Predators caught before they abuse children face tougher sentences

13 May 2021, 00:02 | Updated: 13 May 2021, 08:57

Under the proposed changes, judges and magistrates would have to base their sentence on what a defendant intended to do to a child
Under the proposed changes, judges and magistrates would have to base their sentence on what a defendant intended to do to a child. Picture: PA

By Patrick Grafton-Green

Child sex offenders caught before they can abuse a minor could face up to 14 years in prison under a proposed new sentencing guidelines.

A three-month consultation has been launched on proposals to treat would-be offenders based on the offence they intend to commit.

Many sexual predators are caught every year through police operations and citizen groups either posing as children or under-age teenagers, or as adults offering to traffic children to be abused.

Others are in communication with a real child or other abusers, but are arrested before they commit physical abuse.

READ MORE: 29 men charged over rape of one female child across seven-year period

Under current guidance, published in 2013, some judges and magistrates have treated these offences as "low" harm, even though the defendant intended to commit a very serious offence.

The lack of harm to an actual child has also been treated as a mitigating factor in sentencing, meaning the offender gets a lesser punishment than those who succeeded in carrying out an attack.

The crimes affected by the proposed changes are arranging or facilitating the commission of a child sexual offence and causing or inciting a child to engage in sexual activity.

These would be treated with the same level of gravity regardless of whether a child was involved.

Currently the maximum penalty for these offences is 14 years in cases where a child comes to harm.

Under the proposed changes, judges and magistrates would have to base their sentence on what a defendant intended to do to a child, but would then be able to adjust sentences downwards based on what took place.

The final sentence would also be determined by aggravating and mitigating factors specific to the offence and offender, the Sentencing Council, which sets out guidance to judges and magistrates in England and Wales, said.

Sentencing Council member Lord Justice Fulford said: "The changes we are proposing today will make sure the courts give the proper weight to the harm intended by those who commit offences against children.

"When an offender intends sexual activity with a child, that must be reflected in the sentence imposed, even where that activity does not ultimately take place."

There are also new draft guidelines for the offence of sexual communication with a child.

Offenders would face up to two years in prison for sharing images, causing psychological harm, abuse of trust or the use of threats.

The council is also proposing that remote offences perpetrated against children overseas are treated as seriously as sexual communication with victims in England and Wales.

The National Police Chiefs' Council lead for online child sexual exploitation, Dan Vajzovic, said: "We welcome the Sentencing Council's approach, which recognises the dreadful harm intended by sexual predators, and which should see prison sentences handed down for harm to a child which are more proportionate, consistent and better reflect the abhorrent nature of child abuse."

Justice minister Chris Philp said: "Vile predators who seek to sexually abuse children deserve punishments that reflect the true severity of their crimes, including the harm intended.

"Alongside our plans for tougher sentences, set out in the Queen's Speech, these guidelines will help keep children safe and ensure perpetrators are held fully to account for their behaviour."

The consultation will close on August 13.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Pictures of the Week Global Photo Gallery

Iran fires air defence batteries at two sites after drones spotted

Israel strikes back at Iran: Explosions heard and airspace closed as revenge attack launched

Israel strikes back at Iran: Explosions heard following revenge attack - days after Tehran's drone assault

India Election Narendra Modi

India starts voting as Narendra Modi seeks third term as prime minister

Rishi Sunak is to call for an end to the "sick note culture".

End of the 'sick note': Rishi Sunak to stop GPs signing people off work in welfare scheme overhaul

Andrew Malkinson

'Too little, too late': Andrew Malkinson rejects Criminal Cases Review Commission's apology after being wrongly jailed

Argentina NATO

Argentina asks to join Nato as President Milei seeks more prominent role

An officer threatened to arrest the man for 'breaching the peace'

Shocking moment Met police officer threatens to arrest man for being 'quite openly Jewish' at pro-Palestine march

Israel Palestinians UN Security Council

US vetoes widely supported UN resolution backing full membership for Palestine

Trump Hush Money

Twelve jurors confirmed for Trump hush money trial

Exclusive
Jonathan Hall KC admitted refugees have previously been let into the UK without the full checks.

Refugees have been admitted to UK ‘without proper checks’ as Border Force is 'too overwhelmed’, terror watchdog says

Jeremy Clarkson was seen comforting his girlfriend, Lisa Hogan, after tragedy stuck Diddly Squat Farm when two piglets died in an emotional scene captured on an episode of Clarkson's Farm

Jeremy Clarkson comforts sobbing girlfriend after tragedy strikes Diddly Squat Farm in new series

Lord Nick Houghton speaks to LBC’s Andrew Marr.

Ukraine 'is fighting proxy war on behalf of Nato', says ex-military chief as he criticises 'incoherent' defence spending

Peter Murrell has been charged in connection with the embezzlement of funds from the Scottish National Party.

Nicola Sturgeon's husband Peter Murrell charged in connection with embezzlement of funds from SNP

Kenya’s military chief General Francis Ogolla

Kenya’s military chief dies in helicopter crash

Sydney Sweeney hit back at the comments about her.

Sydney Sweeney hits back at 'sad and shameful' producer who said she ‘can’t act’ and ‘isn’t pretty’

Exclusive
Jonathan Hall has hit out at WhatsApp over the lowering of the age limit.

UK’s terror watchdog hits out at WhatsApp over lowering of age limit as he says more kids are being radicalised online