Australian police blast media over 'unhelpful' reporting of Erin Patterson poisoned mushroom case

17 August 2023, 11:21

Police blast media over the reporting of the Erin Patterson poisoned mushroom case
Police blast media over the reporting of the Erin Patterson poisoned mushroom case. Picture: social media

By StephenRigley

Detectives probing the death of three people following a poisonous mushroom lunch say the leaking of chef Erin Patterson's police statement has been "unhelpful" and hampered investigators.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Patterson's legal statement was provided to police by her lawyers, but made its way into the hands of the press who have reported extensively on the suspect's response to allegations about a mushroom dish she cooked for relatives.

Patterson, 48, had cooked a beef wellington lunch for her former in-laws Gail and Don Patterson, Gail's sister Heather Wilkinson and her husband Ian Wilkinson in Leongatha on July 29.

Gail, 70, Don, 70, and Heather, 66, have all since died from suspected mushroom poisoning, while Ian, 70, remains in a serious condition in need a liver transplant.

Originally Patterson gave a no comment interview to police at the start of their investigation.

But in her leaked statement the mother-of-two revealed her initial decision to stonewall cops on it being a "terrifying and anxiety-provoking" experience.

Erin Patterson
Erin Patterson. Picture: social media

Read More: 'This is not Midsomer Murders': Local mayor calls for privacy after Erin Patterson’s deadly mushroom lunch

Read More: Sole survivor of Erin Patterson’s deadly beef wellington mushroom lunch ‘holds the key to what happened’

Deputy Police Commissioner Wendy Steendam told ABC Radio Melbourne: "Working on an investigation through the media is unhelpful to our investigation.

"The matter needs to be dealt with by us, looked at (by) us, and determined by us thoroughly what's actually occurred, and using the evidence that we have to determine and understand exactly what's happened and if we can explain what caused the deaths."

She said the statement was not an official police document, as it was prepared and provided by Ms Patterson's legal team.

Victoria's Deputy Police Commissioner Wendy Steendam
Victoria's Deputy Police Commissioner Wendy Steendam. Picture: social media

When asked about its contents, the Deputy Commissioner added she thought it would be inappropriate to "speculate" on what remained an active investigation.

"I don’t think it’s helpful to actually comment further on this investigation," she said.

"It is an active matter and when we have more to say publicly, we'll do that. But I think to speculate or to talk about the aspects of the investigation in detail is unhelpful."

In her statement, Patterson denied any wrongdoing and did not know how the meal caused three deaths.

Ms Steendam said the investigation remains ongoing adding: "I understand the interest and the desire to have more information about this, but given it's an active investigation … I am limited in what I actually can say about the matter, except to say, it's not going to be quick."

On Wednesday, Patterson protested her innocence and complained about her portrayal in the media.

"I lost my parents-in-law, my children lost their grandparents," she told The Australian.

"And I've been painted as an evil witch. And the media is making it impossible for me to live in this town.'I can't have friends over. The media is at the house where my children are at. The media are at my sister's house so I can't go there. This is unfair."

She claims she bought the mushrooms used in the beef wellington from a supermarket and an Asian grocer shop in Melbourne - but couldn't recall the name.

In her statement, she revealed that she became unwell after eating the meal and that while in hospital, her ex-husband Simon Patterson accused her of poisoning his parents.

She admitted that she then dumped the dehydrator at a nearby tip soon after because she was in a panic.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

James Cleverly announced the £31m package.

Home Office unveils £31m security package as Cleverly vows to 'protect MPs from intimidation'

World leaders have rejected Macron's idea.

World leaders reject Macron’s plan to send Nato troops to Ukraine in bid to stop 'Russia winning the war'

The pair speak about their relationship in the new doc.

Inside Jennifer Lopez’s rekindled romance with Ben Affleck: J Lo reveals reason pair reunited after years apart

Some of the renovation requests on his £7m home have been rejected.

Gordon Ramsay faces renovation setback on £7m home as council rejects chef's bid for new security gates

Salvatore Mancuso

Warlord Mancuso is extradited back to Colombia after serving sentence in US

Jam Master Jay

Godson and friend convicted in murder of Run-DMC rapper Jam Master Jay

Two men have been convicted over the murder of Jam Master Jay.

Run-DMC star Jam Master Jay's godson and childhood friend both found guilty of his murder

Jair Bolsonaro

Bolsonaro under investigation for allegedly harassing a humpback whale

A lawyer who represented 'murdered' Russian opposition figure Alexei Navalny has been arrested in Moscow, Russian news has reported

Navalny's lawyer 'arrested in Moscow' after helping Russian opposition leader's mother obtain body from authorities

Former Tory MP Scott Benton has been suspended from the Commons.

Former Tory MP suspended from Commons over role in lobbying sting as Rishi Sunak faces fresh by-election headache

PlayStation is closing its London studio and axing 900 jobs (file image)

PlayStation to axe 900 jobs and close London studio to 'future ready' itself

Zelensky and Mohammed bin Salman

Zelensky meets Saudi crown prince to discuss peace deal and return of POWs

Lady Gabriella Windsor's husband Thomas Kingston has died aged 45

Royal family mourns as Lady Gabriella Windsor's husband Thomas Kingston dies aged 45

Mr Scully apologised for his comments.

'I'm sorry I chose those words': Tory MP Paul Scully apologises after claiming there were 'no-go areas' in some cities

Michael Holt, 54, from the Wirral, was found dead in the boat 700 miles into the charity challenge off the coast of Cape Verde, west Africa

Fundraiser launched to return home British father found dead on boat four weeks into 3,000-mile Atlantic ocean row

A remote track near Pitilie

Murder probe launched after former groundsman shot dead while walking his dog on Scottish estate