Surgeon 'catches' cancer after operating on patient in first-of-its-kind case

3 January 2025, 10:37 | Updated: 3 January 2025, 11:56

According to the case report the doctor's body likely did not mount an appropriate response to the tumor cells 'transplanted' from the patient's body
According to the case report the doctor's body likely did not mount an appropriate response to the tumor cells 'transplanted' from the patient's body. Picture: Alamy

By Charlie Duffield

A surgeon has been diagnosed with cancer after operating on a 32-year-old man from Germany who was diagnosed with a rare form of the disease.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The surgeon is thought to have 'caught' the cancer during surgery to remove the tumour from the patients abdomen.

While in surgery, the doctor cut his hand accidentally, with the wound cleaned and bandaged immediately by fellow medics.

However, five months later, the 53-year-old surgeon discovered a small lump at the incision site where he had injured himself and sought medical advice.

Professionals diagnosed the surgeon with a malignant tumour and tests showed it was genetically identical to the cancer suffered by his former patient.

The medical team concluded that he had caught the cancer when tumour cells entered the cut on his hand - in what is believed to be the first case of it's kind.

Read More: Sara Sharif’s dad 'has neck sliced open with tuna can lid in prison attack' as he is 'ambushed by inmates'

Read More: Major Grenfell study reveals one in four firefighters suffering life-changing health conditions

The surgeon operated on the man's abdomen to remove his tumour
The surgeon operated on the man's abdomen to remove his tumour. Picture: Alamy

Typically, in a traditional transplant, the body delivers an immune response and rejects any foreign tissue.

But due to the tumour's development, and growth, it suggests the surgeon's body had an "ineffective antitumour immune response."

The case was first reported in 1996, but has resurfaced with renewed interest in recent days.

Published in The New England Journal of Medicine, doctors wrote about the "accidental transplantation" of the patient's malignant fibrous histiocytoma - which is a rare type of cancer that forms in soft tissue with just 1,400 diagnoses per year. 

The doctor injured the palm of his left hand when trying to place a drain in his patient, as he was surgically removed the cancer from the patient's abdomen.

The wound was immediately disinfected and bandaged.

While the cancer patient's initial surgery was successful, he died following complications after the procedure. 

After five months, there was a hard 1.2 inch swelling which looked like a tumour at the bottom of the doctor's left middle finger.

While the cancer patient's initial surgery was successful, he died following complications after the procedure
While the cancer patient's initial surgery was successful, he died following complications after the procedure. Picture: Alamy

He went to see a hand specialist and had an "extensive" exam which included several laboratory and blood tests, although there were no abnormal discoveries.

The tumour was taken out and the mass was examined under a microscope, which revealed it was also a malignant fibrous histiocytoma.

The physician who had been treating both the cancer patient and the surgeon questioned whether the tumours were linked.

Samples of both tumours were further analyzed and were determined to be "identical".

They both had the same types of cells and arrangement of those cells.

The authors wrote: "Normally, transplantation of allogeneic tissue from one person to another induces an immune response that leads to the rejection of the transplanted tissue.

"In the case of the surgeon, an intense inflammatory reaction developed in the tissue surrounding the tumour, but the tumour mass increased, suggesting an ineffective antitumor immune response."

The authors thought the tumour "escaped immunologic destruction through several mechanisms," included alteration to molecules in its cells, and a failure in the surgeon's body to recognise and attack tumour cells effectively.

Two years after the surgeon had his own tumour removed, there were no signs the cancer had spread or returned.

Doctors were particularly interested by the case because transplanted tissue is different from host tissue and is typically targeted by the host's immune system in an attempt to destroy it.

This is why organ recipients must take immunosuppressive drugs to make sure their body does not reject the transplanted organ.

Cases like the surgeon's are extremely rare and there are no statistics on 'transplanted' cancer. 

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Rust is "haunted by death and scandal", critics have said as the Alec Baldwin movie is released

Alec Baldwin movie Rust 'haunted' by cinematographer shooting, critics say

Exclusive
Lord Hogan-Howe slammed the IOPC decision as 'awful'

Ex Met chief Lord Hogan-Howe slams 'awful' gross misconduct probe into officer who shot dead Chris Kaba

People have a swim on a pond in Hampstead Heath park to cool off from the heat.

Hampstead Ladies pond lets trans women enter as feminists vow to 'reclaim' bathing spot

Exclusive
The car ened up in a ditch in France

Police Charity road trip scuppered after officers spin in oil and crash into a ditch

Chris Eubank Jr (right) in action against Conor Benn (left). Eubank jr says he underwent eye surgery

Chris Eubank Jr says he needed eye surgery after ‘headbutt’ in Conor Benn fight

A Russian drone strike overnight killed at least two people and wounded 15 others in a residential area of Odesa

Russia launches deadly drone strike on Ukraine hours after Kyiv signs minerals deal with US

Baller League UK - Match Day Two - VIP's

Maya Jama finally confirms romance with Ruben Dias after months of speculation

The boy got into difficulty while swimming at  Colwick Country Park

Body recovered after boy, 16 went missing while swimming in lake at country park

Exclusive
Locals to the Calton area are claiming it's also fuelled an 'out of control' situation with needles left in their streets.

Furious residents near UK's first drug consumption room rally over 'needle nightmare'

One of Britain's most iconic breweries is closing.

One of UK's most-iconic breweries to close its doors after than 40 years as owner issues heartbreaking statement

Jade Damarell, 32,

Probe launched after veteran skydiver dies during jump - with concerns of 'deliberate act'

Simon Patterson arrives to the Latrobe Valley Magistrates Court in Morwell, Victoria

Man 'still cares' for ex-wife accused of killing his parents with deadly Beef Wellington, trial hears

Exclusive
Organised criminal gangs are smuggling tonnes of ‘killer meat’ into the UK in bin bags – stashing it in cars and coach luggage compartments without refrigeration for days.

Gangs smuggling tonnes of ‘killer meat’ into UK in bin bags - as LBC told risk of ‘explosive’ disease at ‘all-time high’

Lamine Yamal plays during the match between FC Barcelona and Football Club Internazionale Milano

Lamine Yamal shines as Barcelona and Inter Milan draw 3-3 in Champions League semi-final classic

Exclusive
Chris Kaba

Chris Kaba cop colleague warns 'public safety at risk' over gross misconduct hearing decision

J.K. Rowling

Harry Potter stars take swipe at JK Rowling as they sign open letter supporting trans people