Decision to remove Shamima Begum of British citizenship ‘unlawful’, court hears, as ISIS bride fights to return to UK

25 October 2023, 00:21 | Updated: 25 October 2023, 00:22

Her lawyers attended the Court of Appeal on Tuesday in a bid to overturn the previous ruling.
Her lawyers attended the Court of Appeal on Tuesday in a bid to overturn the previous ruling. Picture: Alamy/Getty

By Jenny Medlicott

The decision to revoke Shamima Begum’s British citizenship was “unlawful”, the Court of Appeal has been told.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

At 15, Begum and her school friends Kadiza Sultana, 15, and Amira Abase, 16, fled London to join ISIS.

She was later found in a refugee camp in 2019 and had her British citizenship withdrawn on national security grounds.

Ms Begum, now 24, lost her legal challenge over the decision to deprive her of her British citizenship earlier this year.

She brought a challenge against the Home Office over the decision at the Special Immigration Appeals Commission (SIAC) but Mr Justice Jay rejected Ms Begum’s legal challenge in February.

On Tuesday Ms Begum’s lawyers began another bid to overturn the decision, which is being opposed by the Home Office.

The tribunal earlier this year found there was “credible suspicion” that Begum had been trafficked to Syria for sexual exploitation.

Now her legal team has claimed the Home Office failed to consider the legal duties Ms Begum may have been owed as a potential trafficking victim.

“[Ms Begum's] trafficking was a mandatory, relevant consideration in determining whether it was conducive to the public good and proportionate to deprive her of citizenship, but it was not considered by the Home Office,” Samantha Knights KC said in written submissions.

"As a consequence, the deprivation decision was unlawful."

Read more: Calls for Israel-Hamas ceasefire grow as UN chief warns situation in Gaza 'worsening by the hour'

Read more: Care home residents treated 'like exhibits in reptile museum' Covid inquiry told

Shamima Begum has taken her case to the Court of Appeal in a bid to overturn February's ruling.
Shamima Begum has taken her case to the Court of Appeal in a bid to overturn February's ruling. Picture: Getty

Ms Knights also pointed to another instance of a group of schoolgirls from Tower Hamlets who had been radicalised but were successfully stopped from joining ISIS after prompt action from police and the courts.

“In contrast in (Begum’s) case there was no State protection”, Ms Knights told the court.

“SIAC found that there were arguable State failures by the police, the school, and the local authority to take reasonable preventative measures to protect (her) from being trafficked.

“The UK has since failed to investigate these State failures, and Ms Begum has been provided with no protection or recovery services by the UK authorities.”

Ms Knights said these State failures could have also have contributed to Ms Begum’s trafficking.

Sir James Eadie KC said in written submissions: "The fact that someone is radicalised, and may have been manipulated, is not inconsistent with the assessment that they pose a national security risk.

"Ms Begum contends that national security should not be a 'trump' card. But the public should not be exposed to risks to national security because events and circumstances have conspired to give rise to that risk."

He continued: “An individual could have been manipulated, radicalised, and have her travel to ISIL-controlled territory facilitated by someone else.

“However, that would not touch the assessment that the individual also posed a real risk to national security, whether or not as a result of those same circumstances.”

The hearing is expected to last three days.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Washington, DC, USA. 15 Apr 2017. A balloon caricature of President Donald Trump appears at the Tax March protest near the U.S. Capitol.

Buy US chlorinated chicken in return for lower tariffs, Trump tells Britain

From jeans to jet fuel and firearms to whiskey: Britain unveils lengthy list of US items facing tariffs

From jeans to jet fuel and firearms to whiskey: Britain unveils lengthy list of US items facing tariffs

Forensic investigators at Milton Keynes train station after a man was shot dead by armed police officers.

Knifeman shot dead by police in Milton Keynes after moving 'at speed' towards officers named for first time

The bodies of Andrew Searle and his wife Dawn were discovered by a neighbour.

British couple found dead in south of France home being ‘treated as murder-suicide’

Kerri Pegg, former governor of HMP Kirkham,

Prison governor denies relationship with drug boss 'Jesse Pinkman' after flip flops carrying his DNA found in her flat

Julie Goodyear as Bet Lynch. Her husband has now deleted a recent photograph of the actress which he shared in honour of her 83rd birthday on Wednesday

Julie Goodyear's husband removes rare photo of Coronation Street star after dementia diagnosis amid blacklash

The vehicle was later extinguished after the driver, covered in flames, emerged from the vehicle.

Amsterdam Dam Square car explosion sees driver engulfed in flames - just days after mass stabbing

Kanye West confirms that him and Bianca Censori have split.

Kanye West confirms split from wife Bianca Censori as rapper claims she 'tried to have me committed'

d

Pictured: US tourist arrested for sailing to remote island and leaving a can of Coke for world's most isolated tribe

The female athlete took a knee instead of competing against a transgender athlete in a fencing tournament.

Fencing row erupts as US athlete takes knee instead of competing against transgender athlete

Luton Airport

Luton Airport expansion plans approved by transport secretary despite environmental concerns

police officer uk jacket

Boy, 15, locked up after stabbing girl, 13, with sword and leaving her to die by side of motorway

The UK's charity watchdog has launched a probe into Prince Harry’s Sentebale charity

Prince Harry breaks silence as he attacks 'blatant lies' amid investigation into Sentebale charity

M5 closed in both directions after body found on motorway sparking police investigation

M5 closed in both directions after body found on motorway sparking police investigation

Lucy

Expert panel claims 'no criminal offences committed' in Lucy Letby case after bombshell new report into baby deaths

The Sentinelese are a pre-Neolithic tribe that rejects contact with the modern world

US tourist arrested for sailing to remote island and leaving a can of Coke for the world's most isolated tribe to try