Opinion: Rishi's Budget leaves an open goal for the SNP

28 October 2021, 14:45

The Chancellor’s cuts to booze duty will be scant consolation for people in Scotland struggling to heat their homes, writes Gina Davidson
The Chancellor’s cuts to booze duty will be scant consolation for people in Scotland struggling to heat their homes, writes Gina Davidson. Picture: Alamy
Gina Davidson

By Gina Davidson

A message to the Chancellor: when people are struggling to afford to eat, when people are struggling to afford to heat their homes, a few pence off the price of a bottle of prosecco really doesn’t cut it.

In a budget which in many respects was aimed squarely at taking the wind out of the SNP’s sails, the Chancellor failed in two major areas to really prove that the union matters - and those failures will be remembered long after people have forgotten that a handful of council projects got some cash through the levelling up fund.

There are 613,000 Scottish households already living in fuel poverty - 311,000 of these considered to be extremely fuel poor - before the last few months’ extreme hikes in energy costs. It’s been predicted that another 100,000 households will be plunged into fuel poverty as a result of the energy crisis.

READ MORE: Middle income families face paying ‘£3,000’ more in tax after Rishi Sunak’s Budget

READ MORE: Chancellor defends Prosecco price cut claiming it is 'not the preserve of wealthy elites'

Fuel poverty is felt across the UK but it’s the northern-most, rural areas of Scotland who feel it most sharply as temperatures plummet. With Mr Sunak’s decision not to cut VAT on energy bills, the Chancellor has done nothing to help those people, and he’s left an open goal for the SNP.

Similarly he turned his face against reinstating the £20 Universal Credit uplift which came to an end in September. Yes, there has been a welcome change to the tapering in UC, so those on incomes so low they still have to rely on the benefit, will have some more money in their pockets. But, and it’s a very big but, it doesn’t help the 60 per cent of Scots on UC who are not in work. They are still dealing with a £1,000 cut to their benefit, while facing rising energy and food costs.

Research has also shown that 1.4m people in Scotland ran out of money before pay day during the pandemic, and there was nothing in the budget which suggests that will improve.

Of course, the Chancellor did splash the cash on health and education and other public services (apparently forgetting which party had instigated austerity in the first place); money which will, given the Barnett formula mechanism, see the Scottish budget rise by £4.6m.

And the levelling up fund kills two birds with one stone for the Conservatives: firstly, it circumvents the Scottish Government by directly funding projects councils would like to see up and running (including SNP local authorities) and while the SNP in the Scottish Parliament will argue this undermines devolution, the Tory counter to that is this is devolution in action - but just beyond the confines of Holyrood.

And although Michael Gove and others say they don’t care just who gets the credit for this funding - Westminster or Holyrood - come next May’s council elections that message will undoubtedly change.

Secondly, it gives No voters a new peg on which to hang their economic arguments against Scottish independence. Look, they will say, not only has the Scottish Government’ budget risen to its highest allocation since devolution, there’s this extra cash too - why would anyone want to end all this apparent largesse?

Certainly the numbers are big and all eyes are now on the Scottish finance minister Kate Forbes to see what she will do with the money when she sets her budget on December 9.

But there is still a perfect cost of living storm facing Scots - and others - this winter and a cheap bottle of plonk is not a solution that.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

An elderly old age pensioner sits with his hands on a walking stick in a care home.

Gut bacteria changes could be ‘warning sign for worsening Parkinson’s symptoms’

Karen Bass says the restrictions will be in force in downtown areas of LA from 8pm to 6am local time (4am to 2pm UK time).

Los Angeles mayor imposes curfew 'to stop the looting' on fifth day of clashes against immigration raids

The report added that it should become easier for parents to organise “safe play” in their streets, and there should be a national ban on “No Ball Games” signs.

'Too much screen time, not enough play': Calls to ban ‘No Ball Games’ signs to reduce children's reliance on smartphones

The ASA did not uphold complaints about Price appearing to be unhealthily thin, and concluded that the ad was not irresponsible on that basis.

'Not empowering - just objectifying': Advertising watchdog bans Diesel ad featuring Katie Price

A number of homes and police vehicles were damaged during the riotous behaviour.

Police use water cannon in Ballymena after petrol bombs thrown at officers in second night of disorder

Bowel cancer patient Kelly Buckle, 40, is operated on during a state-of-the-art robot assisted surgery performed by the NHS at Solihull Surgical Hub in Solihull Hospital, West Midlands.

Robotic surgery set to soar in NHS as 90% of all keyhole surgeries to be assisted by robots in decade

Despite weaker demand, renters are still facing a limited supply of homes for rent, Zoopla said.

'Still being squeezed': Rent rises slow to four-year low but low-income tenants say crisis far from over

Jude Bellingham and Morgan Rogers of England acknowledge the fans after the teams defeat in the international friendly match between England and Senegal at City Ground on June 10, 2025.

Tuchel insists ‘no need to panic’ as England booed off for second time in four days after shock defeat against Senegal

The biggest lottery prize the UK has seen could still be won after Tuesday’s EuroMillions draw had no winners.

EuroMillions jackpot rolls over again as UK’s largest ever prize of £208m is unclaimed

The violence flared following an earlier peaceful protest in support of the family of a girl who was the victim of an alleged sexual assault in the town at the weekend.

Missiles thrown at police in second night of Northern Ireland disorder following protest over alleged sexual assault

Emergency services at the scene on Russell Close in Heckmondwike, West Yorkshire, where a man and a nine-year-old girl died in a house fire on Sunday morning.

Father and nine-year-old daughter that died in house fire named, as girl, 11, still fighting for life in hospital

The global superstar has reportedly offered seats to her London tour at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium to families in need through food banks across the city.

Beyoncé 'gives away' gig tickets to low-income families after struggling to fill seats at Cowboy Carter London tour

from next month, women aged 25 to 49 in England who are negative for human papillomavirus (HPV) will receive screening invites every five years.

Cervical screening invites to be sent out every five years for some women in new NHS changes

Alex Eastwood

Kickboxer, 15, who died after charity match had fought 34-year-old man week before

Exclusive
The government is to introduce extra measures to protect emergency workers from religious and racist abuse, LBC has learned.

New laws to clamp down on racial and religious abuse of emergency workers, LBC learns

British Police Officers in London England UK

Police officers sacked for gross misconduct to be blocked from joining local forces in drive to improve standards