Insulate Britain eco-activists jailed for talking about climate crisis in trial, defying judge's orders

3 March 2023, 20:55 | Updated: 4 March 2023, 03:53

Lewis and Pritchard glued themselves to the street
Lewis and Pritchard glued themselves to the street. Picture: Alamy/Getty

By Kit Heren

Two Insulate Britain activists have been sent to prison for referring to the climate crisis in their trial for causing a public nuisance, after they glued themselves to a busy London road.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Dorset councillor Giovanna Lewis, 65, and horticultural worker Amy Pritchard, 38, had been ordered by the judge not to talk about the environment or fuel poverty in their defence during the trial.

But the pair, who defended themselves in court, broke Silas Reid's order and were found in contempt of court on Friday. They were sentenced to seven weeks' imprisonment, of which they will serve half.

The two were part of a larger group who glued themselves to Bishopsgate in the City of London in October 2021. The jury failed to reach verdicts on the public nuisance charge, and prosecutors indicated that they may seek a retrial.

Judge Reid told the defendants they had sought to "set themselves above the law" by mentioning aspects of their motivation in carrying out the October protest that were not relevant to jury deliberations.

Lewis and Pritchard outside the court
Lewis and Pritchard outside the court. Picture: Alamy

He concluded that the defendants had either set out to "manipulate" the jury into acquitting them even if they were sure of the pair's guilt, or to use the trial to continue their protest within the courtroom.

"Either motivation would be serious as you would be seeking to set yourselves above the law," the judge said.

"Each of you has clear disdain for the judicial process. Your contempts are very serious as they represent complete contempt for the court and court process."

He added: "Most importantly though, in my mind, is the need of the court to protect its process. Not out of any sense of pride or importance, but because the rule of law is vital.

"All people are treated as equals in the courts. No side has the advantage of the court determining that their cause is just, or that the law should be bent or broken because of any personal views a judge may or may not have.

Police officers dissolve the glue on a protester's hand on Bishopsgate
Police officers dissolve the glue on a protester's hand on Bishopsgate. Picture: Getty

"If people are allowed to circumvent the court process just because they feel they should be entitled to, then the system would not be able to be relied on by every member of society.

"You each decided that rather than show respect for the court process you would set yourselves up as individual arbiters of what is fair and proper. That is real contempt."

The defendants had each elected to have a Crown Court trial - heard before a jury of members of the public - instead of a summary trial at a magistrates' court.

Read more: Two months of chaos: A timeline of Insulate Britain's disruptive protests

Read more: Mum who 'nudged' Insulate Britain protester with 4x4 says conviction is 'huge injustice'

Asked by the judge whether they wished him to take anything into consideration in sentencing, Lewis said: "I continue to be astonished that today in a British court, a judge can or would even want to criminalise the mention of the words fuel poverty or climate crisis.

"There are thousands of deaths each year in the UK from fuel poverty and thousands of deaths around the world due to climate change. In the future this will be millions."

A man being arrested during the demonstration
A man being arrested during the demonstration. Picture: Getty

She added: "Your ruling that why we did this was completely irrelevant was quashing the human spirit and the heart and you can only do that so much but it has to speak and that is the place I spoke from. Speaking from the heart and not allowing my soul to be repressed in the way that your rulings were doing."

Pritchard said the world is "staring total eco-system collapse in the face" and criticised "those in power" for failing to act. Addressing the judge directly, she said: "I include you in that and I wonder if people are too comfortable to feel the urgency." Several supporters watching proceedings from the public gallery were warned not to disrupt proceedings by the judge before applauding at the end of the hearing.

Speaking to the PA news agency outside court ahead of the hearing, Ms Lewis branded the ruling "unbelievable" and an attack on civil liberties.

But she added that she had "committed to going to prison" when she broke the law and did not want to act like a "martyr". She said: "Nobody wants to go to prison but in order to stand up for what's right, for our civil liberties in court, it's the price that we have to pay."

Just released Insulate Britain activist says she would do it again

Ms Pritchard said: "I feel that my responsibility here is not to the judge and to this court, my responsibility is much wider. It's to young people who are rightly worried about their futures and my responsibilities to our global families who are already suffering and dying, to the world's ecosystems and also to future generations."

She added that she had interpreted the hung jury as a "promising sign" that some sections of the public may be sympathetic to Insulate Britain's cause.

"I think it's a sign that people are really concerned about the issues that we're raising, and perhaps also concerned that we're being blocked from talking about them in court," she said.

"History has shown that the law is not always in line with justice, and I think this is another example of that.

"This situation is completely unprecedented. The legal system is not fit for purpose to deal with it and to deal with people trying to intervene."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Starmer has slammed the "botched deal" procured by former PM Boris Johnson

Boris Johnson inflicted 'botched' deal on nation, says Starmer who promises to negotiate better Brexit deal with EU

Wall Street Journal reporter Evan Gershkovich waves and smiles as he stands in a glass cage in a courtroom at the First Appeals Court of General Jurisdiction in Moscow, Russia, on April 23 2024

US reporter Evan Gershkovich, held in Russia on espionage charges, to face trial

This image provided by Tamatha Bibbo, principal of the Pollard Middle School in Needham, Massachusetts, shows 23 sets of twins who graduated from Pollard Middle School

Double take: 23 sets of twins graduate from single Massachusetts middle school

Elephant Bubi kicks the ball towards the goal in Starkenberg, Germany

Bubi the elephant predicts Germany to win Euro 2024 opener against Scotland

Exclusive
Keir Starmer has called on the Europe to look again at new passport rules being introduced for EU travel.

Keir Starmer calls on Europe to look again at new passport rules being introduced for EU travel

Russia’s Kazan nuclear-powered submarine arrives at the port of Havana, Cuba, on Wednesday

US submarine pulls into Guantanamo Bay day after Russian warships arrive in Cuba

Wayne Lineker has shared an update with fans

Wayne Lineker says he's 'doing ok' after being knocked out by single punch after protecting woman from being harassed

The 'Happy Days' actor shared a grinning selfie with Dublin Fire Brigade

Happy Days for The Fonz: Henry Winkler thanks firefighters after blaze at Dublin hotel

Rishi Sunak with Italian PM Giorgia Meloni

Rishi Sunak receives warm welcome at G7 summit as he reunites with Italian PM

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky walks past various international flags on arrival at the G7 in Borgo Egnazia, Italy

How will move to lend Ukraine billions backed by Russia’s frozen assets work?

Prince Andrew has a 'secret weapon' amid his ongoing Royal Lodge row with King Charles.

Prince Andrew may deploy ‘secret weapon’ amid ongoing standoff over Royal Lodge home with King Charles

Yazmin Oukhellou, Scott Timlin and Eva Zapico arriving at Westminster Magistrates' Court.

Love Island and Towie stars appear in court accused of promoting dodgy investments on Instagram

Taylor Swift's fans set off earthquake monitors in Edinburgh.

‘Shaking it off the charts’: Taylor Swift fans set off earthquake monitors on first UK nights of singer's Eras Tour

G7 leaders at the summit in southern Italy

G7 summit opens with deal to use frozen Russian assets for Ukraine

‘She’s not sorry and is still on the run’: Harry Dunn’s mum slams his US diplomat killer Anne Sacoolas as inquest rules

‘She’s continuing to run': Harry Dunn’s mum slams 'despicable' US diplomat killer Anne Sacoolas as inquest concludes

Alan won eight League titles and three European Cups with Liverpool

Liverpool issue heartfelt birthday message to Alan Hansen after he was taken 'seriously ill'