Four boys who fell into freezing Solihull lake died from drowning, inquest finds

19 December 2022, 10:01 | Updated: 19 December 2022, 10:25

The four boys who died after falling through a frozen lake in Solihull have been named as Thomas Stewart,11, Jack Johnson, 10, Finlay Butler, eight, and Samuel Butler, six.
The four boys who died after falling through a frozen lake in Solihull have been named as Thomas Stewart,11, Jack Johnson, 10, Finlay Butler, eight, and Samuel Butler, six. Picture: West Midlands Police / Facebook

By Kit Heren

The four boys who passed away after falling into a freezing cold lake in Solihull last week died from drowning, an inquest has found.

Finlay Butler, eight, and his younger brother Samuel, six, both died, alongside their cousin Thomas Stewart, 11, and another boy, Jack Johnson, 10, who rushed to help the trio.

The boys were pulled out of the water at Babbs Mill park near Birmingham on December 11.

They were in the water for more than 20 minutes after the emergency services were called for the first time, the inquest heard on Monday.

Two of the young boys who died after falling through an icy lake in Solihull were brothers, it has been revealed, as a fundraiser for the victims reaches £17,000.
Two of the young boys who died after falling through an icy lake in Solihull were brothers, it has been revealed, as a fundraiser for the victims reaches £17,000. Picture: Alamy / Getty

Three of the boys were pulled out after 22 minutes, with the fourth retrieved seven minutes later.

Birmingham and Solihull coroner Louise Hunt said the families of the boys had her sincere condolences, adding that it was a "devastating tragedy".

Ms Hunt said that it was difficult to understand the pain the relatives of the boys will be feeling.

The full inquest into all four deaths will take place in July.

Mourners visit the scene of the deaths
Mourners visit the scene of the deaths. Picture: Getty

It comes after three of the boys' parents paid tribute to the "beautiful" children.

They said: "As a family we are devastated at the loss of our beautiful boys Tom, Fin and Sam in such tragic circumstances.

"We would like to thank the emergency services for all they did in rescuing the boys and to the community for their support, it has been overwhelming.

"We would like to pass on our condolences to Jack’s family at this very sad time, and ask for privacy from the media to begin to grieve."

Thomas' older brother paid tribute to him and his cousin before Samuel died.

People of Solihul lay tributes in memory of children after tragedy

He said: "Thomas was such a lively little soul, he had a big heart for such a young kid and he was so beautiful.

"He loved being outside playing with his mates. I love you Tom, big bro will take care of the family and I will see you soon. Make sure you keep practising on [video game] Warzone and get a win, will you?"

"Can't forget about my dinosaur man Fin, he loved dinosaurs so much and always showing me new things he built on Minecraft and all the new stuff he learnt on it. Gonna miss you little man."

One of the boy's fathers, a student police officer, and a dog walker had entered the water in an attempt to save the children.

Birmingham City FC manager John Eustace lays wreath in memory of Solihull children after tragedy

An official fundraiser has now been set up for the families of the four boys, which has raised over £17,000.It is backed by the families involved, and a number of relatives have shared it online.

The page bio pays tribute to the 'four Little Princes', and adds: "No parent expects to lose their children so young, and sadly, no amount of money would ever place them back in our arms, but with our help, we can hopefully ease the worry of the financial costs they will need to meet."

There was a candlelit vigil for the boys on Monday night, with a second taking place this Saturday at 4pm.

Emergency services on the lake
Emergency services on the lake. Picture: Getty
Emergency services at the scene
Emergency services at the scene. Picture: Getty
Police officers at the scene
Police officers at the scene. Picture: Getty

Emergency services were first called to the scene at 2.36pm on Sunday, where it was reported that four children had been playing on the ice and fallen through into the lake.

Police officers and members of the public initially got into the water tried to get the children out, before the youngsters were reached by specialist firefighters trained for water rescue who got the group to safety.

Read more: Brothers, 6 and 8, and cousin, 11, killed alongside hero friend, 10, in frozen lake tragedy as families pay tribute

Read more: Fourth boy, aged six, dies after falling through frozen lake in Solihull

Those pulled out of the lake were given immediate life support and rushed to two hospitals; Birmingham Children's and Heartlands.

You can find the fundraiser for the families here.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

J.K. Rowling

Harry Potter stars take swipe at JK Rowling as they sign open letter supporting trans people

Bernard Morgan, 100, shows a letter to school children as he joins Second World War veterans at a tea party organized by the Royal British Legion at The Ritz, London.

50,000 kids write moving letters to WWII veterans ahead of 80th anniversary VE day celebrations

A court sketch shows Erin Patterson at the Latrobe Valley Magistrates Court in Morwell, Victoria, Tuesday, April 29, 2025.

Deadly Beef Wellington lunch ‘terrible accident’, court hears - as woman accused of murdering guests with mushrooms

Erin Cuthbert, Guro Reiten, and Millie Bright of Chelsea celebrate following their team's victory in a Barclays Women's Super League match between Manchester United and Chelsea FC at Leigh Sports Village on April 30, 2025 in Leigh, England.

Lucy Bronze heads in winner as Chelsea win sixth successive WSL title with 1-0 win over Man United

Summer Clarke, now 26, was given a 10% chance to live, with her family told to say their "goodbyes" when she suffered a spontaneous brain haemorrhage.

Woman who suffered stroke at 24 and given 10% chance to live ‘could sing before speaking’

Sara Sharif was murder by her father in Surrey back in 2023

Murder of ten-year-old Sara Sharif leads to renewed calls for smacking ban

School classroom

Calls for schools to deliver more ‘relationship violence prevention lessons’ after Netflix's Adolescence

Rubbish in the street outside Ward End Park

May Day talks to take place in bid to resolve Birmingham bin strike

A co-ordinated 24-hour global strike is being held demanding fair pay, improved working conditions, and greater protections for gig economy drivers.

Private hire drivers go on global strike as thousands walk out for better pay and conditions

It comes as a poll of 1,800 adults in England found that almost one in four (23%) had found inaccuracies or missing details in their medical records.

Medical record errors ‘putting patients at risk’

Striking school support workers taking part in a demonstration outside First Minister John Swinney's constituency office in Blairgowrie.

Council workers sent strike ballots in ‘biggest vote of its kind in years’

Health campaigners have called on the Government to take urgent action to protect infants and young children following a study that found top brands are selling sugar-heavy, nutritionally poor baby food.

Infants and young children should be protected from sugar-heavy unhealthy baby food, campaigners say

The takeaway has been accused of "ripping people off" after it hiked the price of haddock to £8.20.

Fish and chip shop accused of 'ripping people off' as price of haddock hiked to £8.20

A British woman was found beaten to death before her body was discovered in Tremolat, France.

British mother of four, 65, found beaten to death outside her home in picturesque French village

Exclusive
Sadiq Khan

'I'm a proud Englishman', Sir Sadiq Khan says, as he praises 'proper patriotism' - but warns of 'poison of far-right'

Clive Standish, pictured in 2007

Sheep-farming former banker gave wife £80m to avoid paying inheritance tax before they divorced