Suella Braverman marshals Tory peers against 'Charlotte's Law' after LBC reporter's arrest covering eco-protest

7 February 2023, 05:58 | Updated: 7 February 2023, 08:54

Ms Braverman wants peers to oppose "Charlotte&squot;s law"
Ms Braverman wants peers to oppose "Charlotte's law". Picture: Alamy
Connor Hand

By Connor Hand

Suella Braverman has ordered Conservative peers to vote against a new law seeking to bolster the rights of journalists covering protests following the arrest of LBC's Charlotte Lynch in November 2022.

Despite being in possession of her press card and an LBC branded microphone, Charlotte was approached by two officers responding to a Just Stop Oil protest on the M25, who arrested her on suspicion of conspiracy to commit public nuisance.

Handcuffed and with all of her equipment seized, she was taken to Stevenage police station in the back of a Hertfordshire Constabulary van; there, with tears running down her face, she was ushered into a police cell, where she remained for the next five hours.

Recalling the incident on LBC the next day, Charlotte admitted she was "absolutely terrified" throughout the ordeal.

While Hertfordshire Police eventually conceded that she had been wrongfully arrested, her case sparked significant concerns surrounding press freedom, with the prime minister's spokesperson stressing "it is vital journalists are able to do their job freely without restriction".

To this end, a coalition of opposition and crossbench peers tabled an amendment to the government's controversial Public Order Bill, led by Labour peer and former Shadow Attorney General, Baroness Chakrabarti.

LBC Reporter recounts her arrest for doing her job at an eco-protest

Dubbed "Charlotte's Law", Clause 18 was drafted to "protect journalists, legal observers, academics, and bystanders who observe or report on protests or the police's use of powers related to protests".

Yet, as peers prepare to vote on the measure this evening, sources have revealed to LBC that the home secretary is marshalling Conservatives in the upper chamber to reject the amendment's introduction, meaning it is expected to be the latest in a series of heavily contested disputes over the Public Order Bill.

Labour's Lord Falconer said: "Charlotte's experience… she was not alone, there were two other journalists on the day, there have been other journalists who have been arrested in the last year.

"It is absolutely obvious that even if the law protects journalists at the moment the police just ignore that.

"What's more, after Charlotte was arrested, the PCC, the police and crime commissioner for Hertfordshire, justified the arrest by saying well the journalists being there incite the protesters by filming them.

"It's an sbolutely outrage. The minister's answer, namely don't you worry, things are ok, the law's fine, is absolutely nonsense."

He feared without the amendment passing, police will be uninhibited from detaining journalists.

Just last week, the government sustained two narrow defeats on the bill in the House of Lords, with an amendment attempting to prevent protests on an issue of "current debate" being struck down by a mere three votes (221 vs 224).

With the amendment's passing in doubt, Baroness Chakrabarti told LBC that she laments Ms Braverman's decision to oppose "Charlotte's Law".

Suella Braverman wants to block the law
Suella Braverman wants to block the law. Picture: Alamy

"Free and open reporting matters. It matters whatever people's views on protests that they support or detest," she said.

"For the home secretary to double down and reject cross-party attempts to protect those who report on demonstrations, is a dark day for democracy and a new low for this totally dysfunctional excuse for a Government.

"I urge all peers to vote for this new provision in honour of LBC's Charlotte Lynch and all journalists wrongfully arrested, detained and bullied just for doing their vital work."

Asked whether Ms Braverman would be supporting Baroness Chakrabarti's proposals, a home office spokesperson said: "The Public Order Bill will give the police the powers they need to prevent and respond to guerrilla tactics that cause misery to the hard-working public.

"Freedom of the press is a cornerstone of our democracy and there are already safeguards under current legislation, which can ensure that journalists are protected when reporting on protests."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

14 passengers made it onto a life raft

At least six dead and seven missing after fishing boat sinks 200 miles off Falkland Islands

Charlotte Dujardin, Britain's joint-most decorated female Olympian, has pulled out of Paris 2024

Britain’s Charlotte Dujardin ‘whipped horse 24 times like an elephant in the circus’, claims lawyer

Roberta Taylor was diagnosed with pneumonia after a fall two months ago

EastEnders and The Bill star Roberta Taylor dies aged 76 from infection caused by fall

Kamala Harris raises her arms against a backdrop of US flags

Kamala Harris kicks off campaign for US president with rally in Wisconsin

A line of traffic against a red background

Wildfires send thousands fleeing from Canadian Rockies’ national park

Former Home Secretary James Cleverly has announced he will stand in the Conservative Party leadership contest.

Former Home Secretary James Cleverly announces Tory leadership bid

Kamala Harris

‘A fight for the future’: Kamala Harris vows to take on Donald Trump’s ‘extremist’ agenda in first campaign rally speech

Police help a man out of a police vehicle

Man faces murder charges after mass shooting in Croatia nursing home

Labour has seen off a potential rebellion on the two-child benefit cap

Keir Starmer suspends seven rebel Labour MPs who voted to get rid of two-child benefit cap

Spain and Manchester City star Rodri has been charged by UEFA after he chanted about Gibraltar during a Euro 2024 victory event.

Manchester City star Rodri charged by UEFA over Gibraltar chants during EURO 2024 celebrations

President Joe Biden boards Air Force One at Dover Air Force Base, in Dover, Delaware

Joe Biden seen for first time since quitting presidential race as Democrats rally behind Kamala Harris

Robert Hammond, 47, faced a "surging mountain of debt and financial pressures"

Mortgage broker who murdered his wife to cash in on her life insurance and pay off £300,000 debt jailed for 24 years

Michael Marmot said the cap was 'almost a form of eugenics'

Two-child benefit cap amounts to eugenics, public health expert claims ahead of MPs' vote

nna Holland and Phoebe Plummer are accused of throwing two cans of soup at the legendary painting

Tomato soup acted 'like paint stripper' in Just Stop Oil Van Gogh protest, court hears

Crowd of people on a hillside

Death toll in Ethiopia mudslides rises to 229 as search operations continue

Charlotte Dujardin, Britain's joint-most decorated female Olympian, has pulled out of Paris 2024

Team GB’s Charlotte Dujardin suspended after video shows her ‘hitting horse’s legs’