Laughing at someone falling over at work is not harassment, judge rules, as pub worker loses tribunal claim

11 April 2023, 21:27

Finding someone falling over at work funny is not harassment, a judge has ruled, as a pub worker lost an employment tribunal claim after his manager laughed when he took a tumble while on shift.
Finding someone falling over at work funny is not harassment, a judge has ruled, as a pub worker lost an employment tribunal claim after his manager laughed when he took a tumble while on shift. Picture: Alamy

By Chris Samuel

Finding someone falling over at work funny is not harassment, a judge has ruled, as a pub worker lost an employment tribunal claim after his manager laughed when he took a tumble.

Kesarajith Perera fell over after slipping on a patch of oil at The George pub in Harrow, which was met with laughter from his boss Hesham Badra.

Mr Perera was dismissed in October over an unrelated matter, following his failure to produce documentation for his proof of right to work in the UK.

He then took establishment's owners to the tribunal, complaining of racial and religious harassment, and cited Mr Badra's reaction to his workplace fall as evidence.

But the claims were dismissed, with employment judge David Maxwell saying the "slapstick element" of someone falling over was likely to cause laughter.

Read more: 'Claps don't pay the bills': Striking junior doctors march on Downing Street as No10 refuses to back down on pay demands

Read more: UK set to become worst performing G7 economy this year as IMF says world economy entering 'perilous phase'

Mr Perera's suggestion that Mr Badra put oil on the floor deliberately in order to cause the slip was also dismissed as “ridiculous”.

The judge found that the “slapstick” nature of someone someone falling over means it is likely to provoke laughter.

"Whilst it might be tempting to hope that one colleague would only ever react in a sympathetic way towards the misfortune of another, common experience suggests this is not always the case," he said.

The tribunal, held in Watford, heard that Mr Perera began at the pub in January 2020 as a member of the kitchen team, and had the fall in March.

Stock image of wet floor sign
Stock image of wet floor sign. Picture: Alamy

The tribunal said: "Unfortunately, it appears to us, Mr Perera has a tendency to jump to conclusions when he encounters misfortune.

“Furthermore, Mr Perera's allegation was undermined by his own evidence, which was to the effect that the location where he fell was one prone to spillages."

The panel concluded that the laughter had nothing to do with Mr Perera's race or religion.

Mr Perera's additional complaint that he had been handed the “full time role of cleaning toilets” was also dismissed.

"Cleaning the toilets could scarcely be made into a full-time role," Judge Maxwell said.

Read more: Man suspected of being Britain's top IRA spy codenamed Stakeknife dies

Read more: Murderer turned in by mum sentenced to life after stabbing schoolboy, 16, in the heart

"Mr Perera's objection was the same as before – this was an unpleasant duty he did not think he should have to carry out."

Throwing his harassment claims, Judge Maxwell said: "None of the treatment complained of had the proscribed purpose or effect.

"The conduct itself, objectively, came nowhere near having the proscribed effect, and his view of matters was unreasonable."

However, panel did rule in Mr Perera's favour regarding unlawful deductions of wages and awarded him £1,426.11.

He was also given £908.91 for the pub’s “abysmal” paperwork after he was not given a written particulars of employment.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Exclusive
The Home Office confirmed that 1,194 asylum seekers reached the UK in 18 small boats on Saturday—the highest daily total so far in 2025.

Amber Rudd tells Government to ‘get a grip’ as record 1,194 Migrants cross channel in one day

Exclusive
Former head of the diplomatic service Lord Simon McDonald stressed to LBC's Andrew Marr that NATO 'couldn't force the UK to do anything'.

Former Foreign Office head tells LBC NATO ‘can't force UK to do anything’ but warns of ‘painful cuts’ in spending review

The 46-year-old, who has twice won a national bravery award, then slammed the teenager to the ground and placed his hand over the boy’s face while shouting threats and curse words

Award-winning police officer sacked for ‘lack of respect’ after slamming knife-carrying teen to ground

On March 20, 2022, hundreds of protesters attended a rally in front of Hackney Town Hall, London, United Kingdom, to demonstrate their support for Child Q.

Black schoolgirl was ‘demeaned’ and felt ‘physically violated’ after police strip search while on her period

Sunny Jacobs

Exonerated US death row inmate turned campaigner dies in Irish house fire

Commander Julian Bennett outside a Metropolitan Police misconduct hearing at Palestra House, south east London.

Senior Met officer sacked for second time over refusing drugs test

Just before midnight, after major broadcasters projected that Lee Jae-myung would win the presidency, he made his first public appearance with his wife, Kim Hye-Kyung, in front of the National Assembly to greet his supporters.

South Korea opposition Lee Jae-myung wins election following months of martial law chaos

Police officers cover with an inflatable tent, behind a firefighter vehicle, the tents delimiting the scene of an incident in Water Street.

Four people injured in Liverpool parade can be named as restrictions lifted after horror crash

Search teams look through a derelict and abandoned property to the west of Praia De Luz, Portugal in the search for Madeleine McCann.

Madeleine McCann detectives drain well as police look for toys and DNA in renewed search

Sir Tony Blair spoke at the SXSW festival in London and said Britain needs to embrace AI.

Tony Blair says Britain should have AI doctors and nurses as former PM claims it's 'absurd' not to do more in the NHS

Pipers at the statue to Robert The Bruce during a re-enactment to commemorate the 700th anniversary of the Battle Of Bannockburn.

Controversial trotting track development at historic Bannockburn battlefield site dismissed

Ukraine’s underwater explosion attack on Crimean Bridge caught on camera

Ukraine’s underwater explosion attack on Crimean Bridge caught on camera

Dutch PM Dick Schoof steps down and far-right leader Geert Wilders quits as Dutch government plunged into chaos

Dutch PM Dick Schoof steps down and far-right leader Geert Wilders quits as Dutch government plunged into chaos

Alzheimer’s disease is the most common cause of dementia

Six things you need to know about Alzheimers - as drug trials bring new hope

Police on duty outside Windsor Castle (file image)

Man in his 30s arrested after breaking into grounds at Windsor Castle

Erin Patterson has admitted feeding poison mushrooms to her relatives

'Toxic mushroom' mum Erin Patterson admits feeding death caps to her relatives but denies murder