Matt Hancock committed 'minor' breach of ministerial code over NHS contract

28 May 2021, 23:14

The Health Secretary committed a "minor" but undeliberate breach of the ministerial code by failing to declare that a family firm he held shares in won an NHS contract
The Health Secretary committed a "minor" but undeliberate breach of the ministerial code by failing to declare that a family firm he held shares in won an NHS contract. Picture: PA

By Kate Buck

The Health Secretary committed a "minor" but undeliberate breach of the ministerial code by failing to declare that a family firm he held shares in won an NHS contract, the Prime Minister's ethics adviser has concluded.

Mr Hancock declared in the MPs' register of interests in March this year that he owns 20% of shares in Topwood Limited, a firm owned by his sister and other close family members, which specialises in secure storage, shredding and scanning of documents.

The company, as first reported by the Health Service Journal (HSJ), won a place on a framework to provide services to the English NHS in 2019, as well as contracts with the NHS in Wales, after Mr Hancock was appointed to his Cabinet brief in July 2018.

Read more: Daily Covid cases jump by over 4,000 for first time since April

Lord Geidt, an independent adviser on ministerial standards, found in a much-delayed report on ministerial interests that the awarding of the contract to Topwood could be seen to "represent a conflict of interest" that should have been declared.

He said the failure to declare the link at the time was a "technical" breach of the rules.

The Prime Minister, who makes the final decision on breaches of the rules, said no further action was required in the cas
The Prime Minister, who makes the final decision on breaches of the rules, said no further action was required in the cas. Picture: PA

The Prime Minister, who makes the final decision on breaches of the rules, said no further action was required in the case.

But the conclusion is likely to pile further pressure on the Health Secretary, who was accused this week of lying and failing to protect care homes at the outset of the coronavirus pandemic by former No 10 aide Dominic Cummings.

In his 10-page report, Lord Geidt said: "Given that Topwood Ltd had secured the award of a framework contract with NHS Shared Business Services, a company in which the legal personality of the Secretary of State is a shareholder, I believe there to be a danger that a reasonable person might perceive this link to represent a conflict of interest, and that it should have been declared at the time.

Read more: PM's handling of Indian variant 'unsurprisingly dreadful,' says Independent SAGE member

Read more: France to impose new quarantine measures on UK visitors amid concern over Indian variant

"In reaching this determination, I accept that the scale of NHS operations in England (for which the Secretary of State is responsible) are broad and that the activity of NHS SBS may have been very far from the Secretary of State's main focus.

"I assess this earlier failure to declare the interest was as a result of his lack of knowledge and in no way deliberate, and therefore, in technical terms, a minor breach of the ministerial code.

James O'Brien and German caller discuss 'Freedom Day'

"I have advised the Prime Minister accordingly.

"In coming to this finding, I recognise that Mr Hancock has acted with integrity throughout and that this event should in no way impugn his good character or ministerial record."

In a letter to the Prime Minister, Mr Hancock said: "I did not know about the framework decision, and so I do not think I could reasonably have been expected to declare it.

"Nor can I see how a conflict of interest can arise in a matter about which I had no knowledge."

In his reply, Boris Johnson told Mr Hancock he agreed with Lord Geidt's assessment and "I do not consider that any further action is required".

Traditionally, a breach of the code has led to the resignation of ministers, although Home Secretary Priti Patel kept her job earlier this year after being found to have engaged in bullying behaviour towards staff by Lord Geidt's predecessor, Sir Alex Allan.

Sir Alex resigned after Mr Johnson chose to back Ms Patel following his investigation into her conduct.

Lord Geidt said Mr Hancock's shares in Topwood could "be a reasonably perceived conflict of interest" but suggested that they could be "best managed through publication, as has occurred".

"The Secretary of State has acted properly and honestly in promptly making this declaration and diligently seeking advice," he added.

In the same report, Lord Geidt also found the Prime Minister had not broken the code in relation to how the renovation of his Downing Street flat was funded but criticised him for failing to take a "more rigorous" interest in the process.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Merseyside man Eddie Burton, 23, and his former partner Sian Banks, 25, were convicted of orchestrating two large-scale drug importations.

Couple convicted over £20m drug smuggling plot after Ibiza nightclub arrest

Exclusive
Calls for police to reinvestigate parish councillor who 'blew up' neighbour's cat

‘It made me feel physically sick’: Cat owner’s fury at parish councillor accused of trying to ‘blow up’ beloved pet

Gino D'Acampo

TV chef Gino D'Acampo accused of 'unacceptable' and 'distressing' behaviour spanning 12 years

Exclusive
'I feel like Mrs Bates VS The Council': Pub landlady considers legal action over council flooding team's 'lack of action'

'It's like Mrs Bates VS The Council': Pub landlady considers legal action over council flooding team's 'lack of action'

Liz Kendall

Too many people on benefits are 'taking the mickey' - but there are more people who want to work, says minister

Exclusive
Lauren Selkirk

School refuses to tell mum why staff member 'removed' after incident involving her daughter, 5, and social workers

Kanye West, left, and Bianca Censori arrive at the 67th annual Grammy Awards on Sunday, Feb. 2, 2025, in Los Angeles. (Photo by Jordan Strauss/Invision/AP)

Bianca Censori shares true feelings towards Kanye West's nude Grammys stunt

Landlords face £6k bill to meet higher energy efficiency standards on rental homes by 2030 under government plans

Landlords face £6k bill to meet higher energy efficiency targets under government plans

Pope Francis meets Prince Charles, Prince of Wales and his wife Camilla Duchess of Cornwall at the Vatican on April 4, 2017.

King Charles and Queen Camilla to meet Pope Francis during state visit to Italy

A British couple was reportedly found dead by a neighbour in Les Pesquiès, south of Villefranche-de-Rouergue.

British couple found dead inside 'isolated' French villa in 'feared burglary gone wrong'

Exclusive
Commuter backlash after Network Rail 'erases trains from departure boards' early to 'ease rush'

Commuter backlash after Network Rail 'erases trains from departure boards early' to 'ease passenger rush'

b

Knife arches in schools are welcome - but who is going to pay for them?

James Evans, 19, left, and Justin Keeling (formerly Evans), 18, right, have admitted to starting a massive fire that sparked a mass evacuation.

Two teens admit starting huge fire that 'ripped residents out of homes' during summer riots

Inga Gehricke, five, went missing following a family barbecue in Germany back in 2015.

Police launch fresh search efforts for missing girl linked to prime Madeleine McCann suspect

v

School named after Prince Andrew set to rebrand to something less 'controversial'

The Princess Royal during a visit to Southmead Hospital in Bristol to thank the team of doctors, nurses and health professionals who treated her following her accident in June 2024.

Princess Anne returns to the intensive care unit where she had treatment for head injuries