'It goes to the very top': Sacked border watchdog slams Home Office and calls for reform after Cleverly row

11 March 2024, 00:01 | Updated: 11 March 2024, 00:02

Sacked borders watchdog David Neal said the Home Office is 'dysfunctional' and needs reform.
Sacked borders watchdog David Neal said the Home Office is 'dysfunctional' and needs reform. Picture: Alamy

By Chay Quinn

Sacked borders watchdog David Neal said the Home Office is 'dysfunctional' and needs reform.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Mr Neal was sacked as the independent chief inspector of borders and immigration in February and said that he "paid the price" for speaking out about his concerns.

He insisted that his "conscience is absolutely clear" after losing the confidence of Home Secretary James Cleverly amid claims he breached the terms of his appointment.

Read More: 'It's not racist to want to control our borders' says Nigel Farage's team after fiery clash with Nella Rose

The former inspector had become embroiled in a row with the Home Office about concerns he was raising over security checks at airports.

David Neal, former Independent Chief Inspector of Borders and Immigration giving evidence to the Home Office Select Committee in the House of Commons, London. Picture date: Tuesday February 27, 2024.
Mr Neal was sacked as the independent chief inspector of borders and immigration in February and said that he "paid the price" for speaking out about his concerns. . Picture: Alamy

In a BBC interview, Mr Neal said failings in the immigration system go "right to the top" of the Home Office.

He told The Today Podcast: "The Home Office is dysfunctional, the Home Office needs reform."

After his dismissal, the Home Office published 13 of Mr Neal's reports on the same day as damning findings from an inquiry into Sarah Everard's murder by serving police officer Wayne Couzens, leading to claims the Government was trying to bury bad news.

Mr Neal suggested that his sacking and the lack of a replacement meant there would be less scrutiny of border-related issues, including the Rwanda asylum scheme.

"I've been sacked. So there will be no scrutiny of small boats, there will be no scrutiny of adults at risk in detention which is a controversial area, there will be no publishing of the Rwanda material."

London, England, UK. 6th Mar, 2024. Home Secretary JAMES CLEVERLY, leaves Downing Street after a Cabinet Meeting. (Credit Image: © Thomas Krych/ZUMA Press Wire) EDITORIAL USAGE ONLY! Not for Commercial USAGE!
He insisted that his "conscience is absolutely clear" after losing the confidence of Home Secretary James Cleverly amid claims he breached the terms of his appointment. Picture: Alamy
d
The former inspector had become embroiled in a row with the Home Office about concerns he was raising over security checks at airports. Picture: Alamy

A Home Office spokesman said: "It is the job of the independent chief inspector of borders and immigration to identify challenges in our system, including those proposed by Border Force, so we can take action to address them.

"But by their nature, each of the ICIBI reports will only be a snapshot of what is going on and will not reflect the changes we make as a result of their findings.

"A programme of work is already well under way to reform and strengthen Border Force's capabilities. This is delivering on the Prime Minister's pledge to make our structures and resources as strong as possible.

"The work the Home Office, Border Force and the NCA is doing with international partners to stop the boats is another part of our Border Force reform, and is already having a return with small boat arrivals down by a third when Mr Neal was sacked for leaking sensitive information he was told was inaccurate."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

JD Vance joked UK could become 'Islamist' under Labour

Trump's vice-president pick JD Vance joked UK could be 'first Islamist country to have nuclear weapons' under Labour

Britain's Prime Minister Keir Starmer hosts the first roundtable with regional UK mayors, along with Angela Rayner

Ministers pledge to give more powers to local areas, in 'devolution revolution'

Starmer has launched a defence review

Keir Starmer launches review of armed forces as he warns of 'dangerous and volatile world'

Annabel Croft and Graziano di Prima   at Strictly Come Dancing - The Live Tour. Utilita Arena. 18th January 2024.  Ref:LMK11-180124-001 Steve Bealing/Landmark Media

Strictly Come Dancing pro Graziano Di Prima 'flees the country' after being fired following claims of misconduct

Joe Biden has admitted that calling for Democrats to put Trump in a 'bullseye' was a mistake

Joe Biden admits it was a 'mistake' to urge Democrats to 'put Donald Trump in a bullseye' after assassination attempt

Jay Slater's mother Debbie Duncan is said to be 'demanding answers'

Jay Slater's mother 'demands answers' after human remains found just yards from teen's last known location

Trump has selected Vance as his running mate

Who is JD Vance, Donald Trump's pick for vice-president?

Donald Trump has selected JD Vance (right) as his running mate and would-be vice president

Donald Trump chooses senator JD Vance as running mate, as he is officially nominated as Republican candidate

Ralf Schumacher and David Schumacher at Hockenheimring on April 05, 2022

'I'm 100% behind you': Ralf Schumacher's son congratulates his father after he comes out as gay

David Lammy has called for a ceasefire on a trip to Israel

Foreign Secretary David Lammy reiterates call for Israel-Hamas ceasefire and hostage deal in Gaza

Hamza Alam

East Londoner who 'disguised himself as a librarian' while urging TikTok followers to kill Jewish people jailed for 4 years

The England fan is confident England can bring football home in the next four years.

England fan has ‘no regrets’ over doomed Euro ‘winners’ tattoo

Queen Camilla left in histerics as Jersey cows get frisky during royal visit while bemused King watches on

Queen Camilla left in hysterics as Jersey cows get frisky during royal visit while bemused King watches on

Home Secretary Yvette Cooper during a visit to Lewisham Police Station in south London.

Home Secretary to probe 'disgraceful' election intimidation, as Jo Cox's sister says UK politics 'not in a good place'

An FBI investigation discovered the influencer had forced women to work for her in poor conditions with no pay

Instagram influencer jailed for human trafficking and slavery

People shelter under umbrellas as the rain pounds down last week.

Return of the summer washout: UK braces for flooding and travel chaos as Met Office issues weather warnings