Sir Keir Starmer refuses to answer whether Eddie Izzard would make Labour's all-women shortlist

24 October 2022, 10:06 | Updated: 24 October 2022, 11:06

Sir Keir was speaking in response to a question from Vicky in St Albans, who was concerned about women's sex-based rights
Sir Keir was speaking in response to a question from Vicky in St Albans, who was concerned about women's sex-based rights. Picture: LBC / Alamy

By Danielle DeWolfe

Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer has refused to answer whether he believes comedian-turned-prospective politician Eddie Izzard would make an all-women shortlist.

Speaking with Nick Ferrari as part of the leader’s Call Keir phone-in show, the shadow leader was pushed on whether he believed the comedian - who identifies as a transgender woman - would qualify for Labour's shortlist in light of recent comments by fellow labour politician Rosie Duffield.

“So Eddie Izzard could qualify in your opinion?” questioned Nick Ferrari after Sir Keir refused to give a definitive answer on the matter.

“I know Rosie Duffield’s position – my position is as I’ve set out,” said Starmer.

Adding: “I’m not going to discuss individual cases”

Izzard, 60, recently announced she plans to stand for Labour in the Sheffield Central constituency at the next General Election.

Call Keir: Could Eddie Izzard sit on a Labour all women's shortlist?

Read more: 'Never going to work': Keir slams Boris's comeback bid and says we must move on from 'chaotic circus' of Tory leadership

Watch in full: Call Keir - the Labour leader answers your questions

She also publicly announced two years ago her decision to use 'she/her' pronouns.

It comes as Labour is said to be dropping the controversial use of all-women shortlists to choose candidates for general elections following legal advice they would be “unlawful” because the majority of their MPs are female.

They will, however, continue to use the system for other elections it's believed.

Recent weeks have seen fellow Labour politician, Kent MP Rosie Duffield, declare she would sooner be arrested than call Eddie Izzard a woman.

When challenged on the subject of misgendering someone being labelled a hate crime, the 51-year-old said: "Is that a serious thing? Is that coming to Parliament any time soon? I hope not because you might as well arrest me now. I'm not calling Eddie Izzard a woman."

Sir Keir speaks with Nick Ferrari on Call Keir
Sir Keir speaks with Nick Ferrari on Call Keir. Picture: LBC

When questioned by Ferrari, the Labour leader continued: “For 99.9% of women, everything is a matter of biology – and I’m very, very supportive of that.”

The leader was speaking in response to a question from Vicky in St Albans, who was concerned about womens’ sex-based rights.

Sir Kier said: “We have been the part of equality for women for many, many years and many of the changes in the laws in relation to equality have been because of a labour government.

“Now more than 50% are women, there’s a legal opinion that says we cant use them anymore - and this is a worry more generally Vicky,” added Starmer.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Sir Tony Blair spoke at the SXSW festival in London and said Britain needs to embrace AI.

Tony Blair says Britain should have AI doctors and nurses as former PM claims it's 'absurd' not to do more in the NHS

Pipers at the statue to Robert The Bruce during a re-enactment to commemorate the 700th anniversary of the Battle Of Bannockburn.

Controversial trotting track development at historic Bannockburn battlefield site dismissed

Ukraine’s underwater explosion attack on Crimean Bridge caught on camera

Ukraine’s underwater explosion attack on Crimean Bridge caught on camera

Dutch PM Dick Schoof steps down and far-right leader Geert Wilders quits as Dutch government plunged into chaos

Dutch PM Dick Schoof steps down and far-right leader Geert Wilders quits as Dutch government plunged into chaos

Alzheimer’s disease is the most common cause of dementia

Six things you need to know about Alzheimers - as drug trials bring new hope

Police on duty outside Windsor Castle (file image)

Man in his 30s arrested after breaking into grounds at Windsor Castle

Erin Patterson has admitted feeding poison mushrooms to her relatives

'Toxic mushroom' mum Erin Patterson admits feeding death caps to her relatives but denies murder

Will I am, LeAnn Rimes, Tom Jones, Danny Jones, and Tom Fletcher as judges on The Voice UK last year.

The Voice UK coaching line-up revealed with US star replacing country singer LeAnn Rimes

(L-R) Phineas Float, Jonathan Collyer and Lisa Stocker sit inside a court room for their trial at the Denpasar district court, in Denpasar, Bali, Indonesia, 03 June 2025.

Three Brits face death penalty for 'smuggling nearly 1kg of cocaine in Angel Delight sachets' into Bali

DJ Próvaí of Kneecap performs during Wide Awake Festival at Brockwell Park on May 23, 2025

Kneecap announce ‘biggest headline show outside of Ireland’ at London arena

The Red Cross said its hospital received 179 casualties - 21 of whom were dead.

United Nations calls for investigation into killings near Gaza aid distribution site after IDF denied responsibility

Afghan nationals Shah Salim Sajjadi, 38, and Safiollah Mohammadi, 25, were arrested after the vessel arrived into UK waters

French police pulled dead woman and child off migrant boat and let people smugglers carry on to UK

EuroMillions tickets and a pen

Biggest-ever £199,000,000 EuroMillions jackpot up for grabs tonight

At least 69 people have been injured in the earthquake, with one child, 14, dead.

Powerful 5.8-magnitude earthquake hits Turkey and Greece as tourists wake to 'whole building shaking' as teen dies

The farmhouse where police have been searching for Madeleine McCann

Live updates: Police drain a well in search for Madeleine McCann

Keir Starmer Puts UK On War-fighting Readiness In Defence Review

Britain 'to commit to spending 3.5 per cent of GDP on defence' within the next decade as NATO hike targets