Archbishop of Canterbury backs shake-up to 'broken' asylum system ahead of showdown over Rwanda Bill

20 March 2024, 00:10 | Updated: 20 March 2024, 00:15

Faith leaders have backed proposals for a major shake-up
Faith leaders have backed proposals for a major shake-up. Picture: Alamy

By Emma Soteriou

The Archbishop of Canterbury is among several faith leaders to have backed a shake-up to the "broken" asylum system, ahead of a parliamentary showdown over the Rwanda Bill.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Migrants would be eligible to work in the UK after six months of waiting for an asylum decision and given free English language education as soon as they arrive in the country under fresh recommendations.

The proposals are part of a report by the independent Commission on the Integration of Refugees (CIR), which also calls for the reinstatement of a refugees minister in government.

The Most Rev Justin Welby was joined by Chief Rabbi Sir Ephraim Mirvis, Shaykh Ibrahim Mogra, Cardinal Vincent Nichols and Rabbis Josh Levy and Charley Baginsky in calling for the changes.

It comes on the same day that the Rwanda Bill is returning to the House of Lords, after MPs rejected all of their amendments on Monday.

With Easter recess starting next week, the legislation is unlikely to pass before the break if the Lords maintain their resistance.

But Rishi Sunak is still hoping to get the first flights to Kigali off the ground by the spring, with Downing Street urging peers to "work with the government".

Read more: MPs reject Rwanda Bill amendments as Sunak faces fresh battle with Lords over migrant plan

Read more: Rwanda wants slow start to deportations - as spring deportations look unlikely as bill stalls in Parliament

Sunak maintains hope of spring Rwanda flights after seeing off Lords’ challenges

The Archbishop said: "In a world of rising conflict and instability, we agree that immigration must be managed and controlled, small boats must be stopped, and traffickers must be caught.

"Receiving communities especially must be supported and not feel used. That makes it easier for our natural generosity to be expressed, and for our unity to grow and not be threatened.

"It's widely acknowledged that our asylum system is broken - it needs rebuilding with compassion, dignity and fairness at the centre.

"This requires thoughtful, well-informed consideration which promotes collaboration and common ground, not division."

The report references analysis from the London School of Economics, which suggests that migrants could bring in a net economic gain of £1.2 billion over five years.

A survey of refugees and asylum seekers carried out for the commission suggests there is "untapped potential" in Britain, the CIR said.

Around one in three respondents had a bachelor's degree or equivalent but the same number said they were unable to use the skills they learned as part of their qualification.

The same number said language was the most significant barrier to work yet more than one in five have been unable to access English classes due to waiting lists.

MPs rejected amendments to the Rwanda Bill on Monday
MPs rejected amendments to the Rwanda Bill on Monday. Picture: Parliament TV

The report says the government should "make people in the asylum system eligible for general employment after six months of waiting for their asylum decision" and this should "not be limited to the jobs on the shortage occupation list."

It also calls for people in the asylum system to be made eligible for shortage occupation list jobs from day one and for consideration of a "government-backed finance scheme" to help refugees set up businesses.

Ed Kessler, chairman of the commission, said: "Our work over the last couple of years, listening to people from across the country, commissioning research and exploring these issues has provided a rich insight into what is clearly a broken system.

"It's expensive, inefficient and damaging for refugees and Britain.

"But amongst the debris were findings that gave us real hope and inspiration for a very different system. One that supports refugees, communities and wider society to thrive.

"One that our political leaders can realistically embrace."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Had a single ticket-holder matched all the winning numbers, they would have claimed a record jackpot of £210 million

EuroMillions numbers revealed as UK players scoop multi-million pound prizes

Men and children were forced to hold the traditional Eid al-Adha prayers in the open air because much of the Strip has been reduced to rubble.

Eid in ruins: Palestinians pray among rubble as Gaza faces deepening humanitarian crisis

The strain, dubbed Nimbus, descends from the already destructive Omicron variant and has made it's way on to Britain's shores after sparking a rise in cases in China, Singapore and Hong Kong

'Nimbus' Covid variant hits UK: Scientists warn of possible summer infection wave

Claim notifications have been sent to the Clifford Health Club and Spa on behalf of three former spa members.

'I went to keep healthy and ended up getting gassed': Spa members launch legal action after toxic chemical leak

The London Assembly called on Sir Sadiq to ask the Treasury to amend vehicle excise duty to include a tax based on vehicle weight.

Drivers in London face weight-based car tax and larger parking fees

Ed Sheeran (L) and Alex Warren (R).

US singer-songwriter Alex Warren breaks UK chart record previously held by Ed Sheeran

Formal identification has yet to take place however the family of missing man Cole Cooper, 19, has been informed.

Body discovered in wooded area in search for missing teenager Cole Cooper

A view of a Post Office sign in central London.

Five family members jailed in plot to hide £130,000 stolen from post office in staged armed robbery

A former Bargain Hunt art expert has been jailed for two years and six months for failing to declare art he sold to financier of Hezbollah.

Bargain Hunt expert jailed for selling art to suspected Hezbollah financier in 'first of its kind' prosecution

Tottenham sack boss Ange Postecoglou despite Europa League win

Ange Postecoglou has been sacked by Tottenham Hotspur despite winning Europa League

Royal Navy D-Day veteran John Dennett, 101, at the British Normandy Memorial in Ver-sur-Mer, France.

‘We remember our friends who never came home’: Veterans commemorate D-Day landings in France for 81st anniversary

Hassan Jhangur, 25, drove into Chris Marriott (top right), who was trying to help one of Jhangur’s sisters, the court heard

Bride’s brother ‘killed Good Samaritan with his car before stabbing the groom during family feud at wedding'

Married French teacher Simon Clark has been jailed for eight years

Married teacher who posed as boy online to ask girls as young as 10 to send sexual images jailed

The documents were released ahead of the 81st anniversary of D-Day, the Allied invasion of Normandy on June 6, 1944.

D-Day landings boosted by import of ‘wonder drug’ to Britain, archives reveal

28 MAY 2025 - Austin, TX, USA - The developing skyline of Austin, that is undergoing significant growth in recent years with the tech boom

Fears serial killer on the loose in major US city - as 19 bodies pulled from lake

A residential multi-storey building is seen damaged after a Russian drone strike on Kyiv, Ukraine, on Friday, June 6, 2025.

Russia says 'massive attack' on Kyiv was retaliation for Ukraine's strikes as 'almost all of Ukraine' targeted