyone's good, and there is a reality where this organisation has conducted the most lethal, brutal, merciless attack against Israel, that has a history of being attacked by terrorist organisations."

Lt Col Lerner said that "even in last 24 hours since we resumed operations, we have killed tens of their terrorists in different locations in the northern Gaza Strip, and in spurts and precision strikes, and we will continue to do so."

Palestinians mourn their relatives killed in the Israeli bombardment of Khan Younis
Palestinians mourn their relatives killed in the Israeli bombardment of Khan Younis. Picture: Alamy

International pressure has mounted on Israel to implement more truces, with some pushing for a more permanent ceasefire.

But the IDF spokesperson said: "There is actually no pressure on us, from our perspective. There is no time limit, we have time on our hands in order to implement this feat.

"We have to understand Hamas have governed the Gaza Strip for 16 years. In that time, they have embedded themselves extensively".

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Couple holding hands

Campaigners 'deeply moved' by baby loss certificate scheme - as more than 100,000 issued since service started

Pregnancy

Diabetes during pregnancy linked to increased risk of disorders like autism and ADHD in children, study suggests

Just 3% of England’s local road network received any form of maintenance in the 2023/24 financial year, new analysis shows.

Only 3% of local road network received maintenance in the last year

Yuan Yang and Abtisam Mohamed were rejected from entering Israel

Israel's decision to bar two MPs from entering country 'smacks of racism', claims MP

c

Baby girl makes history as first child in UK to be born from womb transplant

US-ISRAEL-POLITICS-DIPLOMACY-TRUMP-NETANYAHU

Trump says US will hold direct talks with Iran as he insists Tehran cannot get nuclear weapons

Video footage shows the convoy had emergency lights flashing when it was hit

Israeli troops opened fire on ambulances because of 'perceived threat', IDF investigation finds

Angela

Angela Rayner quizzed on whether Army could be deployed to Birmingham to help collect bins during strike

John Lees

Teacher who crashed car into tree on way to school after drinking half bottle of wine avoids ban from teaching

LBC's Tom Swarbrick headed to Birmingham to investigate the bin strikes

LBC's Tom Swarbrick investigates the Birmingham bin strike as 'mountains of rubbish' fill the streets

Neighbours rushed to the terraced house after a gunman fired into its living room on Sunday.

Horror video shows moment ‘gunman shoots dad, 60, dead through downstairs window’ in broad daylight

Police have launched an urgent search for missing girl, who was last seen 24 hours ago in Stoke-on-Trent.

Urgent hunt for missing schoolgirl, 12, after she didn't return home last night

A plastic surgeon has been found guilty of attempting to murder a fellow doctor

Plastic surgeon guilty of attempting to murder colleague he wanted 'out of the way'

Blondie, 1979. Clockwise from top left, guitarist Chris Stein, singer Debbie Harry, bass player Nigel Harrison, drummer Clem Burke, guitarist Frank Infante and keyboard player Jimmy Destri

Tributes pour in as Blondie star dies aged 70 after private battle with cancer

Seven people were taken to hospital following the blaze

Seven people taken to hospital and eight homes evacuated after fire breaks out at block of flats

Home Secretary Yvette Cooper has launched a public inquiry into the Southport murders after three young girls were killed last July.

Inquiry launched into Axel Rudakubana's Southport triple-murder