Home Office shows 'little concern over damage caused by immigration failures'

18 September 2020, 00:00 | Updated: 18 September 2020, 00:05

A scathing report by MPs has criticised the Home Office over its attitude towards immigration enforcement
A scathing report by MPs has criticised the Home Office over its attitude towards immigration enforcement. Picture: PA Images
Ewan Quayle

By Ewan Quayle

The Home Office has been accused of basing immigration policies on "anecdote, assumption and prejudice" instead of evidence, and having no idea of the effect they have on migrants.

According to a scathing review from the Public Accounts Committee, the government department shows far too little concern over the damage caused by its failures on "both the illegal and legitimate migrant populations".

Published on Friday, the findings said the Home Office has "no idea" what its £400 million immigration enforcement annual spending achieves, and instead appears to formulate policies not on evidence but on "anecdote, assumption and prejudice".

Committee chair Meg Hillier said: "The Home Office has frighteningly little grasp of the impact of its activities in managing immigration.

"It shows no inclination to learn from its numerous mistakes across a swathe of immigration activities - even when it fully accepts that it has made serious errors.

"It accepts the wreckage that its ignorance and the culture it has fostered caused in the Windrush scandal - but the evidence we saw shows too little intent to change, and inspires no confidence that the next such scandal isn't right around the corner."

Labour MP and chair of the Public Accounts Committee Meg Hillier slammed the Home Office in response to the report
Labour MP and chair of the Public Accounts Committee Meg Hillier slammed the Home Office in response to the report. Picture: PA Images

Despite "years of public and political debate and concern", the department still does not know the size of the illegal population in the UK, the report said.

The committee reiterated criticism previously raised by the National Audit Office about the department not estimating the illegal population in the UK since 2005.

The latest report said the Home Office had "no answer" to concerns that "potentially exaggerated figures calculated by others could inflame hostility towards immigrants".

The department does not know whether hostile environment policies have deterred illegal migration, it added.

A lack of evidence and "significant" lack of diversity at senior levels has created "blind spots" in the organisation, the report said, describing the Windrush scandal as demonstrating the "damage such a culture creates".

The department also does not know why so many migrants were released from detention because they could not deport them as planned last year, the report said.

It also warned the Home Office was "unprepared for the challenges the UK's exit from the EU presents to its immigration enforcement operations", adding that the department had been unable to provide evidence, when asked in July, that it had begun discussions with EU counterparts on international operations.

The committee said it was not convinced the department is "sufficiently prepared" to properly safeguard the existing, legal immigrant population in the UK, while also implementing a new immigration system and responding to the Covid-19 pandemic.

The scathing report claims the Home Office and Home Secretary Priti Patel could not provide any evidence about preparedness for leaving the EU
The scathing report claims the Home Office and Home Secretary Priti Patel could not provide any evidence about preparedness for leaving the EU. Picture: PA Images

It gave the Home Office six months to come up with a detailed plan to make sure its decision-making is led by data and evidence so it can analyse its work, particularly with regard to tackling illegal migration.

Minnie Rahman, campaigns and public affairs manager for the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants, said the report paints a "very accurate picture of a clueless, careless and cold-hearted Home Office.

"It is but the latest in a slew of reports to slam the Home Office's working culture and practices."

The charity echoed the committee's calls for change, adding: "Immigration policy and practice must be based on robust evidence, proper staff training and a new culture of respect and care for individuals."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Exclusive
Denis Kopanev, 33, from London, was due to meet his friend Diego in São Paulo on Tuesday but vanished from his Airbnb

‘There’s something very odd about it’: Friends of British tourist missing in Brazil say he was ‘in good spirits’ as they fear he’s been kidnapped

A large police presence met protesters in Portadown town center this evening after a leaflet was shared on social media calling all residents of the Co.Armagh town to march on the homes of so-called Migrant gangs

Petrol bombs thrown at police during fifth night of Northern Ireland disorder

Turin, Italy. 2nd Feb, 2025. The FIFA Club World Cup trophy made by Tiffany on display at half time of the Serie A match at Allianz Stadium, Turin. Picture credit should read: Jonathan Moscrop/Sportimage Credit: Sportimage Ltd/Alamy Live News

2025 Fifa World Club Cup: How to watch as US tournament begins

A poll of 2,000 parents of school-aged children in the UK suggests around one in six (17%) parents rated the toilets at their child’s school as unclean.

'Like a horror movie': One in 10 parents say children avoid school over 'filthy' toilets

On Saturday evening, the annual silent walk will take place in west London to mark eight years since the blaze, followed by the reading of the names of the 72 dead, and speeches by campaigners.

Grenfell community gathers for final anniversary before tower demolition begins

Lord Victor Adebowale, chair of the NHS Confederation, who has slammed racial inequalities in the health service.

‘Black service, not NHS service’: Health leader condemns racial inequalities that failed mother

Kylie Minogue has cancelled a string of upcoming shows.

Kylie Minogue cancels string of upcoming shows as pop icon shares health update

Emma Webber, the mother of Barnaby Webber (left) and Dr Sanjoy Kumar, the father of Grace O'Malley Kumar during a memorial walk to lay flowers in Nottingham, to mark the second anniversary of their murders.

'Cover-ups' and 'mistruths' surrounding care of Nottingham attack killer, Barnaby Webber's mother claims

David Beckham has been awarded a knighthood in the King's Birthday Honours.

David Beckham receives knighthood as Strictly hosts and Luke Littler made MBEs in King's Birthday Honours

A protest against proposals for a new Chinese embassy will take place from 2pm at Royal Mint Court, near the capital’s financial district, while pro-Palestinian demonstrators are expected to gather in Parliament Square at the same time.

Demonstrators set to gather for multiple protests against Chinese Embassy and Gaza conflict in London on Saturday

he Prime Minister has said he has “grave concerns” about Iran’s nuclear programme as he backed Israel ’s right to self defence.

Keir Starmer voices 'grave concerns' over Iran’s nuclear programme in call with Donald Trump

Rapper O hAnnaidh, who performs under the name Mo Chara, will be represented by a team that includes Gareth Peirce, solicitor for WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange during his fight against US extradition, and Rosalind Comyn.

'We are ready for this fight': Kneecap’s legal team for court battle to include Julian Assange lawyer

Israeli Iron Dome air defense system fires to intercept missiles over Tel Aviv, Israel, Friday, June 13, 2025.

Iranian missiles hospitalise scores of Israelis as Tel Aviv bombarded by waves of retaliatory strikes

British Prime Minister Keir Starmer, left, and Health Secretary, Wes Streeting, visit to the University College London Hospital (UCLH).

NHS to slash waiting lists by sending patients straight to GPs for treatment

Exclusive
Lottie Tomlinson has shared her experience of grief with LBC in hopes to encourage others to open up and seek support.

‘My grief has been a long journey of healing’ - Louis Tomlinson’s sister shares heartbreaking experience with LBC

Former GB News presenter Laurence Fox at Woolwich Crown Court in London.

Laurence Fox faces trial in 2026 accused of encouraging Ulez camera destruction