‘Others have had it restored after worse things’: Forde report author says, as calls grow to return whip to Diane Abbott

17 March 2024, 15:22 | Updated: 17 March 2024, 15:31

Watch again: Sangita Myska speaks to Martin Forde KC

By Jenny Medlicott

The author of the Labour Party’s Forde report has said he is 'at a loss’ as to why Diane Abbott has not had the Labour whip restored.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Ms Abbott had the Labour whip removed almost a year ago in an anti-Semitism row after she suggested Jewish people did not face lifelong racism.

But now Labour has faced calls to return the whip to the MP for Hackney North and Stoke Newington after Tory donor Frank Hester made alleged ‘racist’ comments about Ms Abbott.

Frank Hester, a donor who has given £10m to the party, is claimed to have said that Ms Abbott made him "want to hate all black women" and that she "should be shot".

Martin Forde KC was commissioned to carry out the Fore report in 2020, a report into allegations of bullying, racism and misogyny within the Labour Party, which was published in 2022.

Speaking to LBC’s Sangita Myska, Mr Forde said that the report resulted in “a disturbing amount of complaints about racism, other than anti-Semitism, within the party and misogyny.”

He continued: “What we found in essence was a disciplinary system that just wasn’t fit for purpose.

Read more: 'It's been a difficult week': Diane Abbott thanks marchers who joined allies at anti-hate protest after Tory donor row

Read more: Tory donor who said Diane Abbott 'should be shot' gives 'further £5m' to party after he is reported to police

Members of the public rallied in support of Diane Abbot on Saturday.
Members of the public rallied in support of Diane Abbot on Saturday. Picture: Getty

“Huge backlogs, seem to be more fast-tracking of complaints in relation to anti-Semitism and misogyny than anti-black or anti-muslim, racism, or other protected characteristics.”

Reacting to calls to restore the whip to Ms Abbott, Mr Forde said: “If all there is, and I emphasise this, is what she said, which the party were unhappy with 11 months ago, if that’s all there is, then I am at a loss to understand why it’s taken as long as it has.

“If she offered a swift apology, why does that differ from apologies that have been offered by others, including members of and well politicians within the Labour party who had the whip restored, many would argue for saying or stating far worse things than Diane Abbott.

“It’s the lack of consistency that is troubling.”

Despite mounting calls to restore the whip to Ms Abbott, earlier this week Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer refused to say whether he would let Ms Abbott back in the party.

He acknowledged that she had faced a lot of abuse, but also insisted that the issue could not be conflated with the ongoing investigation into her comments almost a year ago.

Sir Keir Starmer refused to say whether he would restore the whip to Ms Abbott.
Sir Keir Starmer refused to say whether he would restore the whip to Ms Abbott. Picture: Alamy

Sir Keir told LBC: “The abuse against Diane Abbott that’s gone on for many, many years is abhorrent and Diane has suffered more abuse than any other MP – usually racist and misogynistic – but all sorts of abuse," Sir Keir said.

"She’s been a trailblazer as a black MP, paving the way for other people, and all that is to be applauded.

"There’s the separate question of what she said and the investigation into that which needs to be resolved - I don't think you can just conflate the two."

It comes after members of the public rallied in support of Ms Abbott at an anti-hate protest on Saturday.

Crowds gathered outside the Home Office to protest against the rise of racism and hatred and to support the independent MP.

Ms Abbott thanked protestors after the march, saying they were there to "unite against all forms of racism.

"It's been a difficult week. It's not easy hearing about the things that have been said about me.

"But as many black people can testify, it's not just the racist incident that's hard to endure, it's the institutional, systemic and structural racism that follows it.

"This isn't about me. This is about the level of racism that exists today."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Police chiefs have been told to arrest fewer people due to a shortage of space for prisoners across England and Wales.

Police chiefs told to arrest fewer people to save space in overcrowded prisons

Rudy Giuliani

Rudy Giuliani pleads not guilty in Arizona election interference case

Donald Trump

Trump campaign says it will begin accepting cryptocurrency contributions

Prince Harry 'turned down the King's invitation to stay at a royal residence'.

Prince Harry ‘turned down King’s offer to stay in royal residence’ during UK trip because it ‘didn't come with security'

A screenshot taken from AP video showing a general view of northern Gaza as seen from southern Israel, before it was seized by Israeli officials

Israel says it will return video equipment seized from news organisation AP

Craig Mackinlay has said he wants to be known as the first 'bionic MP' after losing both his arms and legs to sepsis.

‘I’m the bionic MP’: Craig Mackinlay says he’s ‘lucky to be alive’ as he reveals he lost both feet and hands to sepsis

Former US president Donald Trump sits in Manhattan Criminal Court in New York

Defence rests without Donald Trump entering witness box in hush money trial

A veterinarian feeds a young howler monkey rescued amid extremely high temperatures in Tecolutilla, Tabasco state, Mexico

Howler monkeys ‘falling out of the trees like apples’ in sweltering Mexico

Mobile coverage is being expanded across the network.

Full list of London Underground stations to receive phone signal this summer - is yours listed?

Prince William hosted a garden party on behalf of his father King Charles

Prince William hosts rain-soaked Buckingham Palace garden party in absence of King Charles

Jan A P Kaczmarek poses with the Oscar for best original score for his work on Finding Neverland during the 77th Academy Awards in February 2005 in Los Angeles

Composer Jan A P Kaczmarek, Oscar winner for Finding Neverland, dies aged 71

Lawbreaking from the extreme-left is just as bad from the extreme-right, Robin Simcox has told LBC.

Lawbreaking by Just Stop Oil is as bad as similar acts by extreme-right, Commissioner for Countering Extremism says

Fred Roos

Fred Roos, Godfather Part II producer and longtime Coppola collaborator, dies

Matthew Trickett, 37, who was on bail after appearing in court accused of assisting the Hong Kong intelligence service

Former Royal Marine charged with spying for China on Hong Kong activists found dead in park in 'unexplained death'

Smokes rise to the sky after explosions in the Gaza Strip, as seen from southern Israel

UN halts food distribution in Rafah due to lack of supplies and insecurity

57 cases of cryptosporidium have been confirmed in Brixham

More than 50 people in Devon ill from contaminated water as suppliers announce £3.5m compensation