Keir Starmer 'right' not to join picket lines as doing so would be 'gesture politics', says former Labour leader Neil Kinnock

10 January 2023, 19:16

Former Labour Leader said Keir Starmer was "right" not to join strike pickets
Former Labour Leader said Keir Starmer was "right" not to join strike pickets. Picture: Getty/LBC
Kieran Kelly

By Kieran Kelly

Former Labour leader Neil Kinnock has suggested Keir Starmer is "right" not to join strike picket lines as doing so would be "gesture politics".

Appearing on Tonight with Andrew Marr, Lord Kinnock was asked by for his view on why Sir Keir has not joined workers on strike on the picket line.

He said: "It's because Keir doesn't engage in gesture politics - and he's right not to.

"He knows that the disadvantages, politically, of turning up on picket lines...vastly outweigh the advantages of it.

"The workers on the picket lines know that whilst they might get a momentary stimulus to morale - which is nice, I've done it myself, I've applauded it myself - but they know it's momentary."

Lord Kinnock added that it makes "no significant contribution" to the resolution of the strikes.

The former Labour leader was in opposition between 1983 and 1992 at a time when industrial relations were turbulent after a series of anti-union bills were passed by then-prime minister Margaret Thatcher.

In recent months, Britain has been rocked by another wave of industrial action across the country, including by rail staff, ambulance workers and Royal Mail employees.

This is set to continue in the next few weeks and months, with another set of strikes by ambulance staff represented by Unison taking place tomorrow and on January 23.

Members of the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) will also walk out on two separate occasions next week.

Lord Neil Kinnock on strikes

Also on Tonight with Andrew Marr, Lord Kinnock condemned new legislation proposed by the government that could prevent workers from striking, and questioned whether it would ever get past legal challenges.

He told Andrew: "It's highly objectionable, indeed, in a democracy, it's poisonous in the absence of further safeguards, but I don't think it's practical anyway.

"They've got to get it through the House of Lords, certainly the House of Commons too because they will be Conservative MPs that will have doubts about this."

Lord Kinnock added that the courts "could be the great impediment, because even in a country, with an unwritten constitution, there are certain accumulated basic human rights that relate to the right to withdraw your labour.

"But I don't think we should ever see full implementation. And certainly, if the penalties involved were to end up with people being dismissed for taking strike action, making themselves open to injunctions against strike action, or indeed end up in jail for contempt of court."

The new bill, introduced by business secretary Grant Shapps, would prevent some employees from being able to go on strike without fear of losing their jobs.

Read More: Plans to curb workers' rights to strike are 'poisonous' and 'highly objectionable', says former Labour leader Neil Kinnock

Read More: NHS must do whatever it takes to tackle crisis, says Shapps - including cabins in car parks

Grant Shapps sets out new laws requiring minimum levels of service during strikes_Original Video_m225961

The proposed law would mean areas including the NHS, education, fire and rescue, border security and nuclear decommissioning would have to introduce minimum levels of service during strikes to provide a ‘safety net’ to the public.

Employers would have to set out the workforce they need, preventing some employees from being able to strike with protection from unfair dismissal.

The plans have been criticised as an ‘attack on human rights’. If made law, some union workers would be required to continue working during a strike.

Mr Shapps told the Commons the Government "absolutely believes in the right to strike" but that it is "duty bound" to protect the lives and livelihoods of people in the UK.

Business secretary introduced the controversial new bill in the House of Commons today
Business secretary introduced the controversial new bill in the House of Commons today. Picture: Getty

He thanked the Royal College of Nursing for working with health officials to ensure "safe levels of cover" during their strike, adding they showed they could protest in a "reasonable and mature way".

Labour's deputy leader Angela Rayner weighed in, calling the bill "stupid".

She added: "There is no common sense about this at all. He says he recognises pressure faced by key workers, but he knows the NHS cannot find the nurses they need to work on the ward, he knows the trains don't run even on non-strike days such is their shortage of staff.

"So, how can he seriously think that sacking thousands of key workers won't just plunge our public services further into crisis?"

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Ivan Toney was named in Thomas Tuchel's latest 26-man squad ahead of England's World Cup qualifier against Andorra on June 7 and friendly against Senegal on June 1

Ivan Toney recalled to England squad after Saudi move as Tuchel names 26-man line-up

The boys had been riding a motorbike on Lower Broughton Road, Salford

Two boys, 16 and 17, ‘riding same motorbike’ killed in crash with car

Kermit the frog passed on his wisdom to students in Maryland

'Leap together': Kermit the frog shares key advice as he delivers graduation speech in Maryland

Shocking footage released by the London Ambulance Service shows a man throwing a missile at the vehicle which crashes through the driver's window

Shocking moment thief smashes ambulance window and steals medics’ bags while they treat patient

A satellite image shows the warship at the harbour before the launch

North Korea launches investigation into 'embarrassing' warship damage - as leader Kim Jong Un left furious by incident

Photovoltaic panels installed on a rooftop with chimney and skylights, harnessing solar power for sustainable energy generation

Energy provider launches solar scheme to save customers £200 a year

Sarah Milgrim and Yaron Lischinsky met while working at the Israeli Embassy

Israeli embassy couple shooting suspect 'fired repeatedly after victims fell to the ground'

Ayla Mellek, 20, was body-slammed to the ground by a "massive" man while walking on Mile End canal.

Men deliberately body-slamming women as more cases of 'violent' trend emerge in London

Gloucester services, with its farm shop and fresh produce, has been named as Britain's favourite service station

UK's 'best and worst' service stations ranked - Is one of the best near you?

The 40-year-old former X Factor star apologised to fans on Instagram with a heartfelt message.

'Glasgow, I'm so sorry', Olly Murs tells fans in emotional video after he pulls the plug on his show and walks off stage

Ncuti Gatwa attending the premiere of Doctor Who season two, at the Odeon Luxe West End, Leicester Square, London, in March 2025.

Doctor Who bosses deny claims star Ncuti Gatwa 'axed' from show

The footage shows Wendy Rush, the wife of Mr Rush, hearing the sound of the implosion while watching from the sub's support ship, asking: "What was that bang?"

Chilling four words spoken by OceanGate CEO’s wife when she unknowingly heard Titan sub imploding during descent

Andrew Malkinson (left) was wrongfully convicted of rape in 2003. Karen Kneller (right), chief executive of the CCRC, which was criticised for its handling of the case.

Criminal Cases Review Commission chief’s position ‘no longer tenable’ after mishandling of Malkinson case, MPs warn

Millions of people will see their bills drop by £129

Millions of people to save £129 on bills as energy price cap drops to £1,720 per year

The container ship NCL Salten ran aground, just a few meters from Johan Helberg's house. The 135-meter-long ship ran aground in the Trondheimsfjord outside Byneset on Thursday night.

'A bulky new neighbour’: Man in Norway stunned as huge container ship crashes into his front garden

Exclusive
members of Kneecap, Liam Og O Hannaigh (Mo Chara), JJ O'Dochartaigh (aDJ Provai) and Naoise O Caireallain (Moglai Bap) attending the Irish Film and Television Academy (IFTA) Awards.

'Total disgrace': Politicians call for rethink on Kneecap festival gig after member charged with terror offence