Caller's theory on why white working-class pupils are 'failing at school'

22 June 2021, 12:26

By Tim Dodd

White working-class kids fail just as much as black kids, this caller says, as MPs say the term "white privilege" may contribute towards "systemic neglect" of white pupils.

It comes as the Commons Education Select Committee says schools should consider whether promoting such "politically controversial" terminology is consistent with their duties under the Equality Act 2010.

The committee made a series of recommendations to improve white working-class pupils' outcomes, including finding "a better way to talk about racial disparities" to avoid pitting different groups against each other.

Sue in Bromley began by telling Nick: "What I want to talk about is this education report because it has me fuming and I don't want to play around with terms like 'white privilege' etc., because as someone who experienced the education system as a black working-class student many years ago, I could look around me and I could see that white kids were failing just as much as black kids.

"We were all in it together, we were all in the same position, there was no division really, and yet there would be report after report saying black kids were failing and that wasn't what I saw.

"What was going on, was that in my household, my parents told me that because I was black, because I would face discrimination my whole life, that I had to work really, really hard, and that education was important. That I had to go university, that I had to achieve the best I could because no matter how much I achieved, my skin colour would go against me."

Read more: Headteacher tells LBC why her school's looking at banning mobile phones

Watch: Term 'white privilege' insults white people, Tory MP tells LBC

Nick then asked: "Why is that not happening with white children?"

Sue replied: "White children were not told that, because what their parents seemed to think was that they'd be okay regardless. Their parents didn't have to say to them you will be discriminated against, which is actually what happened to them as working class pupils."

"Do you mind me asking how long ago you were at school?" Nick asked.

"I was at school in the seventies," said Sue.

"I've worked in education myself, and I think to divide the working class like this is very clever but it's not real."

A DfE spokesperson said: "This government is focused on levelling up opportunity so that no young person is left behind.

"That's why we are providing the biggest uplift to school funding in a decade - £14 billion over three years - investing in early years education and targeting our ambitious recovery funding, worth £3 billion to date, to support disadvantaged pupils aged two to 19 with their attainment."

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

Brandon Lewis

Boris Johnson still working and takes ‘red boxes’ on holiday, says Brandon Lewis

'Where do they find the time?!': Nick Ferrari slates mob attacking 'sexist' paint ad

'Where do they find the time?!': Nick Ferrari slates mob attacking 'sexist' paint ad

Nick Ferrari sold on caller's 'three one-off taxes' plan to raise cost-of-living funds

Nick Ferrari sold on caller's 'three one-off taxes' plan to raise cost-of-living funds

Nick Ferrari mocks caller who blames Brexit for water crisis

Nick Ferrari mocks caller who blames Brexit for water crisis

Nick Ferrari gobsmacked after caller says he has had seven bikes stolen.

Nick Ferrari gobsmacked at how caller has had seven bikes stolen

LBC's Reporter Charlotte Lynch took a dip off the Cornish Coast

Nick Ferrari's 'swimming in shark infested waters' reporter challenge

Jacob Rees-Mogg said civil servants had been offered a course on witchcraft

Courses on Check Yo Privilege and witchcraft for civil servants are a waste of time, says JRM

The Defence Secretary was speaking to Nick Ferrari

Ben Wallace accuses Rishi Suank of trying to block extra cash for defence spending

Ben Wallace is backing Liz Truss

'Feisty' Truss is my choice for PM, says Ben Wallace as he reveals endorsement

Tory party co-chair looks ahead to LBC leadership hustings with Nick Ferrari

Tory party co-chairman looks ahead to LBC leadership hustings with Nick Ferrari

'Totally invented tosh': Nadine Dorries dismisses claims she'd give up her constituency seat for Boris

'Totally invented tosh': Nadine Dorries dismisses claims she'd give up seat for Boris

Sunak is 'opposed to transparency' over police league table plans, says minister

Sunak is 'opposed to transparency' over police league table plans, says minister

Exclusive
'Do you want him evicted?': Mick Lynch defends RMT deputy living in council flat on £78k

'Do you want him evicted?': Mick Lynch defends RMT deputy living in council flat on £78k

Exclusive
Social workers 'showed no interest' in tragic Lily-Mai case, grandfather tells LBC

Social workers showed 'no interest' in tragic Lily-Mai case, grandfather tells LBC

A furious Nick Ferrari summed up the issue

Nick Ferrari slams 'sanctimonious' BBC over Princess Diana interview

Nick Ferrari mocks Prince Harry after UN speech

Nick Ferrari mocks Prince Harry after UN speech - 'Buy the bloke a Peroni!'