Judge rules out separate defamation trials for Fox News and Fox Corp

12 April 2023, 18:44

Rupert Murdoch
Voting Machines Defamation Lawsuit. Picture: PA

The request by Dominion Voting Systems came a day after its lawyers told the judge that Fox had withheld critical information.

The judge presiding over a voting machine company’s defamation lawsuit against Fox has denied the firm’s request to hold separate trials — one for Fox News and another for the network’s parent company.

The request by Dominion Voting Systems came a day after its lawyers told the judge that Fox lawyers had withheld critical information about the role played at Fox News by company founder Rupert Murdoch, who is chairman of Fox Corp.

Delaware Superior Court Judge Eric Davis, who consolidated the cases against both entities in December, refused Dominion’s request to hold a separate trial during which Mr Murdoch would give evidence as a Fox News witness.

Dominion lawyers had told the judge that they had learned this week that Mr Murdoch also was an officer of Fox News, holding the title of executive chairman. That was contrary to repeated assertions by Fox lawyers.

Donald Trump
The case revolves around Donald Trump’s election defeat in 2020 (Evan Vucci/AP)

Mr Murdoch’s role and that of other top Fox executives is at the heart of Dominion’s 1.6 billion dollar (£1.3 billion) defamation case, which alleges that Fox damaged the company by repeatedly airing false allegations that its machines and the software they used rigged the 2020 presidential election against former president Donald Trump.

The company’s lawyers have sought to insulate members of the Murdoch family from the lawsuit, including trying to keep them from giving evidence live before a jury.

The lawyers have argued that executives’ roles at the parent company, Fox Corp, removed them from the day-to-day decisions that allowed the false election claims to be aired on various Fox News programmes.

Fox Corp had claimed since Colorado-based Dominion filed its lawsuit in 2021 that Mr Murdoch had no official role at Fox News.

In its filings, it had listed Fox News officers as Jay Wallace, Joe Dorrego and Suzanne Scott, who is Fox News’ chief executive, but on Sunday, Fox disclosed to Dominion’s lawyers that Mr Murdoch was also “executive chair” at Fox News.

In a statement, Fox said he has been listed as executive chairman of Fox News in Securities and Exchange Commission filings since 2019.

Voting Machines Defamation Lawsuit
Dominion Voting Systems ballot-counting machines (Andres Leighton/AP)

Fox lawyers also noted during Wednesday’s pre-trial hearing that Dominion lawyers, using a publicly available proxy statement, had asked Mr Murdoch at his deposition if he was executive chairman at Fox News.

“No. My son is the chief executive of everything at Fox,” he initially replied, referring to his son Lachlan Murdoch, who is executive chairman of Fox Corp.

He later said: “I may have had that title in the past. I may have it now. I don’t know.”

Fox lawyers have said Mr Murdoch’s title at Fox News was “honorific” and that he has had no role in day-to-day management.

Dominion lawyers contend that Fox’s late disclosure of Mr Murdoch’s dual role has deprived Dominion of the ability to produce documents from him to which it otherwise would have been entitled.

As an alternative to ordering separate trials, Dominion lawyers said the judge should give an “adverse inference” to jurors about Fox’s conduct.

Judge Davis declined to rule on that request, saying Dominion would have to offer evidence to support it and that Fox would have a chance to respond.

But he added: “What do I do with attorneys that aren’t straightforward with me?” suggesting the conduct of Fox lawyers could result in unspecified sanctions.

A trial in the case is set to start on Thursday with jury selection.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Dr Ghassan Abu Sitta

UK doctor denied entry to France for senate meeting on Gaza

Palestinians stand in the ruins of a home after an overnight Israeli strike that killed at least two adults and five boys and girls under the age of 16 in Rafah, southern Gaza Strip

Hamas in Cairo as Egyptian media report progress in ceasefire talks

Tanzania Flooding

Cyclone Hidaya weakens as it moves toward Tanzania’s coastline

Plane takes off at dusk

Snakes on a plane – almost – as reptiles found hidden in passenger’s trousers

Ukrainian leader

Russia puts Ukrainian President Zelensky on wanted list

Holy Fire ceremony

Orthodox worshippers greet ancient ceremony of the Holy Fire in Jerusalem

Heavy rains

Houston braces for more flooding in wake of storms

Israel-Hamas conflict

Students protesting against Gaza war disrupt Cambridge open days

Youngsters wade through a flooded street caused by heavy rain in Peshawar, Pakistan

Pakistan records its wettest April since 1961 with above average rainfall

This drone footage obtained by The Associated Press shows the village of Ocheretyne, a target for Russian forces in the Donetsk region of eastern Ukraine

Drone footage shows damage in Ukraine village as residents flee Russian advance

Rescue workers at the site of a collapsed section of a highway on the Meizhou-Dabu Expressway in Meizhou, southern China’s Guangdong Province

Chinese truck driver praised for helping reduce casualties after road collapse

Gaza has descended into a full-blown famine, a top UN official has said

Gaza descends into ‘full-blown famine’ amid Israeli restrictions on food deliveries to the region, UN official declares

Indonesia Landslide

Flood and landslide hit Indonesia’s Sulawesi island, killing 14

Morgan Wallen Arrested

Court appearance for country singer Morgan Wallen postponed until August

Mark Hamill

Star Wars actor Hamill dubs Biden ‘Joe-bi-Wan Kenobi’ on trip to White House

Rockstar Mick Jagger briefly waded into Louisiana politics while on-stage in New Orleans

'You can't always get what you want' Louisiana governor endorsed by Trump claps back at Mick Jagger after on-stage jibe