Laughing at someone falling over at work is not harassment, judge rules, as pub worker loses tribunal claim

11 April 2023, 21:27

Finding someone falling over at work funny is not harassment, a judge has ruled, as a pub worker lost an employment tribunal claim after his manager laughed when he took a tumble while on shift.
Finding someone falling over at work funny is not harassment, a judge has ruled, as a pub worker lost an employment tribunal claim after his manager laughed when he took a tumble while on shift. Picture: Alamy

By Chris Samuel

Finding someone falling over at work funny is not harassment, a judge has ruled, as a pub worker lost an employment tribunal claim after his manager laughed when he took a tumble.

Kesarajith Perera fell over after slipping on a patch of oil at The George pub in Harrow, which was met with laughter from his boss Hesham Badra.

Mr Perera was dismissed in October over an unrelated matter, following his failure to produce documentation for his proof of right to work in the UK.

He then took establishment's owners to the tribunal, complaining of racial and religious harassment, and cited Mr Badra's reaction to his workplace fall as evidence.

But the claims were dismissed, with employment judge David Maxwell saying the "slapstick element" of someone falling over was likely to cause laughter.

Read more: 'Claps don't pay the bills': Striking junior doctors march on Downing Street as No10 refuses to back down on pay demands

Read more: UK set to become worst performing G7 economy this year as IMF says world economy entering 'perilous phase'

Mr Perera's suggestion that Mr Badra put oil on the floor deliberately in order to cause the slip was also dismissed as “ridiculous”.

The judge found that the “slapstick” nature of someone someone falling over means it is likely to provoke laughter.

"Whilst it might be tempting to hope that one colleague would only ever react in a sympathetic way towards the misfortune of another, common experience suggests this is not always the case," he said.

The tribunal, held in Watford, heard that Mr Perera began at the pub in January 2020 as a member of the kitchen team, and had the fall in March.

Stock image of wet floor sign
Stock image of wet floor sign. Picture: Alamy

The tribunal said: "Unfortunately, it appears to us, Mr Perera has a tendency to jump to conclusions when he encounters misfortune.

“Furthermore, Mr Perera's allegation was undermined by his own evidence, which was to the effect that the location where he fell was one prone to spillages."

The panel concluded that the laughter had nothing to do with Mr Perera's race or religion.

Mr Perera's additional complaint that he had been handed the “full time role of cleaning toilets” was also dismissed.

"Cleaning the toilets could scarcely be made into a full-time role," Judge Maxwell said.

Read more: Man suspected of being Britain's top IRA spy codenamed Stakeknife dies

Read more: Murderer turned in by mum sentenced to life after stabbing schoolboy, 16, in the heart

"Mr Perera's objection was the same as before – this was an unpleasant duty he did not think he should have to carry out."

Throwing his harassment claims, Judge Maxwell said: "None of the treatment complained of had the proscribed purpose or effect.

"The conduct itself, objectively, came nowhere near having the proscribed effect, and his view of matters was unreasonable."

However, panel did rule in Mr Perera's favour regarding unlawful deductions of wages and awarded him £1,426.11.

He was also given £908.91 for the pub’s “abysmal” paperwork after he was not given a written particulars of employment.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Iran's supreme leader has hit back at Trump.

'Nobody knows what I'm gonna do': Trump's cryptic message as Iran brands claims of Washington talks 'despicable lies'

The Adalynn and Front Eagle tankers collided and caught on fire on Tuesday close to the Strait of Hormuz.

Navigational mistake led to oil tanker collision near Strait of Hormuz, says UAE official

Marine experts are set to bring the stricken Bayesian to the surface

Tech tycoon Mike Lynch's sunken superyacht to be raised from the seabed this weekend

Police officers stand next to a restaurant as people protest against overtourism in the Balearic island of Mallorca

Spain: Brits warned of tough rules for holidaying this summer

The Home Office UK Visas & Immigration Office at Lunar House in Croydon, London, UK.

Home Office tells children, aged 11 and eight, they must return to Brazil without parents or face being 'detained'

Yvonne Ford, 59, from Barnsley.

Pictured: Brit grandmother who died from rabies after being scratched by puppy as family issues stark warning

The 35-year-old received the news after earning his biggest win in two years, which also helped him reclaim a spot in the world's top 200 rankings

Dan Evans handed Wimbledon wildcard after stunning win over world No.13 Frances Tiafoe

How Iran could hit back: The growing threat to Western bases as Israeli strikes on Tehran escalate

How Iran could hit back: The growing threat to Western bases as Israeli strikes on Tehran escalate

Jennifer Abbot, 69, was discovered stabbed to death in her Camden home

Manhunt as police search for suspect after woman, 69, stabbed to death in home over 'diamond-encrusted Rolex'

Fenerbahce manager Jose Mourinho.

'We'll make him pay': Leaked Jose Mourinho texts spark scandal in Turkish football

Exclusive
'If you find a gun, you phone the police': Fishing for firearms, knives and grenades in the canals of the North

'If you find a gun, you phone the police': Fishing for firearms, knives and grenades along Britain's canals

Metropolitan Police handout photo of disgraced paedophile Gary Glitter.

Gary Glitter to remain in jail after parole board turn down release bid

Annabel Rook

Children of 'murdered' mother-of-two found in her £1.4m home after gas explosion escaped as they were 'at a sleepover'

Morocco is estimated to have around 3 million stray dogs, known locally as "Beldis"

Brit dies from rabies after contact with stray dog while on holiday in Morocco

A court sketch drawn from a video link shows Erin Patterson giving evidence in her own homicide trial at the Latrobe Valley Magistrates Court in Morwell, Victoria

Woman on trial for 'mushroom murders' should not be found guilty for 'lying', defence argues

Eddie Howe faces decisions over how to line up his squad next season

How Newcastle could line-up for 2025-26