Labour-era hires to senior civil service positions to be investigated, as government denies 'cronyism' claims

30 August 2024, 20:47

Keir Starmer
Keir Starmer. Picture: Getty

By Kit Heren

Several Labour appointments to senior civil service positions are to be investigated, with the Conservatives claiming the government is operating under a "culture of cronyism".

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Investigators within the civil service itself will probe the appointments. Labour have denied any wrongdoing.

Kate Owen, who runs the civil service commission, wrote to the heads of human resources at government departments on Friday to ask for information about appointments "by exception" to the ordinary recruitment principles.

She said that the review would form the basis of "a short, independent review" of new recruits.

Recent appointments to the senior civil service include Jess Sargeant, who previously worked for the Labour Together think tank before she took a role in the Cabinet Office, and Emily Middleton, a consultant who was named a director general in the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology, and appears to have worked closely with Science and Technology Secretary Peter Kyle in the months before the election.

Ian Corfield, who has donated more than £20,000 to Labour politicians in the last decade, was made a temporary director of investment at the Treasury but it has since emerged he would work as an unpaid adviser rather than a salaried civil servant.

Read more: Jacqui Smith dismisses compulsory four-day working week claims, insisting Labour's plans 'won't apply to everybody'

Read more: Nick Ferrari puts Cabinet Office Minister on the spot over who gave Downing Street pass to Labour donor

Nick Ferrari presses Ellie Reeves on Lord Alli's pass

Ms Owen has asked HR directors to provide her with information about all appointments made during July and August which did not need oversight from her Commission, ahead of a "short report".

She also wrote to heads of departments in a separate letter which read: "Given interest in a number of recent civil service appointments by exception and the importance of public trust in these appointments, the Commission has decided to undertake a short review of appointments by exception at delegated grades since July 1 2024 and the departmental processes in place to make such appointments under the recruitment principles."

Ms Owen began her correspondence with a reference to the law on civil service appointments, in particular that recruitment "takes place 'on merit on the basis of fair and open competition'".

There are some exceptions to the rule, according to the Civil Service Commission.

These include temporary appointments, secondments from outside the civil service of up to two years, and "highly specialist skills".

A Cabinet Office spokesperson said: "All civil service appointments must follow the correct rules and processes. The Civil Service Commission is independent of Government and is able to conduct regular reviews of recruitment processes, in line with their powers as set out in the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010.

"We will fully support the Commission with their review."

Prime Minister Keir Starmer
Prime Minister Keir Starmer. Picture: Alamy

Conservative MP John Glen, shadow paymaster general, said: “I welcome that the commission has backed our calls for a review into Labour’s crony appointments.

"As the first step, we need full transparency from the government on every 'exceptional' appointment they have made since the general election.

"Keir Starmer can no longer try to brush this under the carpet."

Starmer has faced questions about cronyism after Lord Alli was given a pass to Number 10 Downing Street, despite not having a formal job there.

John Glen, the Conservatives' Shadow Paymaster General, welcomed news of the investigation
John Glen, the Conservatives' Shadow Paymaster General, welcomed news of the investigation. Picture: Alamy

He said on Tuesday: "Look, if you take Lord Alli, he's a long-term donor and contributor to the Labour Party.

"He was doing some transition work with us, he had a pass for a short-term time to do that work, and the work finished, and he hasn't got a pass. That's the state of affairs."

The Prime Minister added: "I am absolutely determined to restore honesty and integrity to Government, because I think that is core to ensuring that people appreciate that politics can be a force for good."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

The demonstration made its way to popular tourist spot, Weyler Square

'Without fear there is no change': furious protesters to target holidaying Brits at airports and hotspots in these countries

Ioan Gruffudd and Bianca Wallace have tied the knot

Titanic and Marvel star Ioan Gruffudd marries partner Bianca Wallace in intimate ceremony

Mummy Pig revealed the gender of her baby.

Mummy Pig's having a...! Peppa Pig's mother announces new piglet's gender at iconic London spot

CBB announced its winner

Celebrity Big Brother announces winner of latest series

Rupert Murdoch

Rupert Murdoch's company accused of 'actively undermining' Met's phone-hacking investigation

Paul Butler, who killed his estranged wife in a 'frenzied' and 'brutal' attack, has been served a minimum term of 27 years for the murder of Plymouth university lecturer Claire Chick.

'Evil' man who killed Plymouth university lecturer in 'brutal' jealousy-fuelled attack jailed for 27 years

Visitors and mourners pay their respects to the body of Pope Francis

How Pope Francis's funeral will unfold

Luigi Mangione appears at a hearing for the murder of UHC CEO Brian Thompson at Manhattan Criminal Court on February 21, 2025 in New York City.

Luigi Mangione pleads not guilty to federal murder charge over CEO killing as US pushes for death penalty

President Donald Trump and first lady Melania Trump arrive on Air Force One at Rome's Leonardo da Vinci International airport

World leaders arrive for Pope’s funeral as 150,000 mourners pay respects

Moscow says Vladimir Putin has had 'constructive' talks with Donald Trump's envoy at the Kremlin.

Trump envoy holds ‘constructive’ talks with Putin hours after top Russian general killed in Moscow car bomb

Displaced Palestinians crowd with outstretched hands and containers to receive hot meals distributed by aid organizations at the Jabalia Refugee Camp in northern Gaza City, Gaza on April 24, 2025.

UN runs out of food aid in Gaza as Israel continues total blockade, ending 'critical lifeline' for hundreds of thousands

Christina Howell was handed a hospital order under the Mental Health Act, after previously admitting manslaughter by reason of diminished responsibility

Woman killed man in unprovoked racist attack after asking to be sent back to hospital

A huge mountain of rubbish bags and other waste block rows of terraced housing on Primrose Avenue in the Sparkbrook area of Birmingham as refuse workers continue to strike, 15th April, 2025.

Warning issued as Birmingham resident had to be given oxygen after burning recycling inside home amid bin strike

Laurence Fox arrived at court wearing grey jeans, a light blue shirt and a black cap

Laurence Fox pleads not guilty to sharing upskirting photo of TV star Narinder Kaur

Forensic investigators at Milton Keynes train station after a man was shot dead by armed police officers.

Man shot dead by police at point-blank range ‘called 999 himself’, watchdog reveals

A row has erupted amongst scholars over a 'well-endowed warrior' depicted in the Bayeux Tapestry.

Scholarly row erupts over ‘well-endowed warrior’ on Bayeux Tapestry