Government slams junior doctors' 'unreasonable' pay demands as NHS braces for most disruptive strike in its history

11 April 2023, 00:02

The  NHS has said it cannot guarantee patient safety during the strikes
The NHS has said it cannot guarantee patient safety during the strikes. Picture: Getty
Kieran Kelly

By Kieran Kelly

The health secretary has urged junior doctors to drop their "unreasonable" demand for a 35 per cent pay rise, as the NHS braces for the most disruptive strike in its history.

Steve Barclay said it was "extremely disappointing" that the British Medical Association has decided to strike for four consecutive days.

"Not only will the walkouts risk patient safety, but they have also been timed to maximise disruption after the Easter break," Mr Barclay said.

"I hoped to begin formal pay negotiations with the BMA last month but its demand for a 35% pay rise is unreasonable – it would result in some junior doctors receiving a pay rise of over £20,000.

"If the BMA is willing to move significantly from this position and cancel strikes we can resume confidential talks and find a way forward, as we have done with other unions."

It comes after the NHS Confederation chief told LBC that it cannot guarantee patient safety during the junior doctors' strike this week.

Read More: NHS 'can't guarantee patient safety' in doctors' strike, says health leaders' chief, with 350k appointments axed

NHS Confederation CEO admits the NHS 'can't guarantee' patient safety ahead of mass strike action.

As many as 350,000 appointments could be cancelled this week, as tens of thousands of junior doctors walk out for four days from 7am on Tuesday over a pay and conditions dispute with the government.

Speaking to LBC's Andrew Castle on Monday, Matthew Taylor, whose organisation represents the various NHS bodies, said remaining staff would do their best to replace the striking junior doctors, who have demanded a 35% pay rise.

But he warned: "I don't think we can guarantee that. Managers in the health service will do everything they can to try to reorganise things. Consultants, we hope, will step up and take the place of junior doctors.

"So we'll do everything we can, as we always do in these strike situations. And of course, we've been having strikes for months in the health service. We'll do everything we can to maintain those urgent emergency services."

Protestors hold placards expressing their opinion during the Budget Day Protest held in Central London
Protestors hold placards expressing their opinion during the Budget Day Protest held in Central London. Picture: Getty

He continued: "But if you're saying to me, is there a risk to patient safety? Yes, there is. If you're saying to me, is there a risk to patient dignity in terms of us being able to provide the level of care, yes, there is."

Mr Taylor said the strikes were "deeply frustrating" as he called for both the BMA - the doctors' union - and the government to begin negotiating.

"I think what’s happened over the last few days is very worrying in terms of the fact that both sides seem to be becoming more entrenched...

A junior doctor striking
A junior doctor striking. Picture: Alamy

"There’s no question that junior doctors’ pay has fallen in real terms and there’s no question that there are genuine issues about recruiting and retaining those staff. Nobody goes on strike in the health service unless they feel it’s a last resort.

"But today we are calling for the government and the BMA to call in ACAS, the conciliation service - because at the moment, we’re not even talking.

"The government said yesterday that they wouldn’t even talk unless the strikes are called off, and the 35% demand is abandoned, the BMA have said ‘well look 35% is a starting point for negotiation. That’s how negotiation works.'

Mr Taylor added that the NHS had already been through recent waves of strikes by nurses and ambulance workers, when the government said they wouldn't negotiate, only to come to the table later.

He said: "Why do we have to go through this again? Eventually these two sides are going to negotiate.

"This is what’s deeply frustrating - negotiation involves a process in which both sides start from a position which is unacceptable to the other side, and they talk. And then they get to a position where they are able to resolve things.

"Unfortunately we have two sides now who are unwilling to enter into that process.

"And that means not only do we face arguably the worst concerted strike action the NHS has ever seen over the next few days, but we face the possibility of that happening again, and even further escalation."

A junior doctor holds a placard calling for fair pay during their last strike in February
A junior doctor holds a placard calling for fair pay during their last strike in February. Picture: Getty

Read More: Emergency care to be prioritised during junior doctors’ strike, says NHS England

Read More: Warning of Easter getaway chaos amid millions of road trips, fears of Dover delays and strikes in France

The latest strike comes four weeks after the BMA began a controversial campaign which claimed that the new medics earned less than baristas at Pret A Manger.

Doctors previously went on strike for 72 hours in February in a row over pay - saying new medics have seen a 26% real terms pay cut since 2008.

The union previously said: "Pret a Manger has announced it will pay up to £14.10 per hour. A junior doctor makes just £14.09.

“Thanks to this government you can make more serving coffee than saving patients. This week junior doctors will take strike action so they are paid what they are worth.”

The junior doctors have joined teachers, nurses, rail workers and other public servants as part Britain's biggest strike wave since the 1980s.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Grant Shapps has said the world needs to know Israel's plans for Gaza

'The world needs to know': Grant Shapps urges Israel to reveal plan for Gaza after war with Hamas ends

Israel Palestinians

Women and children die in Israeli air strike on Gaza

File photo of the Ovingham Bridge across the River Tyne

Boy, 14, dies and another, 13, in critical condition after getting into difficulty in the River Tyne

Giovanni Pernice's dance partner Amanda Abbington quit Strictly

Strictly's Giovanni Pernice 'stamped on Amanda Abbington's foot' in 'bruising' training, as dancer vows to 'clear his name'

Russia Ukraine War

Ukraine and Russia launch multiple drone attacks on each other

South West Water's Susan Davy has apologised for the Devon water crisis

Water boss apologises to customers after 'hundreds' fall ill, as she says parasite crisis 'shouldn't have happened'


Judge to consider Ohio law banning nearly all abortions

Patricia and Buster Price

Pensioners forced out of their home by 'flood' of sewage - and say Thames Water blamed them

Infected blood victim Bill Wright has criticised the payout scheme

'This isn't about money, people died': Infected blood victim calls Jeremy Hunt payout announcement 'sinister'

NRA Convention Trump

Donald Trump makes election pitch to gun owners after NRA endorsement

The boys got into trouble in the water near Ovingham Bridge

Two teenage boys missing after getting into trouble in River Tyne, as rescue teams and helicopter scrambled to search

Tunisia Mediterranean Migration

Protesters in Tunisia call for migrants to be returned to home countries

Israeli war cabinet member Benny Gantz has threatened to quit the government

Israeli war cabinet member threatens to quit if Benjamin Netanyahu doesn't change tack on Gaza

Britain's Tyson Fury, left, and Ukraine's Oleksandr Usyk trade blows during their undisputed heavyweight world championship boxing fight

Oleksandr Usyk defeats Tyson Fury to become undisputed world heavyweight boxing champion

Fake Electors Indictment Giuliani

Rudy Giuliani final defendant served of 18 accused in Arizona fake electors case

Chancellor of the Exchequer Jeremy Hunt at the Infected Blood Inquiry in London where he is being questioned on the Government's response to the use of infected blood and blood products and the question of compensation. Picture date: Friday July 28, 2023.

Jeremy Hunt says expected infected blood payouts of £10bn fulfil promise to constituent who died due to scandal