Nick Ferrari's fiery debate with train driver who brands driverless tube plans as 'fantasy'

2 June 2021, 09:47

Nick Ferrari takes on train union director over driverless tubes

By Fiona Jones

Nick Ferrari challenged train union ASLEF's Finn Brennan who claimed the "fantasy" of driverless tubes "make no economic sense", as TfL is "forced" to explore this avenue.

UK ministers have demanded Transport for London (TfL) pushes ahead with work to introduce driverless trains on the London Underground as part of the £1 billion rescue package announced on Monday.

The Department for Transport will collaborate with TfL to explore the business case for independently automated trains on the Waterloo and City line and the Piccadilly line -- however, Mayor of London Sadiq Khan has promised to reject any demands for this rollout.

Train union ASLEF's London director, Finn Brennan, utterly dismissed this concept: "It's just not going to happen, rather like [PM's] fantasies of a Garden Bridge and a bridge from Scotland to Northern Ireland and an airport in the Thames, it's simply isn't going to happen.

"It makes no economic sense."

Mr Brennan continued that as the arrangement states TfL must explore the "business case" which by no means makes it a certainty, adding, "If there was a business case for driverless trains they wouldn't need the Government to do it, they would have done it years ago."

TfL's last exploration into this showed there was "no cost savings in driverless trains in the underground," Mr Brennan told Nick, who was left in disbelief, branding the estimated figure of £10 billion a "bargain."

Nick then quoted an LBC contributor who is in favour of driverless tubes "because of trade unions."

"I'm very sorry that people don't like trade unions and don't think it's OK that people have a fair deal at work," Mr Brennan said, to which Nick said that "in some instances tube drivers are paid more than doctors."

Nick continued: "Mr Brennan, there's something called modernisation. We don't put boys up chimneys, we don't have people lighting the gaslights of London...we don't just bolt the door in the face of every tube driver but we now move to driverless trains as you get to every airport in the world by now, and the DLR."

Mr Brennan finished by pointing out that DLR trains have a captain aboard and have on occasion also pursued strike action over their treatment.

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

This is the moment Nick Ferrari puts a government minister on the spot over the government's new plans to ban smoking.

'When will the Conservatives be banning alcohol?' Nick Ferrari puts minister on the spot after smoking ban vote passes

'I'm ashamed to say Nick, I started smoking when I was 12' Tory MP reveals

Minister who reveals she started smoking at 12 says she's not interested in freedom argument against ban

This guest told LBC he was against Rishi Sunak's smoking ban because 'everybody dies in the end' and the NHS should 'price in' the cost of dealing with sick Brits.

'The NHS is there to make you healthy' guest dismisses smoking ban as 'everybody dies in the end'

Speaking to LBC's Nick Ferrari at Breakfast, Lord Kim Darroch the former UK National Security Advisor for his assessment of the performance of "the current PM, the man who was PM and the man who wants to be PM"

Rishi Sunak has 'left the pitch free' for Lord Cameron to be Foreign Sec and 'toughen the line on Israel', says former diplomat

David Cameron tells LBC using RAF jets to shoot down Russian drones over Ukraine would lead to a 'dangerous escalation' in the conflict.

Nick Ferrari puts David Cameron on the spot: 'Why can't the RAF shoot down drones over Ukraine like they do Israel?'

Lord Cameron has described Iran’s strike on Israel as a “double defeat”

Lord Cameron urges Israel to ‘take the win,' don't retaliate and focus on defeating Hamas after Iran’s ‘double defeat’

Exclusive
Rishi Sunak has pledged a crackdown on shoplifting

'We’ve got your back': Rishi Sunak’s message to retail staff as he pledges crackdown on dangerous shoplifters

Exclusive
'None of our closest allies have stopped': Rishi Sunak defends decision not to suspend arms sales to Israel

'None of our closest allies have stopped': Rishi Sunak defends decision not to suspend arms sales to Israel

Exclusive
Braverman: Iran is 'funding and supporting proxies to carry out attacks in the UK'

Suella Braverman warns Iranian regime 'funding and supporting' 'targeted attacks' on UK streets

Exclusive
The mural on the wall of the Golden Chippy

A Greenwich fish and chip shop that's causing a stink over painting, as owner tells LBC he's 'determined to keep mural up'

Rishi Sunak’s job is under threat from a plot of backbench Tory MPs who want to replace him with Penny Mordaunt before the general election.

Tories 'need to stop messing around and get behind the Prime Minister,' Business Secretary tells LBC

Exclusive
'This is trivia': Kemi Badenoch hits out at continued furore over Tory donor 'racism' row

'This is trivia': Kemi Badenoch hits out at continued furore over Tory donor 'racism' row

Government suspends tariffs on key imports to boost SMEs launching £660 million northern powerhouse fund

Government suspends tariffs on key imports to boost SMEs launching £660 million northern powerhouse fund

'Floating voters' unconvinced by Jeremy Hunt's Budget

LBC's 'Floating Voters' left unconvinced by Jeremy Hunt's Budget

Leila Khaled, who hijacked planes, will appear via video link at a fundraiser hosted by the Palestine Solidarity Campaign. Andy Street wants police to look at the event

'I'm not comfortable with it': West Mids Mayor to speak to police amid fury over Palestinian hijacker’s fundraiser

Andy Street taking calls from the public on Nick Ferrari at Breakfast

Tory MP's claim that Birmingham has 'no-go areas' was 'ridiculous', West Midlands Mayor tells LBC