Johnny Depp's bid to overturn assault ruling reaches Court of Appeal

18 March 2021, 06:15 | Updated: 18 March 2021, 06:16

Mr Depp sued The Sun's publisher News Group Newspapers over a 2018 column
Mr Depp sued The Sun's publisher News Group Newspapers over a 2018 column. Picture: PA

By Maddie Goodfellow

Johnny Depp's bid to overturn a ruling that he assaulted his ex-wife Amber Heard will be considered by the Court of Appeal on Thursday.

The Hollywood star wants the court to order a retrial of his libel claim against The Sun over an article calling him a "wife beater", which a High Court judge found was "substantially true".

Following a three-week trial in July last year, Mr Justice Nicol ruled that Mr Depp, 57, assaulted Ms Heard, 34, on a dozen occasions and put her in "fear for her life" three times.

The actor is now challenging that ruling and his application for permission to appeal against it will be heard at the Royal Courts of Justice in London on Thursday morning.

It is not known if Mr Depp or Ms Heard will be in attendance.

Amber Heard outside the Royal Courts of Justice
Amber Heard outside the Royal Courts of Justice. Picture: PA

Mr Depp sued The Sun's publisher News Group Newspapers (NGN) over a 2018 column by the newspaper's executive editor Dan Wootton, which referred to "overwhelming evidence" he attacked Ms Heard.

Following the high-profile trial, Mr Justice Nicol ruled against Mr Depp, but the actor claims he "did not receive a fair trial".

In documents filed with the Court of Appeal, Mr Depp's barrister David Sherborne has asked the court to "set aside the judgment and order a new trial", claiming Mr Justice Nicol's judgment is "plainly wrong".

Adam Wolanski QC, representing NGN, argues Mr Justice Nicol conducted "a painstaking analysis of the evidence", adding: "There is no basis to conclude that the judge failed to examine the evidence or provide reasons for his findings."

In a court order issued in February, Lord Justice Underhill said an application by Mr Depp's lawyers to rely on new evidence, which was not heard at the trial, would also be dealt with at Thursday's hearing.

In his judgment, Mr Justice Nicol concluded that 12 of the 14 alleged incidents of domestic violence relied on by NGN in its defence of the actor's claim did occur.

The judge also found Mr Depp put Ms Heard in "fear for her life" on three occasions, including one the actress described as a "three-day hostage situation" in Australia in March 2015.

Actor Johnny Depp has lost his High Court case to sue the Sun for defamation

But Mr Depp's legal team claim Mr Justice Nicol "failed to examine the competing accounts of each incident, or to explain whether he found them proved and, if so, on what basis".

They also argue "the judge should have analysed the extent to which Ms Heard's evidence undermined her credibility in relation to her allegations of physical assault/injury".

Mr Sherborne said Mr Justice Nicol "took little or no account of the striking examples of Ms Heard's willingness to lie or commit wrongdoing".

In his response, however, Mr Wolanski said the trial judge's ruling was "long and thorough, with each conclusion of fact supported by a detailed analysis of the relevant oral and documentary evidence".

He also argued that Mr Justice Nicol "explained his assessment of the witnesses' - especially Ms Heard's - credibility in considerable detail".

Just days after the ruling in July, Mr Depp announced he had been asked by Warner Brothers to resign from his role in the Harry Potter spin-off franchise Fantastic Beasts - the very role which prompted Mr Wootton to ask how JK Rowling could be "genuinely happy" Mr Depp was cast in the film.

Mr Depp is currently embroiled in a separate libel battle in the US, having sued Ms Heard personally over a 2018 Washington Post opinion piece in which she claimed to be a victim of domestic abuse but did not mention the actor by name.

The actor's 50 million dollar (£35 million) US case against Amber Heard was recently delayed until April 2022.

The Court of Appeal hearing begins at 10.30am on Thursday and will be livestreamed on the court's YouTube channel

It is yet not known if Lord Justice Underhill and Lord Justice Dingemans will give a ruling on Thursday, or reserve their decision to a later date.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Dinal killed himself after he was blackmailed on social media

Private school pupil, 16, killed himself after nude photo blackmail by 'scammer from Nigeria'

Police have been searching a rural property near Bungonia

Divers search for bodies of Sydney couple allegedly shot dead by police officer

The cyclist was on Pont street in Belgravia when he filmed the driver on his phone behind the wheel

Cyclist reports driver for using mobile phone at the wheel - but police accuse him of breaking the law

Shocking footage shows pro-Palestine protestors taking on Bradford kebab shop after owner 'refuses to boycott Coca-Cola'

Pro-Palestine protesters attack kebab shop after owner 'refused to boycott Coca-Cola'

Pope Francis carried out a traditional Sunday noon blessing

Pope Francis cancels engagements due to mild flu symptoms, Vatican says

A makeshift tent camp in Rafah for Palestinians displaced by the Israeli ground offensive on the Gaza Strip

Human Rights Watch accuses Israel of blocking aid in violation of UN court order

A protest by farmers outside a meeting of EU agriculture ministers in Brussels

Farmers converge on EU’s headquarters in fresh show of force

The protester identified himself as Aaron Bushnell, 25

US airman Aaron Bushnell, 25, screams ‘Free Palestine’ before setting himself on fire in protest over Gaza war

Eiffel Tower

Eiffel Tower reopens to visitors after six-day closure amid strike by employees

London Mayor Sadiq Khan has been criticised for his less than frugal spending where 'night tsar' Amy Lamé's luxury 'partnership building' trips were concerned

Sadiq Khan under fire for sending £117k 'night tsar' on luxury business trips despite London's flagging party scene

Charlotte Church has been criticised for the chant being used at the concert

Charlotte Church slammed for singing controversial 'from the river to the sea' chant at pro-Palestine charity concert

Christopher Nolan

Oppenheimer keeps devouring awards with top prize at Producers Guild

Rishi Sunak is facing a revolt for sacking Lee Anderson

PM denies Tories have 'Islamophobic tendencies' as minister says Lee Anderson's comments were 'profoundly wrong'

Bus operators said they were not consulted about the plans and laid the blame on the delays firmly on the LTN

Three mile bus journeys take two hours in low-traffic neighbourhoods with TfL blaming 'serious' delays on scheme

The 1964 film has had its age rating changed after sixty years

Mary Poppins age rating changed from ‘U’ to ‘PG’ over ‘discriminatory language’ sixty years after release

The award for best feature was given to Past Lives

Past Lives and American Fiction among big winners at Independent Spirit Awards