'Why does it cost ten times more to build high speed rail in this country than it does in France?'

2 October 2023, 08:27 | Updated: 2 October 2023, 08:37

Jeremy Hunt said he wants answers over the soaring costs involved in HS2
Jeremy Hunt said he wants answers over the soaring costs involved in HS2. Picture: LBC/Alamy

By Asher McShane

The Chancellor has told LBC that he "needs to have an answer" as to why it costs up to ten times more to build high speed rail in the UK than it does in France.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Speaking to Nick Ferrari from the Conservative Party conference, Jeremy Hunt said: "I can’t tell you what’s going to happen on HS2.

"What I can say is I need to have an answer as to why it costs ten times more to build high speed rail in this country than it does across the channel in France.

"We need good economic infrastructure.

"Some of that spend you’ve been talking about [on PR costs] is totally unacceptable.

Read more: Hunt vows to 'make work pay' announcing benefits reforms and boost to National Living Wage

Read more: Rishi Sunak resists calls for lower taxes, as he says slashing inflation is the best tax cut

There are questions over whether HS2 will ever reach Manchester
There are questions over whether HS2 will ever reach Manchester. Picture: Alamy

"I’m going to be talking about how I’m going to spend all taxpayers’ money more efficiently."

It comes after the PM was forced to deny that UK had become a "laughing stock" as he failed to announce a decision on whether HS2 will ever reach Manchester as he visited the city for the Tory party conference.

The Prime Minister on Sunday "completely" rejected the allegation from critics, which include leaders across the North as well as predecessors at the top of the Conservatives.

Theresa May is the latest former premier to urge Mr Sunak not to ditch the Birmingham to Manchester leg of the high-speed rail project that was designed to link the North and London.

A drastic cost-cutting exercise could also see it end at Old Oak Common in the capital's western suburbs rather than reach its centre.

But the Prime Minister has refused to make clear what his plans are, instead relying on his get-out of not commenting on "speculation".

Andy Street, the Tory mayor of the West Midlands, is among the critics of scaling back the project, while London mayor Sadiq Khan warned it could make the UK a "laughing stock".

But Mr Sunak told the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg programme: "I'd completely reject that."

He insisted the business leaders he speaks to around the world are "excited about the opportunity that investing in Britain offers".

Mr Sunak was being interviewed in Salford as ministers and Tory members congregate in Manchester's centre for their annual conference, where the party slogan is "Long term decisions for a brighter future".

Levelling Up Secretary Michael Gove described HS2 as an "important project" but he said "we do need to look at value for money".

"The costs of this project have been significantly greater than originally estimated," he told Sky's Sunday Morning With Trevor Phillips.

He also stressed that transport links in the North need to be improved between and within cities, as critics say axing the full HS2 project would jeopardise the levelling up project.

Conservative Tees Valley mayor Ben Houchen told a Tory conference fringe event that the "indecision" on HS2 was causing a "distraction" as he urged ministers to commit to Northern Powerhouse Rail.

Former business secretary Sir Jacob Rees-Mogg urged the Prime Minister to cancel the post-Birmingham route and instead put the money towards tax cuts.

"Let's cut HS2, save the money on HS2, give that back to people just as a starter," he told Channel 4 News.

He added: "There is a real opportunity to cut taxes."

Transport Secretary Mark Harper refused to be drawn on the Government's plans for the line during his own appearance at a conference fringe event.

"It is not my job to be a commentator of these things," the Transport Secretary said.

"If Government has things to say about this, it will say them in due course in the usual way. But we are getting on with the project."

Rather than the multibillion-pound rail plans, Mr Sunak was keen to discuss his plans to combat what he terms as a "war on motorists".

Stronger guidance on 20mph speed limits and action on low traffic neighbourhoods are expected to be detailed by Transport Secretary Mark Harper in his conference speech on Monday.

But the Prime Minister suggested that councils could still introduce 20mph zones as long as they have local "consent".

"What they (councils) should be allowed to do in all cases is act in accordance with the government guidance," he added to the BBC.

But Welsh Secretary David TC Davies told the party's conference in Manchester on Sunday: "We call on Labour to end its absurd 20 mile-an-hour blanket speed limit on Welsh roads."

Following Boris Johnson and David Cameron in warning against abandoning the Manchester leg of HS2, Mrs May said it is key to giving more rail capacity on the west coast line.

She told the Henley Literary Festival that terminating the line in the west London suburbs would impact her constituents in Maidenhead, Berkshire.

"If HS2 stops at Old Oak Common, it is going to make our railway journeys into London longer and disrupted potentially over the period that Old Oak Common's building is being done to enable it to take that end point," she added.

"So I am arguing with Government: 'Don't stop at Old Oak Common. You need to take it into Euston because my constituents will be disadvantaged if you don't'."

Announced by the last Labour government but then backed by successive Tory administrations, HS2 was given a £55.7 billion budget in 2015 for its route from London to Birmingham with a Y-shaped section to Manchester and Leeds.

But it is feared that costs have breached the £100 billion mark, even with the Government having cancelled the Leeds leg in 2021.

Mr Johnson used his Daily Mail column to argue that the Government would be "betraying the north of the country and the whole agenda of levelling up" if HS2 to Manchester is delayed or cut.

And he argued that the southern terminal being Old Oak Common instead of Euston London would leave HS2 as a "white elephant".

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Christian Horner has been cleared of inappropriate behaviour

Geri Halliwell 'relieved and elated' after F1 boss husband Christian Horner is cleared after Red Bull investigation

Dame Esther said she was "disappointed" at no clear call for a vote on assisted dying

‘The law is a mess’: Dame Esther Rantzen issues fresh call for free vote on assisted dying

Canada Gaza Strip Aid

Canada says it is working to deliver aid to the Gaza Strip as soon as possible

Mark Feehily announced he's temporarily stepping away from the band amid health struggles.

Westlife star Mark Feehily reveals he’s standing down from the band just days before US tour leaving fans devastated

The Duke of Sussex took legal action against the Home Office over a decision in 2020 to change the level of his personal security

Prince Harry faces £1m bill after losing High Court challenge over taxpayer funded police protection

Rishi Sunak has warned 'mob rule' is threatening to 'replace democratic rule'.

End descent into ‘mob rule’ and shut down intimidating protests, Rishi Sunak tells police amid threats to MPs


President Joe Biden declared ‘fit for duty’ after annual medical test

Thomas Kingston died aged 45.

Lady Gabriella Windsor's husband Thomas Kingston 'died at his parents' £3m country mansion'


Supreme Court to rule if Trump can be prosecuted in election interference case

Richard Lewis has died aged 76.

Curb Your Enthusiasm star Richard Lewis dies aged 76 after suffering heart attack

Obit Richard Lewis

Richard Lewis, humorously morose star of Curb Your Enthusiasm, dies aged 76

Robert Brown's lost his bid for parole.

BA pilot Robert Brown who bludgeoned wife to death with claw hammer loses bid for early prison release

Film Oscars-Guide

Everything you need to know about this year’s Oscars ceremony

It is understood that RedBird IMI is offering to help pay the £1.16 billion in debts that the current owners, the Barclay family, owe to Lloyds Bank.

Foreign governments must be banned from owning British newspapers, says former Tory cabinet minister

Creech was due to be taken to the execution chamber where he would be strapped down onto a medical table.

Death row execution abandoned after officials 'unable' to give lethal injection - with inmate's death warrant to expire

Mexico volcano

Flights cancelled as Mexico’s Popocatepetl volcano erupts