Major Labour U-turn with MPs set to vote on scrapping Winter Fuel Payment for millions

5 September 2024, 12:23 | Updated: 9 September 2024, 09:17

Tories force Labour U-turn over plans to scrap Winter Fuel Payment for millions of pensioners
Tories force Labour U-turn over plans to scrap Winter Fuel Payment for millions of pensioners. Picture: alamy

By Danielle de Wolfe

The Conservatives have forced a major Labour U-turn over plans to scrap Winter Fuel Payments to millions of pensioners.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Labour had previously said they would not hold a vote on the decision to cut Winter Fuel Payments - a controversial policy that has faced considerable backlash from Conservatives and Labour MPs alike.

The proposed plans from Labour would see 10 million people stripped of their fuel allowance this winter.

However, Thursday's announcement appeared to show a dramatic change of heart, with MPs now set to return to the House of Commons to hold a vote on the plans.

Speaking with LBC on the subject of means-tested payments on Thursday, Deputy Prime Minister Angela Rayner reiterated Labour's comments blaming a "significant black hole" left by the previous government for the proposed cuts.

It's a move that has been welcomed by shadow work and pensions secretary Mel Stride.

London, UK. 9th June, 2024. Mel Stride, Former Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, at the BBC for Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg. Credit: Mark Thomas/Alamy Live News
London, UK. 9th June, 2024. Mel Stride, Former Secretary of State for Work and Pensions, at the BBC for Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg. Credit: Mark Thomas/Alamy Live News. Picture: Alamy

Lucy Powell, the leader of the Commons, said the proposed changes to Winter Fuel Payments will now be debated on September 10.

It followed increasing pressure on Keir Starmer over the stripping the winter fuel allowance, which would use financial testing to allocate the allowance to pensioners, instead of a blanket allowance being handed out to all.

The move follows ten Labour MPs joining a revolt on stripping of the allowance.

Speaking following the announcement, Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary Mel Stride said: “We welcome that the Labour Government have u-turned and there will now be a vote on the Conservative motion to scrap the cruel cut to Winter Fuel Payments.

Read more: Royal Mail set to axe part of Saturday service under string of new reforms

Read more: Domestic abusers could be released on the streets next week, former Justice Secretary Alex Chalk tells LBC

“Labour thinks it is right to give their union paymasters an inflation-busting pay rise over protecting vulnerable pensioners, just as bills are going up. This tells you everything you need to know about the Government’s values.

“Labour still wants to stop this vital support for the most vulnerable pensioners, but we would urge all MPs to do the right thing and back this Conservative motion to stop this punishing cut.”

About five out of every six pensioners living below the “poverty line” could be at risk of being stripped of their winter fuel payments, according to a former pensions minister.

Watch Again: James O'Brien is joined by Deputy PM Angela Rayner | 05/09/24

Sir Steve Webb, who is now a partner at pension consultants LCP (Lane Clark & Peacock), said analysis suggests that about 1.6 million older people who are below what is commonly regarded as the poverty line do not receive pension credit.

Chancellor Rachel Reeves and Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer have faced criticism from opponents, campaigners and some of their own MPs over the decision to means test winter fuel payments, worth up to £300.

Reeves has defended her decision to strip winter fuel payments from millions of pensioners in recent weeks, as energy bosses were called in for talks on helping the most vulnerable households ahead of winter.

Only those receiving pension credit or other means-tested benefits will be eligible for the payment in England and Wales as a result of the Government’s decision, which ministers have said is needed to help fill a £22 billion black hole in the public finances.

Angela Rayner once again rejected demands on Thursday during her morning interviews to rethink the plans, noting the government had an obligation to balance the books.

During Prime Minister's Questions on Wednesday, he suggested Labour had chosen train drivers over pensioners by agreeing a pay deal with unions to end strikes while proposing the winter fuel cut.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Rory McIlroy of Northern Ireland holds the trophy after the final round of Masters Tournament at Augusta National Golf Club

'Welcome to the club': Tiger Woods congratulates Rory McIlroy following long-awaited Masters victory

General view of staff on a NHS hospital ward

Skin cancer patients to be given fast-tracked access to vaccine trial on NHS

Rory McIlroy

Rory McIlroy completes golf’s Grand Slam by winning Masters, after play-off drama

Members of a grooming gang in West Yorkshire who were jailed last year

Child sex abuse survivors launch legal campaign over authorities who 'failed to tackle grooming gang epidemic'

MPs have said that the claim of 'two-tier policing' related to the Southport riots is 'baseless'

'Two-tier policing' claim after Southport riots is 'baseless', MPs say

The outpatient and laboratory wards of the Al-Ahli Arab Baptist hospital are seen after being hit by an Israeli army strike

Lammy slams Israel's 'deplorable' attack on Gaza hospital

Jean Marsh has died

Jean Marsh, award-winning star and co-creator of Upstairs Downstairs, dies aged 90

Mickey Rourke

Moment Hollywood star Mickey Rourke kicked off Celebrity Big Brother after foul-mouthed tirade at housemates

Lanzarote has been hit by flooding

Easter travel warning for Lanzarote as Canary Island holiday hotspot hit with catastrophic floods

Katy Perry and the space team

Katy Perry debuts spacesuits she and all-female astronaut team will wear on Jeff Bezos' Blue Origin rocket launch

Three prison officers rushed to hospital after Manchester Arena terrorist 'threw scalding oil and stabbed them'

Ministers order review into Manchester Arena terrorist's 'attack on prison guards' using 'oil and makeshift weapons'

Sumy

Russian strikes on Ukraine border town 'cross any line of decency', US says, after over 30 killed including children

Kaliyah Coa, 11, was reportedly down at the water when she was 'swept away'

Body found in search for 11-year-old girl who went missing in the Thames

Sakhir, Bahrain. 13th April 2025. Sir Jackie Stewart During Race Day. Ahmad Al Shehab/Alamy Live News.

Jackie Stewart drives F1 car for last time wearing helmet signed by all living champions - including Michael Schumacher

Barry Dawson

Five men charged over death of 'much-loved' granddad shot through his front window

The Oxford Women's team appear dejected after losing The 79th CHANEL J12 Women's Boat Race on the River Thames, London. Picture date: Sunday April 13, 2025.

Cambridge beats Oxford by 'unprecedented' margin to win 170th Boat Race