Baby allegedly murdered by nurse Lucy Letby had 'extraordinary discoloured patches' doctor had never seen before

20 October 2022, 20:00

Lucy Letby is accused of murdering seven babies
Lucy Letby is accused of murdering seven babies. Picture: LBC

By Kit Heren

A baby allegedly murdered by children's nurse Lucy Letby had "extraordinary" patches of discoloured skin before dying - which a doctor had never seen before.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Letby is in Manchester Crown Court accused of the murder of seven babies and attempted murder of ten more. She denies all charges.

Child A, who was born prematurely in Countess of Chester Hospital, died 24 hours later on June 8, 2015 after deteriorating very rapidly and unexpectedly, the court heard on Thursday.

The doctor who was called in to care for him said Child A's death did not fit the pattern of how unwell babies look as their condition gets worse.

Read more: 'Taking newborn to the mortuary was the hardest thing I've had to do', says Lucy Letby

Dr Harkness said: "It was incredibly unexpected. This was a completely stable, well baby who had no reason to deteriorate. I was very surprised to be called back.

Nurse accused of murdering seven babies wrote ‘I am evil I did this’, court told

"There was very unusual patchiness on his skin which I had not seen before. There were patches of blue/purple colour, patches of red and of white that didn't fit.

"This was bright red patches... that means you have blood going round your body." He said the patches were all over the body and were "there from shortly after the event started".

"It didn't come and go," said Dr Harkness. "It came. It was there. He had a cardiac arrest. Unfortunately I have seen lots of babies who have had the pattern that fits with death or dying and I have not seen these."

Medical experts to appear at nurse's murder trial

Child A died shortly after 9pm that night. The prosecution says Letby injected a fatal amount of air into Child A's bloodstream within 90 minutes of coming on duty.

The defence do not accept an air bubble, was the cause of death and say the care given to Child A on the unit - not by Letby - was "suboptimal".

Dr Harkness agreed with defence lawyer Ben Myers KC, that the discoloured patches struck him personally as "something quite extraordinary".

Read more: 'I am evil, I did this': Nurse accused of killing babies 'wrote confession note,' murder trial hears

But the medic accepted he did not make a recorded note of those particular skin colour changes at the time.

He said it was "something I only picked up later" when similar further incidents with babies took place at the hospital.

Mr Myers said: "Certainly by the time you came to make your police statement in July 2018, you talk about the colour changes then?"

A prison van believed to contain former nurse Lucy Letby leaves Chester Crown Court
A prison van believed to contain former nurse Lucy Letby leaves Chester Crown Court. Picture: Getty

"Yes," said Dr Harkness.

Mr Myers said: "I am going to suggest that you have been influenced in that recollection by conversations that have taken place about skin colours?"

"No," said the medic. "This was worth mentioning because it was a pattern recognition.

"At the time this was one of my first neo-natal deaths I had to deal with as a registrar. I was in tears. I required time off work."

The murder trial heard Lucy Letby penned notes saying "I am evil, I did this"
Lucy Letby. Picture: Shutterstock

The doctor accepted he also did not mention the "striking" skin patchiness in a statement to the coroner ahead of Child A's inquest in October 2016 when he said he thought he was "still upset".

Mr Myers said: "I am going to suggest there is a possibility that by this point the discussions had set in your mind about this colour when it really had not been there at all."

Dr Harkness replied: "No."

Asked by junior prosecutor Simon Driver if he was sure about Child A's skin discolour, he said: "Categorically yes. There was skin discolouring."

The jury has been told Child A did not have intravenous fluids for up to four hours on June 8 before he received glucose through a "long line" plastic tube at 8.05pm, co-signed by Letby and fellow nurse Melanie Taylor.

Children's nurse Lucy Letby who faces 22 charges of murder and attempted murder
Lucy Letby. Picture: Shutterstock

Earlier on the shift, a cannula to a blood vessel stopped working, followed by two attempts to correctly insert a catheter in the belly button, which failed.

Dr Harkness fitted the long line but removed it shortly after Child A's sudden deterioration, the court was told.

Read more: Mother begged staff 'please don't let my baby die' as medics tried to save him, Lucy Letby trial hears

He later queried in his contemporaneous notes whether the procedure could be linked to Child A's death.

He told the court: "It was a knee-jerk reaction because in my mind this is the last thing that changed so should be the first thing to go. But there is no evidence then or since to support that as being the cause."

John and Susan Letby, parents of Lucy Letby, are at Manchester Crown Court for their daughter's murder trial (pictured last week)
John and Susan Letby, parents of Lucy Letby. Picture: Alamy

Dr Harkness said he initially thought the line's position was less than perfect but revised his opinion after a review with his consultant colleagues the next day.

Ms Taylor told jurors she could not remember whether she or Letby administered the glucose.

The court also heard from Lisa Walker, a neonatal nursery assistant who had worked at the unit for about seven years.

She said she had only known a "couple of deaths" during that time.

Read more: Children's nurse Lucy Letby 'injected babies with air and insulin' court hears as she denies murdering seven newborns

"I remember coming in to work to see another baby had died and remember thinking, 'What on Earth is happening?' she said.

A court order prohibits reporting of the identities of surviving and dead children allegedly attacked by Letby, and also prohibits identifying parents or witnesses connected with the children.

Letby, originally from Hereford, denies all the offences said to have been committed between June 2015 and June 2016.