Shamima Begum 'knew what she was doing', MI5 agent tells court as lawyer claims she was 'child trafficking victim'

22 November 2022, 10:41 | Updated: 22 November 2022, 10:42

Shemima Begum
Shemima Begum. Picture: PA

By Stephen Rigley

ISIS bride Shamima Begum "knew what she was doing" when she travelled to Syria to join Islamic State, a senior MI5 officer told her citizenship appeal.

The 23-year-old's lawyers had told the court that Begum was "cynically recruited and groomed" when she was 15, before being trafficked for sexual exploitation by the terror group in 2015.

Begum has launched a fresh attempt to have her British citizenship restored after then-home secretary Sajid Javid revoked it in 2019 when she was found in a Syrian refugee camp.

Begum is challenging the Home Office's decision to remove her British citizenship, with her lawyers arguing that the department had a legal duty to investigate whether the then-teenager was a victim of trafficking when the decision was made.

Her lawyers said Begum's case was a "paradigm example of child trafficking for the purposes of sexual exploitation and forced child marriage".

Begum, now 23, was 15 when she and two other east London schoolgirls travelled to join the so-called Islamic State group in February 2015.

Her British citizenship was revoked on national security grounds shortly after she was found, nine months pregnant, in a Syrian refugee camp in February 2019.

On the first day of a five-day hearing at the Special Immigration Appeals Commission (SIAC) - where a proportion of the proceedings are expected to be in private - an MI5 officer only known as Witness E gave some evidence in public.

Dan Squires KC, part of Begum's legal team, asked the officer whether they had discussed talking to a trafficking expert while considering Begum's case.

Shemima Begum speaking during an interview after leaving IS
Shemima Begum speaking during an interview after leaving IS. Picture: Video

Speaking from behind a screen, the officer said they could not answer the question publicly, but later said it was "worth remembering the context" of the terrorist organisation's acts around 2015.

The officer said the groups' actions around the time included large terror attacks and the public beheadings of multiple people - including journalist James Foley and aid worker Peter Kassig in 2014.

"It is inconceivable someone would not know what Isil was doing as a terrorist organisation at the time," they continued.

Shemima Begum speaking to BBC during an interview
Shemima Begum speaking to BBC during an interview. Picture: BBC

The witness noted Begum was predicted high grades in her exams, suggesting she was "intelligent", "articulate" and likely capable of critical thinking".

They added: "In some respects yes, I do think she would have known what she was doing and would have had agency in doing so."

Witness E later said that MI5 are experts in national security threats, not trafficking.

"We consider whether someone is a threat and it is important to note we recognise that victims can be threats if someone is a victim of trafficking," they added.

At the start of Monday's hearing, Samantha Knights KC, also for Begum, said the woman had been "persuaded, influenced and affected with her friends by a determined and effective Isis propaganda machine".

In written submissions, Mr Squires and Ms Knights said Begum's case was a "paradigm example of child trafficking for the purposes of sexual exploitation and forced child marriage".

"She was following a well-known pattern by which Isis cynically recruited and groomed female children, as young as 14, so that they could be offered as 'wives' to adult men."

Her lawyers said that the Home Office deprived Begum of her citizenship "without seeking to investigate and determine, still less consider, whether she was a child victim of trafficking and whether there were failures by public authorities in the UK to prevent her being trafficked".

"What evidence is available shows that rather than viewing the appellant as a victim, a child that was manipulated and exploited, the Home Secretary proceeded on the basis that she acted 'voluntarily' in travelling to Syria and aligning with Isis," the lawyers added.

Sir James Eadie KC, for the Home Office, said in written submissions that the Security Services "continue to assess that Ms Begum poses a risk to national security".

"This is a case about national security," he said, later adding: "This is not a case about trafficking."

Sir James said that Begum "travelled, aligned and stayed in Syria for four years" and that she only left IS-controlled territory for safety reasons "and not because of a genuine disengagement from the group".

He continued: "When she did emerge, and gave multiple press interviews shortly before the Secretary of State decided to deprive her of her citizenship, she expressed no remorse and said she did not regret joining Isil, acknowledging that she was aware of the nature of the group when she travelled."

The hearing in London marks the second part of Begum's SIAC case, following a ruling in February 2020 that the Home Office did not unlawfully leave her stateless by revoking her British citizenship.

The hearing before Mr Justice Jay is due to finish on Friday with a decision expected in writing at a later date.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Serbia Croatia

Serbia protests after Croatian minister calls president a Russian ‘satellite’

Labour-run Lambeth Council has raked in up to £50m in fines since introducing controversial low-traffic neighbourhoods (LTNs) in the south London borough.

Labour-run Lambeth rakes in up to £50m in fines since introducing controversial low-traffic neighbourhoods

Russia Ukraine War

Ukraine’s defence minister says supply delays are costing lives

Namibia Geingob Funeral

African and European leaders attend state funeral of Namibian president

Israel Palestinians Truce Talks

Netanyahu says ceasefire deal would only ‘delay somewhat’ an offensive in Rafah

Russia Ukraine War

31,000 Ukrainian troops killed since start of full-scale invasion – Zelensky

Belarus Election

Belarusians vote in tightly controlled election amid calls for boycott

Sadiq Khan has accused Rishi Sunak of 'enabling' Islamophobia

Sadiq Khan accuses Rishi Sunak of 'enabling anti-Muslim hatred' in the Conservative Party

Sloan Mattingly died in a 'freak accident' on the beach

Horrifying final moments of girl, 7, buried alive in sand when hole she was digging on family beach trip collapsed

Donald Trump said Prince Harry betrayed the Queen

'Harry betrayed the Queen': Donald Trump says prince's behaviour is 'unforgivable' as he wades into royal row

Nasar Mohammed Hussein

Urgent manhunt for violent criminal on the loose in London after he took off his ankle tag while out of jail on licence

The Muslim Council of Britain has called for an investigation into institutional Islamophobia in the Conservative Party

Conservatives must investigate 'institutional Islamophobia' in the party, Muslim Council of Britain says

Oliver Dowden said Lee Anderson 'didn't mean to be Islamophobic'

Deputy PM says Lee Anderson 'didn't intend to be Islamophobic' by saying that Khan was controlled by Islamists

Peter Doherty

Peter Doherty says he 'was healthier on heroin' as he reveals life-changing diagnosis after saying he's a 'sick man'

Donald Trump

Nikki Haley vows to fight on after Donald Trump wins in her home state

Biden Governors

Calls to ‘disagree better’ as US state governors meet at White House