Pensioner who 'could not breathe' dies three hours after calling for ambulance that was never dispatched

17 February 2024, 22:25

File image of an ambulance vehicle from East Midlands Ambulance Service
File image of an ambulance vehicle from East Midlands Ambulance Service. Picture: Alamy

By Christian Oliver

A pensioner has died three hours after calling for an ambulance that was never dispatched - despite telling the 999 operator she was struggling to breathe.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Janet Lyon, 67, was trying to get through to her GP surgery after paramedics failed to show up on December 27

The grandmother from Leicestershire was earlier told by the 999 operator that her issue was not life-threatening and told her to contact her GP walk-in centre.

East Midlands Ambulance Service said it investigated the call and said it was handled appropriately, but apologised.

The ambulance service said it was experiencing "high demand" at the time of Ms Lyon's call.

File image of NHS Ambulance station with fleet of ambulances
File image of NHS Ambulance station with fleet of ambulances. Picture: Alamy

Read More: Doctor charged with attempted murder following alleged poisoning of pensioner involving 'unknown substances'

Read More: Family's tributes to pensioner, 84, killed by fallen tree in Storm Isha, as man named for first time

Katie Keating, Ms Lyon's daughter, told the BBC she was "enraged" by the ambulance services' response and added that she had submitted a formal complaint.

"I am totally flabbergasted they have not admitted responsibility."

"That was a completely preventable death. She was not given a chance to have any treatment."

According to Ms Lyon's death certificate, she died from pneumonia.

The daughter, from Nottingham, said her mother's lungs were "full of fluid" when she "inwardly drowned" after not being able to breathe.

The pensioner - who had type 2 diabetes and asthma - walked into her son's bedroom on Boxing Day saying she could not breathe and that she needed an ambulance. Her son called 999 just after 5am, Ms Keating said.

Ms Lyon died three hours later with her phone in hand after trying to get seen by her GP.

Ms Keating said her son would have taken her to A&E if the 999 operator had told her to go there.

"The only thing that would have helped was medical intervention," Ms Keating said. "They should have sent an ambulance - she needed oxygen."

In a letter to the family of Ms Lyon, East Midlands Ambulance Service said: "From the information provided during the call, the situation was correctly coded by the EMA [Emergency Medical Advisor] as requiring a category 3 response."

It said it aims to respond to emergency call-outs of this nature within two hours in 90 per cent of these cases.

"At the time of the 999 call our service was experiencing a high demand for emergency responses.

"The caller was correctly advised, via a pre-determined script, that from the information gathered this was not an immediate life-threatening emergency and we would not be sending an emergency ambulance."

East Midlands Ambulance Service said Ms Lyon was advised to go to her local walk-in or urgent care centre or contact her GP. The service told her to call 999 again only if her symptoms worsened or changed.

It said the 999 call was audited and established that the outcome reached was "safe and appropriate".

The service apologised for the distress caused or the advice warning that an ambulance would not be dispatched to Ms Lyon.

It said the second call at 08:23am saying Ms Lyon was not breathing was classed as "category 1" and medics were at the house in two minutes.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Rob and Lindsey Burrow a few weeks before he died

Rob Burrow's wife reveals heartbreaking moment she knew rugby league star 'couldn't go on' with MND struggle

Axel Rudakubana will be 'target number one' in prison

Southport killer Axel Rudakubana's sentence won't be referred to Court of Appeal despite claims it's 'unduly lenient'

The damaged shield

'Risk of radioactive leak' after Russian 'high explosive' drone hits Chernobyl, causing 'significant damage'

The fire broke out at the Chiltern Firehouse

Fire engulfs celebrity haunt Chiltern Firehouse as 100 evacuated from luxury hotel

Trump confirms he will meet Starmer in Washington 'in the next few weeks'

Trump to meet with Starmer in Washington 'in the next few weeks' - as JD Vance slams Europe in fiery speech

Both Meghan and Kate shared Valentine's pictures

Harry and Meghan share sweet Valentine's photo after William and Kate also post romantic picture

Jaden Sheriff.

Man found guilty of killing ex-girlfriend's neighbour over 'blue balls', sentenced to life imprisonment

The woman was attacked by a shark

Horror as woman loses both hands after being mauled by shark as husband desperately fights it off

United States Vice-President JD Vance, second right, meets with Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, third left, during a bilateral meeting on the sidelines of the Munich Security Conference in Munich

'Putin is a liar': Zelenskyy's warning to Trump as Ukraine's leader voices concern over 'risky' phone calls with Russia

Addenbrookes hospital, Cambridge

Children's surgeon suspended after nine operations fall 'below standards' in Cambridge

Lesley Joseph refuses to discuss Pauline Quirke's dementia diagnosis.

'I won't talk about her at the moment': Lesley Joseph refuses to discuss Pauline Quirke's dementia diagnosis

Ada Bikakci

Girl, 9, killed after being hit by London bus, as driver charged with driving while drunk or on drugs

Exclusive
A small group of secondary school pupils working on practical experiments in a chemistry lab.

Ministers should consider shortening school holidays and letting teachers work from home, union chief says

JD Vance

Free speech is 'in retreat' across Europe, claims JD Vance - as US brands it a 'bigger threat than Russia'

oxford street with shoppers

Two arrested in Oxford St 'celebrity romance scam' after victims coerced into sending £200k to 'well-known boyfriends'

What if Ukraine were the UK? Could you accept surrendering a fifth of our country to Putin after so much sacrifice?

What if Ukraine were the UK? Could you accept surrendering a fifth of our country to Putin after so much sacrifice?