Police overwhelmed by digital forensics as 25,000 devices await checks

1 December 2022, 07:06 | Updated: 1 December 2022, 07:11

25,000 devices await checks
25,000 devices await checks. Picture: Alamy

By Emma Soteriou

Police are overwhelmed and ineffective when it comes to digital forensics - with a backlog of more than 25,000 devices waiting to be examined, inspectors have found.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

A report, by His Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary and Fire & Rescue Services (HMICFRS), looked at how effective the police are at capturing evidence from digital devices, including smartphones and computers.

It concluded that some forces are overwhelmed and do not have a clear understanding of what digital forensics are.

Inspectors found that it had led to huge delays in examining electronic devices, with knock-on effects on the prosecutions of offenders and the well-being of victims.

Read more: Prisons packed as overcrowding forces Govt to ask police to borrow their cells

Read more: Police stations closing at the rate of one per week, LBC reveals

There has been huge delays in examining electronic devices,
There has been huge delays in examining electronic devices,. Picture: Alamy

His Majesty's Inspector of Constabulary Matt Parr said there was an "enormous gulf" in performance between police forces.

"The rapid emergence of a digital society has created a huge opportunity for police to gather new types of evidence and identify criminals. But in our inspection, we didn't see enough examples of policing making effective and efficient use of digital forensics," he said.

"Many forces didn't have a sufficient level of understanding of the work involved to recover evidence from mobile phones. Delays, lack of resources and lack of adequate training means some victims are being let down and officers are missing their chance to bring offenders to justice.

"During our inspection we found more than 25,000 devices waiting to be examined, and this doesn't take into account all the devices already in the system.

"Some forces are showing promise, and we did see examples of good practice. But we found little evidence of this good practice being more widely shared and adopted by others.

"There is an enormous gulf in performance that cannot continue - it is unacceptable that victims in some force areas receive a significantly better service than others.

"The demand in digital crime will only continue to grow, so police leaders need to work with the Home Office and Crown Prosecution Service to tackle this immediately. Our report makes nine recommendations to address these issues.

"It is clear from our inspection that victims cannot afford to wait any longer for police to start taking this more seriously."

As a result, HMICFRS made a series of recommendations to improve digital forensics, including appointing a national digital forensics policing lead, increasing the number of dedicated, competent and trained digital media investigators, and a Home Office review into the digital forensics budget.

His Majesty&squot;s Inspector of Constabulary Matt Parr said there was an "enormous gulf" in performance between police forces.
His Majesty's Inspector of Constabulary Matt Parr said there was an "enormous gulf" in performance between police forces. Picture: Alamy

The National Police Chiefs' Council (NPCC) lead for digital forensics, Deputy Chief Constable Paul Gibson welcomed the report's findings.

"Today, virtually every crime has a digital element, often involving vast amounts of complex data," he said.

"This presents policing with a serious challenge. We recognise this, and the need to do more, and are taking action.

"The NPCC published the Digital Forensic Science Strategy in July 2020, laying out a road map for improving the provision and use of digital forensics across law enforcement. In line with this, a range of activity is under way.

"For example, we are trialling the use of automation in cases relating to child sexual exploitation, in order to free up capacity within digital forensics units to focus on other crimes and tackle backlogs.

"In one force that has trialled this initiative, cases were processed 55% faster on average, with 9.5 hours per case being saved.

"Through Operation Soteria, part of the Government's response to the 2020 Rape Review, we are improving how every element of rape is dealt with.

"As part of this, we have delivered a range of mobile frontline digital forensic tools to enable forces to take technology to victims of rape.

"This includes a £5 million roll-out of mobile digital forensic vans and specialist digital equipment, with further investment supported by the Home Office this year.

"This initiative means we can provide a more sensitive service to victims, give investigators faster and more proportionate access to the right digital evidence and enable them to return devices more quickly."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Mark Logan has said he is backing Labour at the General Election.

'We need a new Government': Former Conservative MP Mark Logan defects to Labour

The gang have been jailed for 25 years

Bulgarian gang behind Britain's biggest £54million benefit fraud jailed for 25 years

Two arrests have been made in conntection with the robbery

Two arrested over raid at Richmond jewellers day before robbery victim found dead

Former US president Donald Trump arrives at Manhattan Criminal Court during jury deliberations in his criminal hush money trial in New York

Trump trial jury resumes deliberations after rehearing instructions and evidence

The Prime Minister was quizzed by a worker during a visit to a factory in Milton Keynes

Rishi Sunak challenged over Partygate by factory worker whose mother died during pandemic

US Secretary of State Antony Blinken speaks at a Czech Defence Capabilities Event at Prague-Kbely Airport in Prague

Blinken condemns ‘poison’ of Russian misinformation

The judge looked stunned as the defendant appeared before the virtual court room

Judge left dumbfounded as man with suspended licence appears in US court - from behind wheel of car

Andrew Marr's Election Diary: After the first week of election campaigning, writes Andrew Marr

Andrew Marr's Election Diary: After the first week of election campaigning, have we learned anything?

Pressure signals could be used to locate the missing plane

MH370 breakthrough as investigators plan to use sea explosions to solve mystery of aircraft's location

More than eight police forces in England have experienced a decline in total officer numbers compared to May 2010.

A quarter of England's police forces have fewer officers now than when Tories came into power, LBC analysis reveals

French President Emmanuel Macron and US President Joe Biden

Biden to make first state visit to France after attending D-Day commemorations

Fiona Beal, 50, from Northampton, stabbed Nicholas Billingham, 42, to death between October and November 2021

Teacher who murdered boyfriend and buried him in garden jailed for at least 20 years

Heath Ledger in the Dark Knight, 2008

Man who ‘identifies’ as The Joker from Batman accused of trying to kill ex-girlfriend who he called 'his Harley Quinn'

Soldiers help inter the remains of recently identified Greek soldiers who were killed in Cyprus in 1974s

Families reclaim remains of 15 Greek soldiers killed in Cyprus in 1974

Angela Rayner has defended Diane Abbott amid an ongoing row over the MP's future

'No reason' why Diane Abbott can't stand in general election as Labour MP, says Angela Rayner

Richard Tice has called for a police crackdown on ‘cash only’ barber shops

'Barber shops are fronts for money laundering drug money' claims Reform UK leader Richard Tice after LBC question