375,000 vulnerable patients were missed by shielding alert, watchdog finds

10 February 2021, 07:20 | Updated: 10 February 2021, 10:15

A watchdog found 375,000 people who should have shielded could not be reached
A watchdog found 375,000 people who should have shielded could not be reached. Picture: PA

By Asher McShane

Hundreds of thousands of clinically vulnerable people were not told to shield at the start of the coronavirus pandemic due to out-of-date records, according to a report.

Whitehall spending watchdog the National Audit Office (NAO) said a lack of contingency planning meant officials had to scramble to create from scratch a system to identify those who might need support while they were unable to leave their homes

In doing so, they had had to rely on hospital records that were weeks out of date or with missing or inaccurate telephone numbers, meaning some had to wait weeks before they were able to get deliveries of food or medicines.

Read more: Quarantine hotels: £10k fine and prison threat for hiding 'red list' visits

Read more: Nick Ferrari scrutinises Grant Shapps over "oppressive" 10 year travel sentence

A contact centre set up to reach those who had not registered for the scheme online or through an automated telephone line was unable to reach 375,000 people.

Shapps: 'Nobody should be going on holiday or travelling round UK'

Meanwhile, 126,000 people were contacted in error and wrongly advised to shield when they did not need to do so.

The Government originally announced on March 22 - just before the first national lockdown - that an estimated 1.5 million of those considered "clinically extremely vulnerable" (CEV) should stay home for the next 12 weeks.

However the NAO said that a 2016 exercise to test for preparedness for a flu pandemic codenamed Exercise Cygnus had not covered the need for vulnerable people to shield.

It meant there was no system in place to allow a fast "sweep" across all patient data to identify those who should be on the list and who may need support.

Initially, NHS Digital was forced to rely on hospital, maternity and prescribed medicines data - even though the hospital records were seven weeks out of date.

The first list identified some 870,000 people who were identified as CEV and were sent letters advising them to shield.

By April 12, NHS Digital had managed to identify a further 420,000 through the use of GP data while a further 900,000 were added to the list between April 18 and May 7, taking the total to 2.2 million.

In an attempt to ensure all those who were eligible for support registered with the scheme - whether they needed help or not - the Government commissioned a contact centre to reach those who had not signed up.

However, of the 1.8 million names they were given, 375,000 could not be reached because of missing or inaccurate phone numbers in NHS patient records, while a further 440,000 declined to register - in some cases hanging up because they thought it was a nuisance call.

In all, more than 510,000 people were supported through the scheme to the start of August at a cost to the taxpayer of £308 million - of which £200 million was spent on food boxes.

The NAO said that the Department of Health and Social Care was unable to say whether shielding led to fewer deaths or cases of serious illness among the clinically vulnerable - although it was "likely" that it helped.

The head of the NAO, Gareth Davies, said: "The shielding programme was an important response to support clinically extremely vulnerable people asked to shield.

"However, challenges pulling together data meant it took time to quickly identify those needing to shield, and therefore eligible for support."

Meg Hillier, the chair of the Commons Public Accounts Committee, said: "Government quickly identified the need to support vulnerable people at the onset of the pandemic. But with nothing prepared, Government had to build its shielding programme from scratch.

"Nearly a million people were not eligible for support for weeks while the Government scrambled to gather basic information. Meanwhile, too many vulnerable people were left confused by Government's mixed messages."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

NHS 999 staff are quitting and suffering burnout caused by the "relentless pressure" of calls, according to new research.

NHS 999 staff quitting and suffering burnout due to ‘relentless pressure’ of calls, research finds

Using a mobile phone to use TikTok video sharing site

Patients who record NHS care for TikTok or Instagram causing workers unnecessary anxiety

Russ Cook

Gen-Z adults with a fitness regime ‘more likely to have a financial plan’

Daytime view of a busy Oxford Street

Sir Sadiq Khan to pedestrianise Oxford Street ‘as quickly as possible’

Low water levels at Baitings dam near Ripponden following a very dry spring

England faces ‘huge’ water shortages of 5bn litres a day by 2055, officials warn

Merthyr Tydfil Crown Court in Wales.

Driver handed 10-year sentence after ramming pedestrians, including teenager, with SUV in Airbnb row

Vinicius Junior of Real Madrid celebrates a goal.

Four people given suspended prison sentences for hate crimes after hanging effigy of Real Madrid star

Electricity prices in the UK are high because of the "insane" wholesale market, Parliament has been told.

UK electricity prices ‘way too high’ because of ‘insane’ wholesale market, Parliament told

Detectives have released CCTV footage of a man they wish to speak to following an attempted rape

Bid to trace man as police investigate attempted rape of woman in cinema

Exclusive
Jess Phillips on LBC

Victims deserve credit for grooming gangs national inquiry - not Elon Musk, says Labour minister

Israel attacked Iran's state broadcaster IRIB during a live broadcast.

Israel accused of 'war crime' after bombing Iran's state TV studio live on air and warning it would 'disappear'

The Holiday Inn Express in Rotherham, England, where Britain's Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner will visit on Wednesday Aug. 7, 2024 following riots

Pregnant teenager facing jail term following role in Rotherham riots targeting migrant hotel

Hamilton started the race in fifth and looked to be on course for a positive 70 laps - before his Grand Prix was impacted in the initial stages.

Lewis Hamilton is left 'devastated' after hitting a furry animal at 100mph in F1's Canadian Grand Prix

Gareth Bale is reportedly being lined up to front a takeover of League One side Plymouth

Gareth Bale in talks to front shock US takeover of League One club

DJ John Reid has died suddenly aged 61

Top DJ dies suddenly aged 61 as music stars pay tribute

Britain's Prime Minister Keir Starmer speaks to the media at the G7 summit, in Kananaskis, Alberta, Canada, Monday, June 16, 2025.

'Israel has right to defend itself - and Iran cannot have nuclear weapons', say world leaders at G7 summit in Canada