Girl, 12, loses High Court battle against school for 'requiring' pupils to wear masks

5 May 2021, 18:02

A 12-year-old schoolgirl has lost a High Court battle against mandatory mask wearing (file picture)
A 12-year-old schoolgirl has lost a High Court battle against mandatory mask wearing (file picture). Picture: Getty

By Kate Buck

A 12-year-old girl has lost a High Court fight against her school for "requiring" pupils to wear face coverings, after claiming they risk causing "serious harm" to children's physical and mental health.

The pupil brought legal action against the Tapton Academy School Trust, which runs a number of primary and secondary schools in the Sheffield area, to stop it from "requiring or encouraging" children to wear masks at school to prevent the spread of Covid-19.

The schoolgirl, known only as AB and who has been exempted from wearing a mask at school, said mask-wearing could lead to "long-term" harm.

At a remote hearing last month, AB's lawyers asked the High Court to grant an interim injunction preventing her school and the trust from making children wear masks.

Read more: Canada and Germany suspend AstraZeneca jab over safety concerns

Explained: Differences between AstraZeneca, Pfizer and Moderna vaccines

However, the trust argued that its policy "is to encourage, not to enforce" the wearing of masks, in line with Government guidance, in order to protect children, staff and visitors.

Campaigner says care homes are applying Covid rules differently

The court previously heard that 120 members of staff across the trust's various schools, representing more than 10% of its total staff, had contracted coronavirus since the end of August 2020.

In a judgment on Wednesday, Judge Roger ter Haar QC rejected the request for an injunction, as the pupil is not required to wear a mask and the injunction was not necessary to protect her health and safety.

He said: "The case as presently put forward by the claimant suffers from a fundamental defect: the school does not require the claimant to wear a mask - she has been treated as being exempt from that requirement."

Read more: UK secondary school pupils 'to be offered Pfizer jab from September'

Read more: Britain secures 60m extra Pfizer doses for autumn booster programme

The judge said he made "no conclusions whatsoever as to the safety or otherwise of requiring children to wear face masks at school".

AB's lawyers had provided a report from a chartered health and safety practitioner about problems children may face wearing masks, as well as a report from a clinical psychologist about psychological risks of a mask-wearing policy.

Judge ter Haar continued: "Put shortly, the underlying premise of the claim is that the physical and psychological risks presented to children by the requirement to wear face masks is not justified by medical or epidemiological evidence.

"That is a belief strongly held by many people, including the claimant's father, as illustrated by the fact that, as I was told, this action has been crowdfunded."

He added that the witnesses' views "do not represent universal scientific and medical views as to the scientific and medical merits, disadvantages and dangers of the wearing of masks in schools".

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Harry has paid tribute to veterans

Prince Harry pays heartfelt tribute to 'fellow veterans' in rare statement to mark Armistice Day

Klopp with David Coote at a Liverpool v Burnley game in 2020

Premier League ref David Coote suspended after 'launching X-rated rant against Liverpool and Jurgen Klopp'

Oxford Street Security In London

'I was held at knifepoint': One in six shopworkers assaulted by customers

A bride was left devastated after only five guests attended her wedding despite her sending invitations to 75 people

Bride left devastated after no one turns up to her wedding

The 'skip forward' voyage will last up to four years.

Cruise company offers four-year 'skip forward' voyage for Americans to avoid Donald Trump's presidency

Derriford Hospital

Pensioner, 87, dies after being blown off her feet by helicopter after hospital visit

The identity of the fan who mocked the death of George Baldock has been revealed

Sheffield Wednesday fan who mocked death of George Baldock named as police launch probe

Patrick Ruane encouraged violence towards Prof Sir Chris Whitty

Covid denier jailed for five years after suggesting ‘whacking’ Chris Whitty with a rounders bat

Justin Welby’s position at the Church of England has been described as ‘untenable’ by a senior member of the church

Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby under growing pressure to resign over Church abuse scandal

Shoppers queued for hours to get themselves a bargain in the sale

Top of the pots: Le Creuset sale sparks four-hour long queues as police called in to manage crowds

Patrick Ruane, 55, was found guilty at the Old Bailey of two charges of encouraging terrorism

Covid conspiracy theorist jailed for terrorism offences after encouraging violence against Chris Whitty

Driving without insurance is illegal

Worst areas in Britain for uninsured drivers revealed, with one city dominating list

Millions of Brits fell silent to honour the fallen on Monday.

'We will remember them': Nation falls silent as millions of Brits remember the fallen for Armistice Day

Keir Starmer has attended Armistice Day events in Paris

Starmer becomes first British leader since Churchill to attend Armistice Day ceremony in France

Former soldier Daniel Khalife has pleaded guilty part way through his trial at Woolwich Crown Court to escaping from HMP Wandsworth

Former soldier Daniel Khalife admits escaping from Wandsworth Prison part way through trial

Exclusive
UK’s oldest World War II Veteran honoured with hundreds of handmade poppies in Armistice Day display.

UK’s oldest Second World War veteran honoured with hundreds of handmade poppies in Armistice Day display