Russian state TV defies Putin and finally starts broadcasting criticism of the war

11 March 2022, 09:21 | Updated: 11 March 2022, 09:25

Russian TV broadcast criticism of the war despite the Kremlin's bid to clampdown on dissent
Russian TV broadcast criticism of the war despite the Kremlin's bid to clampdown on dissent. Picture: Alamy

By Will Taylor

Guests on Russian state TV have defied Vladimir Putin's bid to strangle criticism of his invasion of Ukraine as they took aim at the war.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The conflict was compared to the disastrous Soviet invasion of Afghanistan in the 1980s, in which thousands of soldiers died.

The dissent was broadcast on Russia 1, which is owned by the state, despite a new law banning what the Kremlin described as misinformation about the war - widely seen as a method to stifle opposition and protests throughout Russian cities.

The eponymous host of An Evening with Vladimir Soloviyev had to begin interrupting as the Kremlin's line was torn into.

Academic Semyon Bagdasarov asked: "Do we need to get into another Afghanistan, but even worse?"

Read more: 'Ukraine is gonna win, Kyiv will not be taken': Defenders will prevail, says ex US general

Read more: Boris warns Russia could use chemical weapons as Ukrainians seen 'fighting for food'

Lieutenant General Ben Hodges says Ukraine is going to win

Worrying that Ukraine had become more advanced with handling weapons, as the West supplies anti-tank and anti-aircraft missiles, he said: "We don't need that. Enough already."

Karen Shakhnazarov, a filmmaker, called for an end to the fighting and said: "I have a hard time imagining taking cities such as Kyiv, I can't imagine how that would look."

He went on: "If this picture starts to transform into an absolute humanitarian disaster, even our close allies like China and India will be forced to distance themselves from us.

Read more: 'Incomprehensible': Brit's wife 'ordered to go 500 miles to war-torn Kyiv' for UK visa

Read more: Russian armoured convoy 'on the move' as Klitschko warns Kyiv is now a 'fortress'

"This public opinion, with which they're saturating the entire world, can play out badly for us."

The Telegraph also reports that on Zvezda, a channel run by the country's ministry of defence, broadcast a serving army officer who said Russian forces were dying in Ukraine as the host shouted for him to stop, insisting the operation was a good thing.

Russia's information war has tried to frame Ukraine as a state run by Nazis, despite the government being democratically elected and President Volodymyr Zelenskyy's own family having fallen victim to the Holocaust.

A potential 15 year jail term could be imposed on dissidents in Russia if they are convicted of spreading "misinformation".

Nick Ferrari's epic rant on accepting Ukrainian refugees

Ahead of the invasion, the West warned about "false flag" operations run by the Kremlin that would try and paint Kyiv as an aggressor.

Those claims were again made as Russia tried to push a line that Ukraine has been developing chemical weapons, which has been dismissed and ridiculed in Kyiv and Washington.

It has led to fears that Russia - which is thought to have moved much slower in its invasion than anticipated in the face of staunch Ukrainian defences and supply issues - will deploy chemical weapons themselves and use their previous allegations against Ukraine as a cover story.

Boris Johnson said: "They start saying that there are chemical weapons that have been stored by their opponents or by the Americans and so when they themselves deploy chemical weapons, as I fear they may, they have a sort of maskirovka, a fake story, ready to go."

Previously, Anonymous was said to have hijacked TV and streaming services in Russia, displaying footage from the war.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Harry Potter star Warwick Davis' final heartbreaking post to 'beautiful wife' following her death, aged 53

Harry Potter star Warwick Davis' final heartbreaking post to 'beautiful wife' following her death, aged 53

Croatia Election

Croatia’s ruling conservatives win parliamentary vote but cannot rule alone

Indonesia Volcano Eruptions

Thousands evacuated and tsunami alert issued after Indonesian volcano eruption

A major UK-founded network of fake websites was infiltrated by police.

Dozens arrested as police infiltrate UK-founded cyber network after 500k tricked into handing over card details

Defence spending will not be increased until after the general election

Jeremy Hunt admits Britain needs to increase defence spending – but no extra cash will be given before next election

Election 2024 Biden

Joe Biden speaks of WWII history as he calls Donald Trump unfit to lead military

Mark Menzies

Tory MP Mark Menzies loses whip as investigation launched into claims he misused campaign funds

Samantha Davis, the wife of Star Wars and Harry Potter actor Warwick Davis, has died aged 53.

Harry Potter star Warwick Davis pays tribute to 'favourite human' wife Samantha after her death aged 53

A Boeing 787-10 Dreamliner

Boeing faces Senate scrutiny during back-to-back hearings on safety culture

Harry has made the US his primary residence

Prince Harry cuts ties with UK as he makes surprise change to official documents

Pointe performance

Ballerinas set world record at New York’s Plaza Hotel

Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt split two years after getting married.

Angelina Jolie accuses Brad Pitt of ‘bleeding her finances dry’ - despite ‘$100m boost to her fortune’

OJ Simpson in 1994

OJ Simpson has been cremated, says lawyer handling his estate

People protest against Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government and call for the release of hostages held in the Gaza Strip by the Hamas militant group in Tel Aviv, Israel

Netanyahu brushes off calls for restraint in response to Iran’s attack

Exclusive
Ben Elton has criticised Liz Truss

Liz Truss' resurgence shows the 'depressing level of politics we've arrived at', says comedian Ben Elton

Israeli PMBenjamin Netanyahu has said his country will be the one to decide how to respond to Iran's major air assault

Israel 'will make own decisions' in response to Iran attack, says Benjamin Netanyahu after meeting with David Cameron