'Don't joke about chaining black staff to desk', judge rules, as woman wins £18k following 'intrinsically racist' comment

20 December 2022, 06:27

The ruling does not set a legal precedent
The ruling does not set a legal precedent. Picture: Alamy

By Kit Heren

A judge has ruled that joking about chaining black employees to their desks is "intrinsically racist", as she awarded a woman a five-figure payout.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The decision came in a case about a cleaning company in Manchester, where boss Teresa McArdle had made the comment to administrator Adele Waring because she often left her work station.

Ms Waring, who is of Afro-Caribbean descent, sued the company, Tudor Contract Cleaners, over the comment and other incidents that she claimed constituted racial harassment.

Judge Pauline Feeney ruled at the tribunal hearing that the comment "was intrinsically racist to someone of African-Caribbean heritage", in a ruling that does not carry legal precedent.

Jeremy Clarkson's ex-editor comments on his racist column

The claim failed on a technicality as Ms Waring said the remark was victimisation, rather than harassment.

But she won £18,000 after the panel ruled in her favour on another workplace issue.

Ms Waring started work at Tudor Contract Cleaners in 2017, beginning as a cleaner but later becoming a part-time administrator.

The hearing heard how Ms McArdle told Ms Waring that “she needed to chain her to her desk” because she “was always disappearing”.

Four receptionists left the company and Waring was asked to cover some of their responsibilities. But the work atmosphere became "toxic" as two of the administrators would only speak Polish to one another, while another would often leave his desk.

‘What's the official age at which you're allowed to be racist?’

Ms McArdle denied using the word "chain" when speaking to Ms Waring, telling the tribunal she said "tag" instead - but the panel found Ms Waring's version more plausible.

Ms Waring resigned, saying she had been racially discriminated against, including a claim that a colleague told her that black people cannot drive well.

The tribunal decided that she had been racially harassed and discriminated against by her bosses because they did not understand why she was offended by the "blacks can't drive" comment.

Ms Waring's other claims were dismissed.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Exclusive
The findings are likely to call into question the Probation Service’s ability to monitor dangerous individuals as they serve the remainder of their sentences in the community.

Probation-monitored offenders charged with murder every six days

Liam O'Hanna, left, was charged over an alleged incident which occurred during a London gig.

'We are not the story': Kneecap slam 'political policing' after rapper Liam O'Hanna charged with terror offence

The CSA Centre estimates as many as 1 in 10 children could face abuse before the age of 16 in the UK

Child sexual abuse services ‘on the verge of breaking point’, experts say

London, UK. 20 May 2025.  Relatives of victims in the UK's contaminated blood scandal campaign outside Parliament

'People are dying': fury at delay in infected blood payouts as minister denies hold-up 'not about saving money'

Earthquake of magnitude 6 hits Crete coast in Greece

Earthquake of magnitude 6 strikes Crete coast in Greece - as tsunami warning issued by authorities

Exclusive
Appearing on Facebook and Instagram it begins with a faded photo of him and the words 'Anas Sarwar has said he will prioritise the Pakistani community".

Reform UK spends £7k on 'outrageous' ads suggesting Scottish labour leader wants to 'prioritise Pakistani community'

Earned prison release, more community supervision… and chemical castration: Gauke’s sentencing review

Paedophiles and sex offenders face castration: Gauke’s sentencing review

Two Israeli embassy staff members killed in Washington shooting, suspect held

Two Israeli embassy staff members shot dead in 'targeted attack' outside Jewish Museum in Washington, DC

The latest figures show that in March 2025 there were 314,432 children and young people waiting for community health services.

Children face ‘catastrophic’ waits for care, leading doctors warn

A piggy bank being held

Some first-time buyers accessing bumper Lifetime Isa deposits of £50,000-plus

Players of Tottenham celebrate with the trophy during the Final UEFA Europa League football match played between Tottenham Hotspur FC and Manchester United.

Tottenham win Europa League final after beating Manchester United 1-0 in Bilbao

Liam Gallagher, former frontman with English band Oasis performing live on stage, Newport.

Oasis fans ‘set to spend £1bn on UK reunion tour concerts’

R&B singer Chris Brown is alleged to have hit music producer Abe Diaw over the head with a bottle multiple times at a London nightclub last year.

'FROM THE CAGE TO THE STAGE': Chris Brown makes statement after being released from prison on £5million bail

A flotilla of Little Ships in the English Channel after they sailed out of Ramsgate, Kent, during 'Dunkirk 85'.

Migrant boat forces Dunkirk commemoration fleet to divert route

Liam O'Hanna, left, was charged over an alleged incident which occurred during a London gig.

Kneecap rapper Liam O'Hanna charged with terrorism offence after 'displaying Hezbollah flag' at London gig

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu speaks to journalists at press conference in Jerusalem, Wednesday, May 21, 2025.

Netanyahu says 'all of Gaza' will be 'under Israel's control' at the end of current military offensive