UK risks becoming ‘incubator economy’ where tech start-ups develop then leave

3 February 2025, 11:04

Keir Starmer unveils AI Opportunity Action Plan
Keir Starmer unveils AI Opportunity Action Plan. Picture: PA

Urgent action is needed by the Government to help UK companies, including AI and creative technology start-ups, to scale up, a new report has said.

The UK risks becoming an “incubator economy”, where technology start-ups develop before selling or moving abroad, a House of Lords committee has warned.

Urgent action is needed by the Government to foster innovative UK companies, including AI and creative technology start-ups, and support them in scaling up, a new report from the Lords Communications and Digital Committee has said.

The Prime Minister has previously said he wanted the UK and London to be the “best place in the world to start and scale an AI business”, but the Lords committee warned that companies are facing significant barriers preventing them from scaling up.

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer gives a speech during a visit to Google’s new AI Campus in Somers Town, north west London
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has emphasised AI’s ‘ability to transform millions of lives across our country’ (Stefan Rousseau/PA)

These include limited access to capital compared to other countries, challenges in recruiting tech talent that is in high demand and business and investment culture that can be too risk averse, according to the report.

The report, published on Monday, reads: “The consequences of failure are significant.

“The UK risks being an ‘incubator economy’ for other nations, as innovative British technology firms pursue greater growth potential in other markets or seek acquisition by foreign companies.

“A continuation of this trend could lead to decreased global competitiveness, weaker economic prospects and a ‘brain drain’ of talented individuals, at a time when technology is rapidly advancing.”

The committee has called on the Government to “do better by doing less”, including consolidating and streamlining existing schemes to support businesses, rather than launching new schemes.

Too often it’s a case of UK begins, other countries cash in. That has to change.

Baroness Stowell, chair of the House of Lords Communications and Digital Committee

Currently, the report says, there is an “overly complex spaghetti of schemes that may be hindering rather than helping innovation in some areas”.

Baroness Stowell, chair of the House of Lords Communications and Digital Committee, said: “Too often it’s a case of UK begins, other countries cash in. That has to change.

“The UK has some great advantages when it comes to AI and creative tech; a strong university sector undertaking ground-breaking research and generating commercial spin-outs, and a proud tradition of world-leading creative industries.

“These sectors have the potential to deliver the fast-paced economic growth the Government wants to achieve.

“But we have a real problem turning start-ups into scale-ups.

“Every UK unicorn that gallops overseas to list, or sells out to foreign investors, is a blow to UK PLC and our aspirations for growth.”

The report sets out key recommendations for the Government for bolstering scale-ups, including ensuring that industrial strategy provides “coherent, cross-sector vision” for supporting technology scale-ups in driving economic growth, unlocking domestic growth capital and fostering a culture where company founders are incentivised to stay in the UK to grow their businesses.

Other recommendations include sustaining investment in the creative industries and tackling barriers for growth for UK AI companies.

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

In this photo illustration, an Apple logo is seen displayed alongside the Google logo.

Tech giants Apple and Google 'profiting from phone thefts', MPs claim

A man's hands using a laptop keyboard

Scots warned of ‘scamdemic’ as £860,000 lost to cyber criminals in 12 months

A close up image of a The North Face fleece

North Face and Cartier customer data stolen in cyber attacks

Imagery of a Zilch payments card and a virtual card

Buy now pay later provider Zilch to launch first physical card

UK’s most EV-friendly city has been revealed by new research.

Cities with slowest EV charging times and least amount of chargers revealed

View of a VodafoneThree logo outside the firm's offices

Vodafone completes Three UK mega-merger to form ‘new force’ in mobile market

A hand holding a Monzo bank card and a mobile phone showing the Monzo app

Monzo annual profit surges as paying subscribers boost digital bank

Majestic British Airways Airbus A380 taking off from London Heathrow at sunset, amazing colors

UK airspace shake-up could slash journey times and cut flight delays for millions of passengers

File photo dated 30/05/25 of the saltmarsh at Abbotts Hall in Essex. Saltmarshes are 'significant' carbon stores, but are at risk from rising sea levels, new research reveals

UK's muddy saltmarshes vital to tackle climate change, report finds

Nigel Farage

Reform backs cryptocurrency tax cut as party receives first Bitcoin donations

Digital devices on office workplace table of young business woman

‘Young people and black workers at highest risk of workplace surveillance’

Debris from the Titan submersible, recovered from the ocean floor near the wreck of the Titanic, is unloaded from the ship Horizon Arctic at the Canadian Coast Guard pier in St. John's, Newfoundland, in June 2023

The shock household item discovered in 'sludge' of OceanGate sub wreckage

Google is facing a £25 billion legal claim in the UK, accusing the tech giant of abusing its dominant position in the online search advertising market

Google facing £25 billion legal claim over abuse of search advertising market

A hand holding a phone showing the Nvidia logo

Nvidia posts strong growth despite ongoing tariff challenges

Dinosaur fossils could hold the key to new cancer discoveries and influence future treatments for humans, scientists have said.

Dinosaur fossils with tumours could hold key to new cancer treatments for humans, scientists say

A SpaceX Starship spun out of control in a test flight

Elon Musk's SpaceX Starship spirals out of control before exploding in third consecutive mission failure