Alex Batty’s mum & granddad won't face criminal charges after keeping Brit teen in commune for six years

22 January 2025, 12:52 | Updated: 22 January 2025, 13:03

The British boy, originally from Oldham, was 11 years old when he went missing while travelling with his family in Marbella, Spain, in October 2017.
The British boy, originally from Oldham, was 11 years old when he went missing while travelling with his family in Marbella, Spain, in October 2017. Picture: Alamy, Greater Manchester Police, PA

By Henry Moore

Alex Batty’s mum and granddad will not face criminal proceedings after taking the British teen from a holiday to an “off-the-grid” commune in 2017.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Alex, originally from Oldham, was 11 years old when he went missing while travelling with his family in Marbella, Spain, in October 2017.

He was with his mum Melanie Batty at the time, as well as his granddad, David.

They were not allowed to be with Alex due to "domestic difficulties".

His family took him to an “off-the-grid” commune in France, where he spent six years, before fleeing in 2023.

Read more: Everything we know about Alex Batty’s disappearance, his mother and why he fled 'spiritual community' in France

Alex was found in the Pyrenees in the south of France, picked up by a driver and taken to French authorities.
Alex was found in the Pyrenees in the south of France, picked up by a driver and taken to French authorities. . Picture: Greater Manchester Police

Police say they have “explored all possible lines of enquiry” but “there is insufficient grounds to move forward with any criminal prosecution.”

The decision not to pursue criminal proceedings applies to both Alex’s mum, Melanie, and his grandad David - who took him to the commune aged 11.

In a statement released on Thursday, Detective Superintendent Matt Walker, who led the investigation said; “Alex and his safety has been at the forefront of our minds and actions since he was found in Toulouse, France in 2023.

“In our commitment to protecting children, we felt it was important that the circumstances of Alex’s disappearance be properly and thoroughly investigated. I led a dedicated team to do exactly that when Alex was first found, and this has continued since.

Alex sent his grandmother, and legal guardian, Susan Caruana a message on Facebook: “Hello grandma it is me, Alex."
Alex sent his grandmother, and legal guardian, Susan Caruana a message on Facebook: “Hello grandma it is me, Alex.". Picture: Alamy
Melanie Batty became caught up with David's new lifestyle and she got involved with a cult.
Melanie Batty became caught up with David's new lifestyle and she got involved with a cult. . Picture: PA

Alex, now 17, re-emerged in 2023 when a delivery driver came across him in the Aude region of France.

He told the driver he had hiked for four days over the Pyrenees, having left his mother who he said wanted to go to Finland.

He has since been brought to the UK and is living with Susan Caruana, 68, his grandmother. He previously lived with her in Oldham, Greater Manchester.

Alex has said while he disagrees with his mum’s decision, he doesn't want her to be imprisoned.

Upon being found last year, he said: “I don’t think they should get in touch with the police because I don’t want them to go to jail.”

Kidnapping a child carries a maximum sentence of seven years in the UK.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Poland blames Russia for causing massive shopping centre fire in Warsaw last year

'We will get you all!': Poland blames Russia for causing massive shopping centre fire in Warsaw last year

The number of employers expecting to increase staff numbers in the next three months has fallen to a record low outside of the pandemic, new research suggests.

Number of employers expecting to hire staff in short term falls to record low, as 1 in 4 expecting to make redundancies

Child on woman's shoulders collecting shells on a beach on a rough day in the UK.

Applications open today for 30 hours government-funded childcare expansion

Wegovy...

Weight loss injections may have powerful anti-cancer effect, research suggests

International Nurses Day Marked In China

NHS programme to prevent brain injuries during childbirth to be rolled out

25 people have been injured at a pitch invasion at Volksparkstadion in Hamburg, Germany

25 football fans hospitalised - one with life-threatening injuries - after pitch invasion

'No motor vehicles' signs and a 'rain garden' mark a modal filter in the Oval to Stockwell 'low traffic neighbourhood' in Lambeth, South London.

London council earned £1m in fines from illegal low traffic zone in just six months

A child has sadly died after a minibus overturned on a motorway slip road in Berkshire

Tragedy as child dies after minibus overturns on motorway slip road

Toby Jones, Monica Dolan and Sir Alan Bates on stage with the Limited Drama Award for 'Mr Bates vs The Post Office'

Fight is 'not over yet', say writers of Mr Bates Vs The Post Office as gripping real-life drama wins Bafta

Varda Ben Baruch holds photos of her grandson Israeli- American hostage Edan Alexander as she walks near Israeli soldiers during a rally of families of hostages held in the Gaza Strip at Nir Oz.

Hamas announces release of American-Israeli hostage Edan Alexander in push for ceasefire

Among regular drinkers, intake decreased by 68%, from 23.2 units a week to 7.8 units a week.

Weight loss jabs could help cut amount of alcohol drank by obese people by two thirds, new study suggests

Alan Cumming is hosting the 2025 BAFTA TV awards

David Tennant, Jessie J and Billie Piper stun on Bafta red carpet

Exclusive
Regent's Canal at Mile End Lock

Man, 38, arrested on suspicion of assault in connection with 'body slamming' incidents along East London canal

Greater Anglia, British Rail Class Stadler 755 bi-modal multiple unit passenger train arriving at Ipswich railway station, Suffolk, England, UK

Lines blocked after train collides with car on level crossing

Donald Trump is urging Ukraine to agree to meet with Russia in Turkey next week for direct talks

Zelenskyy offers to meet Putin after Trump urges Ukraine to speak with Russia 'immediately' - in bid to end 'bloodbath'

Nottingham Forest owner Evangelos Marinakis stormed onto the pitch to confront manager Nuno Espirito Santo following a 2-2 draw with already-relegated Leicester.

Furious Nottingham Forest owner storms onto pitch to publicly berate manager Nuno as Reds’ European dream dented