Rishi Sunak faces fresh blow over Rwanda as European judge claims plan is unlawful

25 January 2024, 16:05 | Updated: 25 January 2024, 16:18

Rishi Sunak has been warned he will be breaking European human rights law if he ignores emergency court orders
Rishi Sunak has been warned he will be breaking European human rights law if he ignores emergency court orders. Picture: Alamy/Getty

By Emma Soteriou

Rishi Sunak has faced a further blow over his Rwanda plan after a European judge said the scheme would breach international law.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Siofra O'Leary, the Strasbourg court's president, warned the UK would be in breach of legal obligations if it does not comply with so-called Rule 39 interim measures.

The measure - branded a "pyjama injunction" by critics as it can be issued outside normal court hours - was behind the grounding of the first flight to Rwanda in June 2022.

But the PM has repeatedly vowed not to let "foreign courts" block the plan to send migrants to the African nation.

The Rwanda Bill going through Parliament states that it is up to ministers to decide whether or not to comply with interim rulings issued by judges in the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR).

However, the Lords voted to delay the controversial legislation as "significant additional legal and practical steps are needed in order to implement the protections the treaty is designed to provide".

Downing Street has maintained that the bill complies with international law, suggesting Strasbourg had no need to intervene.

Read more: Lee Anderson admits he should've backed Sunak over Rwanda and wants Tory job back after failed revolt

Read more: Rishi Sunak's flagship Rwanda bill faces long delay after defeat in House of Lords vote

Rwanda deportation plan suffers first defeat in House of Lords

Ms O'Leary said on Thursday that "there is a clear legal obligation" under the ECHR for states to comply with Rule 39 interim measures.

They are only issued "in exceptional circumstances where there is a real and imminent risk of irreparable harm", she said.

"The legal basis for this is principally Article 34 of the convention.

"In the past, where states have in the past failed to comply with Rule 39 indications, judges have found that the states have violated their obligations under Article 34 of the convention."

What is next for Rishi Sunak’s Rwanda plan

The Prime Minister's official spokesman said: "We've set out our case very clearly.

"I think, firstly, we are confident our legislation is compliant with our international obligations. We're clear the Bill and the treaty address the Supreme Court's concerns.

"There should be no need for Strasbourg to intervene to block flights in the way they did in 2022.

"We've also drafted the Bill to give ministers the power not to comply with those rulings if necessary.

"And obviously every case is assessed on its individual facts, but the Prime Minister has been clear repeatedly that we will not let a foreign court block flights from taking off."

The spokesman added: "I think it would be bizarre to draw any comparison between Russia's cruel treatment of Alexei Navalny, who was a victim of an attempted assassination attempt, and our plan to protect and deter vulnerable migrants from making perilous crossings across the Channel."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

James McClean of Wrexham stood away from his team-mates during the minute’s silence before the Sky Bet League One match at SToK Cae Ras, Wrexham. Picture date: Saturday November 9, 2024.

Wrexham player James McClean refuses to stand beside teammates during Remembrance silence

Callum Tindal-Draper, 22, was serving as part the International Legion when he was killed defending the country.

Tributes paid to 'brave as they come' British volunteer, 22, killed in Ukraine

Donald Trump 'could exempt Britain from his tariffs', sources close to the President-Elect have said.

Trump 'could give UK special exemption from tariffs' when he becomes President

Qatar has suspended mediation between Hamas and Israel, officials say.

Qatar quits mediation role in Hamas-Israel talks as terrorist group rumoured to be leaving Gulf state

Rebellious farmers are threatening to blockade ports and leave supermarket shelves bare in an escalation in their row with Rachel Reeves over her plan to up inheritance tax.

Farmers threaten to blockade ports and supermarkets in escalating row over Rachel Reeves's Budget

Emergency services were called to Grove Place near the junction with Carshalton Road, Banstead, shortly after 4pm on Saturday, the Metropolitan Police said.

Child dies after being hit by tree branch in Surrey, police say

The Princess of Wales has continued her comeback to royal duties after cancer treatment as she appeared at the Festival of Remembrance.

Princess Kate continues return to duty as she appears at Festival of Remembrance

Golden Organic Honey against a back ground

Nine-in-ten pots of British honey 'fail authenticity tests' as sugar syrup dilutes spread down

President Joe Biden is set to meet Donald Trump next week - after the latter's landslide election win on Tuesday.

Biden to meet Trump next week after Republicans landslide victory and presidential comeback

Women are making blue bracelets to show each other that they didn't vote for Trump

Viral trend sees women make blue 'Taylor Swift' style bracelets to show to each other that they didn't vote for Trump

The brothers have been sentenced for attempted double murder

Brothers involved in attempted double murder in London 'ambush' jailed for 69 years

Nigel Farage says his 'great relationship' with Trump could make him 'useful as an interlocutor' with Labour

Nigel Farage says his 'great relationship' with Trump could make him 'useful as an interlocutor' with Labour

Seventeen taken to hospital after two double-decker buses collide in Manchester

Seventeen taken to hospital after two double-decker buses collide in Manchester

Queen to miss Remembrance services Buckingham Palace confirms, as she continues recovery

Queen to miss Remembrance services Buckingham Palace confirms, as she continues recovery

The teenage girl was crashed into by a paraglider in Turkey

'I thought she was dead': British teen left fighting for life in Turkey after paraglider crashes into her on family holiday

The first recipients of the Elizabeth Emblem include two police officers killed in the line of duty

First emergency services workers honoured with 'Elizabeth Emblem' for those who die in line of duty