Obsessed security guard ‘plotted to keep Holly Willoughby in dungeon where screams couldn't be heard for miles'

24 June 2024, 16:01

Gavin Plumb is accused of plotting to kidnap, rape and murder Holly Willoughby
Gavin Plumb is accused of plotting to kidnap, rape and murder Holly Willoughby. Picture: Alamy
Fraser Knight.

By Fraser Knight.

A security guard from Essex is accused of telling a co-conspirator he had “found the possibility of a few abandoned places” to keep Holly Willoughby in, as part of an alleged plot to kidnap her.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Gavin Plumb, 37, is said to have spent almost two years planning to “ambush” the TV personality at her home, before taking her somewhere to be repeatedly raped and killed.

During the opening of his trial at Chelmsford Crown Court, prosecutor Alison Morgan KC read messages Plumb is claimed to have sent to a man online, named as Marc, in which he described one location he’d found as “a dungeon, big enough for a bed where the screams can’t be heard for miles”.

The court heard Mr Plumb had been part of an online group called ‘Abduct lovers’ where his plans were intercepted by an undercover police officer in the United States.

The officer, using the name ‘David Nelson’ was tasked with infiltrating forums where abduction, kidnap, rape and murder for hire were being discussed.

Read more: Security guard who plotted to kidnap, rape and murder Holly Willoughby previously held other women against their will

Read more: 'Obsessed' security guard spent almost two years 'plotting to kidnap, rape and murder' Holly Willoughby

Court artist drawing by Elizabeth Cook of Gavin Plumb
Court artist drawing by Elizabeth Cook of Gavin Plumb. Picture: Alamy

A number of voice messages, allegedly sent by Mr Plumb to Marc were also played to the court, in which he was heard explaining what he planned to do with Ms Willoughby and her husband Dan Baldwin.

The recording said: “Basically we’re gonna hit it at 9, less traffic on the road etcetera.

“We’ll chloroform both of them. That way they can both be easily restrained. Pick out outfits of hers that we like and then take her and the outfits with us.

“We’re then gonna force her to make a video saying she came with us under her free will, and she’s fully consenting in whatever we do to her so that covers us.”

Ms Morgan said: “In this trial, the defendant is likely to suggest that this is all just fantasy but when you look at these messages, you’ll consider the way in which he describes her and what he would do to her.

Holly Willoughby
Holly Willoughby. Picture: Getty

“You’ll consider whether this is the talk of a fantasist or if it’s someone who expresses himself with such a dark depravity that it is clear that he meant what he said.”

The court heard Mr Plumb had bought bottles of chloroform and 400 metal cable ties in April 2022, described as being “heavy duty”.

In one message, Ms Morgan said he’d discussed using the metal cable ties to detain Dan Baldwin and handcuffs for Ms Willoughby.

In another message, allegedly sent to the undercover officer on October 4 2023, the court heard he’d indicated he wanted his 15-year-old son to get involved with the plan to sexually assault her.

Plumb was arrested by Essex Police later that day.

Earlier in the trial’s opening, the jury heard that he had previously held other females against their will - attempting to kidnap two women from trains in 2006.

The court was told he’d also forced two 16-year-old colleagues into a back room at the shop where he worked in 2008, where he tied one of their hands together using rope and tape.

Plumb denies the charges against him.

The trial continues.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Strictly Come Dancing is reportedly considering hiring chaperones for celebrity stars after misconduct claims against two professional dancers.

Strictly Come Dancing could 'hire celebrity chaperones' after two professionals accused of misconduct

Police confirmed the human remains belonged to missing teen Jay Slater after a 29-day search

Jay Slater's mother pays tribute to 'beautiful boy' after body confirmed as that of missing teen

King Charles will lay out Labour's plan for government in the King's Speech.

What will be in Keir Starmer's first King's Speech and what does it mean?

Jamie Howlett is a serving police constable at the Metropolitan Police Service

Serving Metropolitan Police officer charged with sexually assaulting two children and raping adult

Body found in Jay Slater search is missing Briton, police confirm

Body found in Jay Slater search is that of missing Briton, police confirm

Police paused their search for Jay Slater two weeks after he vanished.

Madeleine McCann detective hunting Jay Slater breaks silence after ‘deteriorated’ human remains found in search

Children have been ‘left to fend for themselves’ when parents sent to prison (right stock image)

Children 'left to fend for themselves' when parents sent to prison – because authorities 'don't know about them'

The Spanish Civil Guard said Jay Slater, from Oswaldtwistle, Lancashire, could have fallen in a steep and inaccessible area

Jay Slater's best friend Lucy Law pays heartbreaking tribute to 'happiest' person after his ‘deteriorated’ body found

Victoria Thomas-Bowen appears at Westminster Magistrates' Court today after Nigel Farage was drenched in a banana flavoured drink

OnlyFans model, 25, to stand trial after denying throwing a McDonald’s milkshake over Nigel Farage

Jay Slater was 'killed instantly' after falling from height in Tenerife family believe

Body found in hunt for Jay Slater was 'very deteriorated' as Tenerife officials reveal key details

Prince William hailed Southgate as a "true leader" in a touching tribute to the coach.

'A class act': Will and Kate share touching tribute to Gareth Southgate as England boss resigns

Swansea, 9th August 2016. Picture by Robert Melen. Vaughan Gething, cabinet secretary for health, Well-being and sport.

Vaughan Gething to quit as Welsh First Minister

Basildon Remains In Top Three Worst Areas For Covid Infections

Manhunt launched after woman stabbed and robbed in hospital car park by masked knifeman

Gareth Southgate is to leave his role as England manager

Read in Full: Gareth Southgate's emotional statement resigning as England manager

Gareth Southgate has quit as England manager after Euro 2024 final defeat

'It's been the honour of my life': Gareth Southgate quits as England manager after Euro 2024 final defeat

A 25-year-old Brit is missing in Sardinia

Urgent hunt for missing Brit, 25, in Sardinia as desperate mum issues plea after he 'undressed and vanished'