Herd immunity Covid strategy a 'dangerous fallacy', researchers warn

15 October 2020, 00:43

Researchers have warned that herd immunity approaches are not support by science
Researchers have warned that herd immunity approaches are not support by science. Picture: PA
Nick Hardinges

By Nick Hardinges

Herd immunity coronavirus strategies are a "dangerous fallacy unsupported by the scientific evidence", a group of researchers have warned.

In an open letter signed by 80 international researchers and published by The Lancet, herd immunity strategies will not end the coronavirus pandemic.

Instead, the authors argued the approach would create recurring epidemics and that uncontrolled transmission in younger people would risk ill-health and death across a whole population.

They also argued that any strategy that is dependent on immunity from natural infections of Covid-19 is "flawed".

The group instead urged officials to suppress the virus until an effective vaccine becomes available.

It comes after Health Secretary Matt Hancock branded herd immunity without a vaccine as "flawed", telling MPs it was "simply not possible" to segregate the old and the vulnerable.

Read more: Cases surge but Boris resists calls for lockdown 'misery'

Read more: UK reports another 19,724 coronavirus cases and 137 deaths

"Herd immunity is a myth in the context of Covid"

The authors of the letter, referred to by its authors as the John Snow Memorandum, noted that lockdowns have harmed the economy and had a substantial impact on people's mental and physical health.

They added that this has led to "widespread demoralisation and diminishing trust" among communities.

The letter says: "The arrival of a second wave and the realisation of the challenges ahead has led to renewed interest in a so-called herd immunity approach, which suggests allowing a large uncontrolled outbreak in the low-risk population while protecting the vulnerable.

"Proponents suggest this would lead to the development of infection-acquired population immunity in the low-risk population, which will eventually protect the vulnerable.

"This is a dangerous fallacy unsupported by scientific evidence."

Read more: Sadiq Khan urges PM to grant support package for London

Read more: France declares state of emergency due to Covid-19

Health Secretary: Herd immunity is a flawed goal without a vaccine

The authors warn there is no evidence for lasting protective immunity after natural infection, and so the strategy could result in repeated waves of transmission over several years.

This would put vulnerable populations at risk for the "indefinite future", as it would not end the Covid-19 pandemic but result in recurrent epidemics, they add.

The researchers argue that defining who is vulnerable would be "complex", while prolonged isolation of large swathes of a population is "practically impossible and highly unethical".

Additionally, the authors say it is still not understood who might suffer from long Covid - when people experience symptoms months after infection.

"The evidence is very clear: controlling community spread of Covid-19 is the best way to protect our societies and economies until safe and effective vaccines and therapeutics arrive within the coming months," the letter concludes.

"We cannot afford distractions that undermine an effective response; it is essential that we act urgently based on the evidence."

Johnson explains why herd immunity wouldn't work

Speaking in the Commons on Tuesday, Mr Hancock criticised the so-called Great Barrington Declaration, which calls for lockdown measures to be relaxed and the adoption of a herd immunity approach.

Mr Hancock said: "It says that if enough people get Covid, we will reach herd immunity. This is not true.

"Many infectious diseases never reach herd immunity, like measles and malaria and Aids and flu, and with increasing evidence of reinfection, we should have no confidence that we would ever reach herd immunity to Covid, even if everyone caught it.

"Herd immunity is a flawed goal without a vaccine, even if we could get to it, which we can't."

Listen & subscribe: Global Player | Apple Podcasts | Google Podcasts | Spotify

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Mother of jailed Just Stop Oil campaigner complains daughter will miss brother's wedding after she blocked M25

Mother of jailed Just Stop Oil campaigner complains daughter will miss brother's wedding after she blocked M25

Breaking
Rene Graham was killed on Sunday July 21

Teen victim of west London park shooting named and pictured for the first time

Kamala Harris has praised Joe Biden

Kamala Harris pays tribute to 'unmatched' legacy of Joe Biden in first speech since he pulled out of election

Police said they attended the residence at Wexford Road, Coventry at around 12.15pm on Monday following an emergency 999 call

Woman in her 30s killed after being mauled by pet dog at home in Coventry

Secret Service boss Kimberly Cheatle denied claims she failed to provide Trump with adequate protection.

'We failed': Secret service boss brands Donald Trump shooting 'most significant failure in decades'

One of Britain's oldest cricket clubs bans players from hitting sixes after neighbours complain of damaged property

One of Britain's oldest cricket clubs bans players from hitting sixes after neighbours complain of damaged property

Anand Runwal jumped in front of the train to try to save his children

Pictured: Hero father who jumped in front of train to try to save his twin daughters, whose pushchair rolled onto tracks

The moment a sexual predator lured a 14-year-old schoolgirl to a guesthouse where he later raped her has been caught on camera.

Chilling footage captures sex predator luring schoolgirl, 14, to guesthouse before raping her after plying teen with alcohol

Migrants heading to Britain. Home Secretary Yvette cooper today revealed the scheme cost £700m and saw only four volunteers sent to Africa

Rwanda deportation scheme cost £700m and saw just four volunteers sent to Africa, Home Secretary reveals

Piccadilly line to partially close for 16 days in August causing major disruption for commuters and Arsenal fans

Piccadilly line to partially close for 16 days in August causing major disruption for commuters and Arsenal fans

Strictly pro dancer Janette Manrara breaks her silence following claims by former contestant Will Bayley

Strictly dancer Janette Manrara breaks silence following contestant's 'life-changing' injury claims

President of Croatia Zoran Milanović described the attack as a "savage unprecedented crime".

Several killed as gunman opens fire in Croatian care home

A boy was pronounced dead at the scene in Ladbroke Grove

Gunman 'jumped from bushes to assassinate 15-year-old boy' on 'family fun day' at west London park

Search for murdered Muriel McKay's remains called off by police after 'unsuccessful' farm dig

Search for murdered Muriel McKay's remains called off by police after 'unsuccessful' farm dig

Nuclear submariner Marcus Gauntlett is under investigation

Royal Navy sailor accused of stealing secrets from nuclear submarine after 'documents found on phone'

Alex Dancyg and Yagev Buchshtab died while being held in Gaza.

Israel confirms deaths of two hostages in Gaza ahead of ceasefire talks