'Woeful budgeting' at the Home Office caused repeated overspends on asylum, says watchdog

29 August 2024, 00:00

"Woeful budgeting" at the Home Office has caused repeated overspends on asylum, a fiscal watchdog has said.
"Woeful budgeting" at the Home Office has caused repeated overspends on asylum, a fiscal watchdog has said. Picture: Alamy

By Lauren Lewis

"Woeful budgeting" at the Home Office has caused repeated overspends on asylum, a watchdog has said.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) said the department has frequently spent far more than it had budgeted for asylum, border, visa and passport operations - and that the budget for 2024/25 is repeating mistakes made under the previous government by submitting figures it "knows to be insufficient".

Between 2021/22 and 2023/24, plans put before parliament by the Home Office at the start of each year budgeted an average of £110 million for asylum operations, but it ended up spending much more - an average of £2.6 billion per year.

The IFS report claims that the "woeful way" the Home Office and HM Treasury have budgeted for asylum costs lies at the heart of the recent disagreement between Chancellor Rachel Reeves and her predecessor Jeremy Hunt.

In a financial audit of public spending conducted not long after Ms Reeves took office, spending pressures relating to asylum and illegal migration were one of the largest items identified amounting to an estimated £6.4 billion in 2024/25.

In response, Mr Hunt argued that this contradicted the budgets signed off by civil servants and presented to parliament just weeks before.

The IFS said both the current and former chancellors have a point - but only because the Home Office and HM Treasury are continuing the "poor budgeting practice" of recent years.

Read more: 'It goes to the very top': Sacked border watchdog slams Home Office and calls for reform after Cleverly row

Max Warner, research economist at IFS and an author of the briefing, said: "The way in which the Home Office and Treasury have budgeted for asylum costs leaves a lot to be desired.

"The fact that the Home Office has spent £7.6 billion more than initially budgeted on asylum, border, visa and passport operations over the past three years is testament to that.

"When there is a one-off unexpected spike in costs or demand, spending more than was budgeted is entirely understandable. But when it is happening year after year, something is going wrong with the budgeting process. It would be far more sensible to recognise the likely amount of asylum spending up front.

"That would also leave the Treasury's contingency Reserve for genuine emergencies, rather than for spending that the Government knows will occur but does not want to budget for."

The briefing further claims that the Home Office has got into the "bad habit" of submitting initial budgets to parliament that it knows to be insufficient, in the expectation of a top-up from the Treasury's contingency Reserve later in the financial year.

The top-up last year was £4 billion.

Read more: Police bodycam footage shows arrests made after attack on Rotherham hotel housing asylum seekers

Despite reprimands from the Home Affairs Select Committee, and the fact that it seemingly contravenes Treasury guidance on the Main Estimates put before parliament, the IFS said the Home Office is once again doing the same this year.

It has submitted plans for 2024-25 which already include a £1.5 billion top-up from the Treasury, but which are nonetheless judged "not sufficient to support those currently in the asylum system".

Even with the £800 million of expected savings from the new Government's ending of the Rwanda scheme, the fiscal watchdog is warning another top-up in the region of £4 billion "appears all but inevitable".

They add: "It is not that the spending pressures were entirely unexpected (they were not). It is that they have not been budgeted for."

The report concludes that Mr Hunt can rightly question whether the Home Office Main Estimates presented to parliament do in fact represent the best forecast of the department's requirements - but the same was true last year, when he was chancellor.

It added that Ms Reeves is right to say that there is a big in-year asylum spending pressure that has not been budgeted for, though she "perhaps overstates the extent to which this was unforeseeable and unexpected".

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Supporters of Dignity in Dying celebrate on hearing the result of the vote on the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, outside the Houses of Parliament in Westminster, London.

UK doctor says helping patients die in Australia is a ‘tremendous privilege’ and calls for law change at home

The body of Yair Yaakov, 59, has reportedly been recovered.

Two more hostages recovered by Israeli forces in Gaza, Netanyahu says

There were reports of vehicles being damaged and burned out, stolen cars, motorbikes being used and bricks thrown at officers amid the disorder, Greater Manchester Police said.

Girl, 16, charged with assaulting an emergency worker in Salford after ‘60 masked youths’ clash with police

The affected products include the Jolly Rancher Hard Candy, “Misfits” Gummies, Hard Candy Fruity 2 in 1, and Berry Gummies, the FSA said.

'Don't eat them': Brits told to avoid popular American sweets linked to cancer amid 'toxicological concern'

A woman has been arrested after a four-year-old boy was found dead in Dunholme End.

Boy, 4, found dead inside Maidenhead home as police arrest woman on suspicion of murder

Exclusive
Caz Holbrook, 54, said 2023 was a "very stressful" year after her landlord evicted her and her 15-year-old son from their home in Ross-on-Wye, Herefordshire

I was evicted after Liz Truss's budget tanked the economy – my son and I ended up in a beetle-infested flat

St Michael's Church, Mytholmroyd

Village church ordered to silence 'cherished' chiming bells after residents' complaints spark huge row

The Bridgerton actress said she has been left with a concussion and "on edge" - and the incident traumatised her dog.

Bridgerton actress Genevieve Chenneour left 'traumatised' after fighting off phone thief who threatened to 'stab' her

Shopper walking through the aisle of a supermarket.

Deadly disease outbreak linked to 'contaminated' UK supermarket item

Demonstrators gathered outside Stoke Newington Police Station in protest against police in schools, after it emerged that a 15-year-old Black girl ('Child Q') was strip-searched by police at a Hackney school, which is thought to be racially motivated.

Officer who strip-searched black schoolgirl while she was on her period admits failings but denies racist motivation

Thomas Tuchel, Head Coach of England

My mum finds Jude Bellingham’s on-field antics repulsive, says Thomas Tuchel

The jury found him not guilty of an additional sexual assault charge and have not yet returned a verdict on a charge of rape.

Harvey Weinstein found guilty in New York sexual assault retrial but acquitted on second charge

A fire broke out at a leisure centre in a town near Ballymena amid ongoing riots.

Masked thugs set leisure centre on fire as residents fear for their life in Ballymena

Brian Wilson performs Pet Sounds at the Pantages Theatre on May 26, 2017 in Los Angeles, California.

Legendary Beach Boys co-founder and primary songwriter Brian Wilson dies aged 82

England head coach Thomas Tuchel.

'I'm in the right place': Thomas Tuchel wants to extend England head coach job until Euro 2028

The Lower Broughton Road in Salford.

Rioting erupts and 16-year-old girl arrested in Salford as ‘60 masked youths’ clash with police and 'set fire to car'