Lucy Letby accuses doctors of conspiracy to blame her for babies' deaths as she denies collecting children's documents

18 May 2023, 14:02 | Updated: 18 May 2023, 14:11

Lucy Letby has accused her colleagues of engaging in a conspiracy to blame her for the babies' deaths
Lucy Letby has accused her colleagues of engaging in a conspiracy to blame her for the babies' deaths. Picture: Shutterstock/Alamy

By Kit Heren

Lucy Letby has claimed doctors at the hospital where she worked as a nurse have conspired to blame her for the deaths of babies she is accused of murdering.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Ms Letby, 33, is accused of murdering seven babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital's neo-natal unit between 2015 and 2016.

She denies the murders, and trying to murder ten other babies.

Listen and subscribe to Unprecedented: Inside Downing Street on Global Player

Ms Letby told Manchester Crown Court on Thursday that a "gang of four" doctors blamed her for the deaths "to cover up failings at the hospital".

Prosecutor Nick Johnson asked her how she felt about her former colleagues during cross-examination.

Mr Johnson went on to ask Ms Letby if she felt there was a "conspiracy" against her, she agreed.

"Who is in the conspiracy group?," Mr Johnson asked.

She named Ravi Jayaram, Stephen Brearey, John Gibbs and another doctor who cannot be named for legal reasons.

Asked what the conspiracy was, Letby she said the four doctors had "apportioned blame onto me".

Read more: Lucy Letby wrote 'I killed them' in notes at home, baby murder trial jury hears

She added that she believed they conspired against her "to cover up things at the hospital."

Letby also denied that she had got "a thrill" from photographing a sympathy card that she and colleagues sent to the parents of a baby girl she is accused of murdering.

Lucy Letby is accused of murdering seven babies and trying to murder ten more
Lucy Letby is accused of murdering seven babies and trying to murder ten more. Picture: Alamy

Letby is said to have killed the baby in question - named as Child I - at the fourth attempt.

The trial heard that she took a picture on her phone of a sympathy card she wrote to be passed to colleagues attending the child's funeral.

Prosecutor Mr Johnson said: "You took a picture of a card, addressed to the parents of a child who had died in dreadful circumstances, at the place where she died."

Read more: Lucy Letby photographed thank you card from parents of two alleged victims as 'something to remember', court hears

Letby said: "The place is insignificant. My usual behaviour is to photograph things that I send or receive."

Mr Johnson asked: "Did it give you a bit of a thrill to photograph it at the place where this poor unfortunate child died?"

Lucy Letby is accused of murdering the babies at the  Countess of Chester Hospital
Lucy Letby is accused of murdering the babies at the Countess of Chester Hospital. Picture: Getty

Letby replied: "Absolutely not."

Jurors have also been told that following her arrest a total of 257 shift handover sheets - some including the names of babies she allegedly harmed - were found at her then home in Chester and her parents' address in Hereford.

One sheet found "in pristine condition" at her address in Westbourne Road, Chester, was dated June 1 2010 - her first day of work as a student at the neonatal unit.

Mr Johnson asked: "Did you have a keepsafe box with roses on it at Westbourne Road?"

Read more: Lucy Letby tells murder trial that baby boy's death at start of her shift was a 'huge unexpected shock'

Read more: ‘I did my best to care for them’: Nurse accused of murdering seven babies gives evidence for the first time

"Yes," said Letby.

Mr Johnson said: "What was in the keepsafe box?"

Letby said: "I can't recall from memory."

Mr Johnson said: "One of the things in that box was that handover sheet, wasn't it?"

Letby said: "I don't have any recollection where the handover sheets were."

Mr Johnson said: "How does it differ from all the other handover sheets?"

Lucy Letby
Lucy Letby. Picture: Shutterstock

Letby said: "It doesn't have any writing on it."

Mr Johnson said: "And it doesn't have any folds in it. It's in pristine condition."

Letby agreed.

Mr Johnson went on: "Some 99 handover sheets from your home as a student."

Letby said: "I wouldn't know."

Mr Johnson said: "You have not been prepared to tell the truth about these handover sheets, have you?"

Letby said: "The truth is what I have told you."

The defendant previously told the jury of eight women and four men that the sheets "inadvertently come home with in my uniform pocket".

Police found 31 handover sheets in a Morrisons bag - her work bag - under her bed.

Mr Johnson asked: "Why put them in the bag at all?"

Letby said: " I can't recall. They are just pieces of paper to me."

Mr Johnson said: "You are not telling the truth, are you?"

Letby said: "I am."

Nurse Lucy Letby
Nurse Lucy Letby. Picture: Alamy

Mr Johnson said: "Why don't you want to tell the truth?"

Letby said: "That is the truth. They have no meaning to me at all. I have copious pieces of paper and cards that I have not thrown away my whole life."

Also discovered in police searches was a blood gas reading of a baby boy, Child M, who she allegedly attempted to murder.

Mr Johnson reminded Letby that a nursing colleague who took the measurement had told the court she would have disposed of the printout in the unit's confidential waste bin.

The prosecutor asked: "When did you fish it out of the bin?"

Lucy Letby pleaded not guilty to seven counts of murder and ten counts of attempted murder
Lucy Letby pleaded not guilty to seven counts of murder and ten counts of attempted murder. Picture: Supplied

Letby said: "I never fished anything out of the confidential bin."

Mr Johnson said: "How did you get it?"

Letby said: "I can't recall specifically."

Mr Johnson said: "It was for your little collection, wasn't it Lucy Letby?"

"No," replied the defendant.


More Latest News

See more More Latest News

France Abortion Right

French lawmakers gather for vote that will make abortion a constitutional right

Bear (L) is due to find out how much of his sex tape profits he must pay back

Stephen Bear arrives at court for confiscation hearing in 'Mexican Cartel' tracksuit after revenge porn conviction

The Middleton family have previously described the businessman as the "black sheep of the family".

'Kate doesn’t need this stress': Princess' uncle 'read riot act by Middletons' amid Celebrity Big Brother rumour

Gerhard Berger's stolen Ferrari has been found nearly 30 years after it was stolen

Gerhard Berger's £350,000 Ferrari stolen in 1995 recovered by police 28 years later

October Rain is the leading song choice, with Dance Forever in second place.

Israel agrees to change controversial October Rain lyrics ahead of Eurovision 2024

Exclusive
Dame Priti Patel told LBC there should be a government review into how the police watchdog is working

‘Corrupt’ minority of police ‘using their position to do terrible things,’ former Home Sec Dame Priti Patel tells LBC

APTOPIX Haiti Violence

Haiti declares a curfew as it tries to restore order after weekend jailbreak

Thailand Politics

Thai court acquits former PM over mishandling of government funds

The hunt for missing Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 could be renewed

Families of passengers on board Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 given new hope of answers

Germany Nursing Home Fire

Four dead and at least 21 injured in nursing home fire in western Germany

Minister quizzed on tweet where he described Trump as 'cancer'

Minister Bim Afolami says tweet in which he referred to Donald Trump as 'a cancer' is appropriate

Election 2024 Haley

Nikki Haley wins her first 2024 Republican primary in District of Columbia

Detective Goodwin also revealed that police discovered Couzens had been suspected of an indecent exposure offence in Kent.

Chilling moment Sarah Everard detective found out that killer Wayne Couzens was a serving police officer

Bim Afolami, an economic secretary to the treasury, joined LBC's Nick Ferrari this morning

Brits on lower and average incomes are ‘better off’ now than they were in 2010, treasury minister insists

Sweden Farewell To Neutrality

Newly enlarged Nato starts Scandinavian drill in defence of Nordic turf

A state of emergency has been declared in Haiti

Thousands of prisoners on the loose in Haiti after armed men storm major Prison leaving at least 12 dead