Mandatory Covid jabs for NHS staff 'blunt instrument', JCVI member says

10 November 2021, 07:47

JCVI member on NHS compulsory jab policy

EJ Ward

By EJ Ward

Dr Maggie Wearmouth, who sits on the Joint Committee for Vaccination and Immunisation, said that legislating mandatory vaccines for frontline health and care workers in England was a "blunt instrument" but she was "supportive" of the move.

She told LBC's Nick Ferrari: "I'm broadly in favour of this move.

"I think legislation is a blunt instrument, but as frontline health and social care workers our goal and our main responsibility should be the health and protection of the very vulnerable, frail and elderly patients in our care.

"As a frontline health worker myself, I find it incomprehensible that someone would want to work in a job like mine and wish not to be vaccinated, so I broadly support it."

Asked about the prospect of daily testing as an alternative to unvaccinated staff, she added: "Daily testing is really quite cumbersome. I test twice a week and that's bad enough.

"I do think that you make a choice if you're a frontline worker, and the choice should be to protect your patients."

Iain Dale challenges GP over view on vaxx mandates for NHS

Frontline workers have a choice to make on getting jabbed against coronavirus to protect their patients, Dr Wearmouth told Nick Ferrari.

The JCVI member told LBC: "Clearly people who are very opposed to this and are frontline workers are going to have to make some difficult decisions."

Dr Wearmouth recalled having had some "very interesting and ethically challenging conversations with staff and patients in these situations over the last few months".

One group of people she highlighted are health and social care workers, who have had a first dose and then due to "possibly a change of heart or side effects have decided not to have the second jab".

For these, she suggested "there's some work there to facilitate people having a full, completed programme possibly with a different vaccine".

But pregnant women and those who are planning to become pregnant are her main concern, she said.

"The most often reason that's quoted to me are women who don't want to have it because of pregnancy," she said.

"I think that raises double concerns because we know that only 15% of women who are pregnant are fully vaccinated, so that for frontline workers, I think it's extremely important that these people are educated and helped and supported by their midwifery crew, teams to get vaccinated for themselves, their unborn babies, their staff, colleagues and their jobs."

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

Nick Ferrari and caller Eve

Nick Ferrari and caller Eve go back and forth over the Middle East conflict

LBC caller Paula drives home the impact of PIP benefit cuts

LBC caller Paula drives home the impact of disability benefit cuts

'Iran has a democratic candidate, unlike Iraq...'

Iraqi caller explains why Iran-Iraq comparisons fall short

It's not fair

Nick Ferrari loses his patience with caller over ‘non-dom’ tax scheme

Caller Som has a warning from the past as the conflict between Israel and Iran escalates.

Caller Som has a warning from history as Israel and Iran conflict escalates

LBC callers react to Israel’s ‘risky’ strike on Iran

LBC callers react to Israel’s ‘risky’ strike on Iran

Caller in Israel warns against Iran becoming a nuclear-armed state

Caller in Israel warns against Iran becoming a nuclear-armed state

Caller points out that Israel denied entry to Labour MPs as UK comes under fire for new sanctions

Caller points out that Israel denied entry to Labour MPs as UK comes under fire for new sanctions

Caller Layla

Caller Layla fears for her daughters following Kemi Badenoch's Burqa comments

Caller Barry

LBC caller backs the government's reversal on the winter fuel allowence

Nick Ferrari is unsure about caller Bill's proposal to turn migrant hotels into prisons

Nick Ferrari is unsure about caller Bill's proposal to turn migrant hotels into prisons

Call the Cabinet: Nick Ferrari is joined by Environment Secretary Steve Reed to take your calls

Call the Cabinet: Nick Ferrari is joined by Environment Secretary Steve Reed to take your calls

LBC reaction: 1200 Channel migrants arrive in a single day

LBC reaction: 1200 Channel migrants arrive in a single day

Exclusive
'Elite mindset' and ‘left-wing opinion’ fuelling migrant crisis says Nick Ferrari as he slams government

'Elite mindset' and ‘left-wing opinion’ fuelling migrant crisis says Nick Ferrari as he slams the government

Reform, racism and ‘a perverse Batman’ | LBC’s best callers of the week

Reform, racism and ‘a perverse Batman’: LBC’s best callers of the week

'Farage is a media-made man'

David and Nick debate whether 'tiny and ridiculous' Reform gets too much airtime