Trump 'would have been convicted of trying to overturn 2020 election if he had lost 2024 vote'

14 January 2025, 07:53

Donald Trump
Donald Trump. Picture: Alamy

By Kit Heren

Donald Trump would have been found guilty of trying to overturn the 2020 presidential election if he had not been re-elected in 2024, a US government report has found.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The president-elect took part in an "unprecedented" attempt to cling to power after his 2020 defeat to Biden, according to special prosecutor Jack Smith.

Mr Smith submitted a report to US Congress detailing his team's findings about Mr Trump's efforts to cling to power.

He said that Mr Trump inspired acts of violence in his supporters in the January 6 US Capitol riots, as well as knowingly spreading a false narrative about the election.

But efforts to prosecute Mr Trump were thwarted by his victory in 2024. The US Justice Department does not prosecute sitting presidents.

Read more: Greenland PM says ‘we are ready to talk’ as Trump refuses to rule out military invasion

Read more: 'Progress' made in Israel-Hamas ceasefire deal after Trump warned 'all hell will break loose' if hostages were not freed

Jack Smith
Jack Smith. Picture: Getty

"Indeed, but for Mr Trump's election and imminent return to the Presidency, the Office assessed that the admissible evidence was sufficient to obtain and sustain a conviction at trial," the report said.

District Judge Aileen Cannon, who was nominated to the bench by Mr Trump, had earlier temporarily blocked the department from releasing the entire report on Mr Smith's investigations into Mr Trump that led to two separate criminal cases.

Ms Cannon's latest order on Monday cleared the way for the release of the volume detailing Mr Smith's case that accused Mr Trump, a Republican, of conspiring to overturn his 2020 election loss to Joe Biden, a Democrat.

She set a hearing for Friday on whether the department can release a separate volume on the case that accused Mr Trump of hoarding classified documents at his Mar-a-Lago estate after he left the White House in 2021.

Donald Trump spared jail in historic hush money trial

The department has said it will not publicly disclose that volume as long as criminal proceedings against two of Mr Trump's co-defendants remain pending.

Ms Cannon dismissed the classified documents case in July, ruling that Mr Smith's appointment was illegal.

The Justice Department abandoned both cases after Mr Trump's presidential victory in November, citing department policy that prohibits the federal prosecutions of sitting presidents.

Mr Smith resigned his position on Friday after handing in his report to Attorney General Merrick Garland, the Justice Department revealed in a footnote in a court filing over the weekend.

Mr Trump's spokesman Steven Cheung said in a statement that it was "time for Joe Biden and Merrick Garland to do the right thing and put a final stop to the political weaponisation of our justice system".

Donald Trump
Donald Trump. Picture: Alamy

Monday's ruling could open the door for the public to learn additional details in the coming days about Mr Trump's frantic but ultimately failed effort to cling to power in the run-up to the deadly January 6 2021 insurrection at the Capitol.

But it could also lead to the classified documents volume being shelved long term, with the Justice Department under the Trump administration unlikely to make it public.

Lawyers for the Republican president-elect's two co-defendants, Mr Trump's valet Walt Nauta and Mar-a-Lago property manager Carlos De Oliveira, had argued that the release of the report would prejudice them given that criminal proceedings remain ongoing against them in the form of a Justice Department appeal against Ms Cannon's dismissal of charges.

As a compromise, the Justice Department said that it would not make that document public so long as those proceedings continue but would instead share it with select congressional officials for their private review.

Donald Trump
Donald Trump. Picture: Alamy

But Ms Cannon halted those plans and instead scheduled a hearing for Friday afternoon.

"Release of Volume II, even on a limited basis as promised by the United States, risks irreversibly and substantially impairing the legal rights of defendants in this criminal proceeding," Ms Cannon wrote.

"The Court is not willing to make that gamble on the basis of generalised interest by members of Congress, at least not without full briefing and a hearing on the subject," she added.

"Nor has the United States presented any justification to support the suggestion that Volume II must be released to Congress now, as opposed to after a reasonable period for an expedited hearing and judicial deliberation on the subject."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Row of terraced houses in residential Street, London, England, UK

Mortgage which lets first-time buyers put off repayments for first three months unveiled

Iconic Big Ben, nickname for the Great Clock of Westminster renamed Elizabeth Tower in 2012 to mark the Diamond Jubilee of Elizabeth II, is lit up to mark the 80th anniversary of Victory in Europe (VE) Day on May 6, 2025 in London, England.

Pictured: VE Day celebrations light up historic landmarks across Britain

An energy bill displayed on a mobile phone alongside a five pound note and loose change

Ofgem makes Good Energy pay out £150,000 to customers for billing failures

Franco Colapinto to replace Jack Doohan at Alpine for the next five races in Formula One calendar

Franco Colapinto to replace Jack Doohan at Alpine for next five races in Formula One calendar

Kim Hall

British 'drugs mule' tried to trick ICE into deporting her after £15m cocaine bust at US airport

Madeleine McCann (l) and suspect Christian  Brueckner (r), who has been cleared of unrelated sex crimes

Hard drive of Christian Brueckner's 'sick' pictures could reveal new piece in Madeleine McCann's disappearance

Download the new LBC app now!

LBC launches all-new app putting users fully in control to prioritise the news they want

Dozens dead after India launches missile strikes on Kashmir 'terror camps' - as Pakistan downs five jets in response

Fears of 'all out war': At least 19 dead after Indian missile strikes on 'terror camps' - as Pakistan 'downs jets'

Exclusive
Kelvin

‘Uneducated and unhappy’: How I fell down the Alt-Right pipeline and how Hitler's artwork helped me escape

A boy on his mobile phones In shool.

'Incel teens can't come back from brink,' campaigner warns as she backs phone ban in schools

Cardinal Vincent Nichols attends an interview at the Venerable English College, in Rome, Friday, May 2, 2025. (AP Photo/Alessandra Tarantino)

UK cardinal asks for prayer as conclave begins and world watches for new pope

Protestors block the road by Parliament Square, Westminster for the Extinction Rebellion demonstration

People more likely to empathise with groups than individuals, study finds

A UK-based spy ring passed secrets to Russia for nearly three years, endangering the national interest and putting "many lives at risk", a court has heard.

Six Bulgarian nationals facing years behind bars for part in Russian spy ring run from UK seaside guesthouse

Call the midwife SOS sages femmes Call the midwife Serie TV 2012 Real  Heidi Thomas Jessica Raine Bryony Hannah Helen George Judy Parfitt Cliff Parisi Collection Christophel © Laurence Cendrowicz / Neal Street Productions 2011

Call the Midwife producers announce film and prequel series in the works

Protestors hold placards as they demonstrate in front of members of the media outside of The Queen Elizabeth II Law Courts in Liverpool, north west England on January 23, 2025, ahead of the sentencing Southport attacker Axel Rudakubana

‘No proper answer’: Watchdog blasts police over handling of online misinformation amid Southport riots

Minimum age for train drivers to be lowered to 18 amid shortage

Minimum age for train drivers to be lowered to 18 in bid to tackle staff shortages and delays