'Just give them half and they'll go away happy': Nick Ferrari reacts to Rwanda plan £170k per migrant cost

27 June 2023, 08:01

Nick Ferrari's unique take on the Rwanda migrant plan

EJ Ward

By EJ Ward

With the news the Home Office could spend £170,000 on every asylum seeker sent to Rwanda under government plans Nick Ferrari gives his unique take.

Ministers could spend £169,000 on every asylum seeker forcibly removed to a third country such as Rwanda, according to the Home Office's own estimates.

Nearly two in five people would need to be deterred from crossing the Channel in small boats for the Illegal Migration Bill to break even, the economic impact assessment published on Monday said.

Nick Ferrari at Breakfast was left staggered by the cost of the plans and then came up with his own solution: "Why don't you just give him or her half of that and they'll probably go away very happy."

Read more: Tory fury as civil servants threaten strike as they ‘fear being forced to break the law’ over Rwanda policy

Read more: Sending migrants to Rwanda 'best available option' to crush people-smuggling gangs, David Cameron says

Guto Harri explains 'showdown' between Boris Johnson and the King over Rwanda

Judges will hand down their judgment on the stalled Rwanda policy on Thursday as the Government desperately battles to fulfil its promise to "stop the boats".

Last year 45,755 people were detected to have made the perilous journey.

The Home Office document said the policy of relocating migrants to "safe third countries" could save between £106,000 and £165,000 per person.

However, it said the figures are "highly uncertain" and that the measures would need to deter 37% of people from crossing for the costs to be recouped.

Home Secretary Suella Braverman called for Parliament to support her legislation, arguing that the assessment "shows that doing nothing is not an option".
Home Secretary Suella Braverman called for Parliament to support her legislation, arguing that the assessment "shows that doing nothing is not an option". Picture: Alamy

The £169,000 cost includes flights and detention, as well as a £105,000 per person payment to third countries.

The sum is an estimate not based on the true cost of the "commercially sensitive" Rwanda scheme.

Despite Government efforts, Kigali is the only capital to have agreed to such a scheme with the UK.

Home Secretary Suella Braverman called for Parliament to support her legislation, arguing that the assessment "shows that doing nothing is not an option".

"We cannot allow a system to continue which incentivises people to risk their lives and pay people smugglers to come to this country illegally, while placing an unacceptable strain on the UK taxpayer," she said.

"I urge MPs and Peers to back the Bill to stop the boats, so we can crack down on people smuggling gangs while bringing our asylum system back into balance."

The document said that the asylum system could cost £32 million a day by the end of 2026 if recent trends continue without the reduction of hotel usage.

The assessment said that it is "not possible to estimate with precision the level of deterrence" the Bill will have.

It noted that academic consensus is there is "little to no evidence" that policy changes deter people leaving their home countries and seeking refuge.

Instead, shared language, culture and family ties were accepted to be "strong factors" influencing choice of final destination.

The document said evidence from a variety of countries such as Australia gives a "stronger basis" to think a policy change in the UK could have an impact.

But it acknowledged asylum seekers may not be aware of UK law when making their journeys and may push on regardless because they consider the benefits to be larger than the risks.

The assessment process does not consider the potential cost of making further agreements to expand the scheme beyond Rwanda, while noting that its estimates for the cost of third-party schemes was based on an National Audit Office study of the cost of the UK's Syrian Vulnerable Persons Resettlement Programme.

"It should not be considered to represent the actual cost of any current or future relocation agreement with a third country," the assessment notes.

The Refugee Council, which criticised the assessment, pointed in particular to the assumption that individuals will spend on average four years in the asylum system.

Chief executive Enver Solomon said the document "fails to evaluate the true costs and consequences of the Bill".

He added: "It does very little to predict the actual cost of implementing the Bill, and offers no estimates of the number of arrivals after the Bill becomes law. The Home Office admits in this assessment that it does not know how much of a deterrent effect the Bill will actually have, yet it still relies on this assumption to claim financial savings will be made.

"The assessment's predictions of future costs if the Bill is not implemented assume no improvements to decision-making efficiency, accommodation costs, or broader system enhancements.

"The reality is that making quicker decisions remains the most effective way to reduce the cost of asylum accommodation."

Shadow home secretary Yvette Cooper called the impact assessment a "complete joke".

"By its own admission, this failing Conservative government is totally clueless on how much this Bill will cost or what the impact of any of its policies will be. They are taking the country for fools," the Labour MP said.

"The few figures the Home Office has produced show how chaotic and unworkable their plans are."

The document came as Ms Braverman's plan to house asylum seekers on barges was branded "unworkable" as she missed her own target for the first vessel to be in place.

The Bibby Stockholm accommodation vessel, which will house around 500 people, is not yet in Portland Port, Dorset, despite Mrs Braverman promising MPs it would be in the dock a week ago.

The barge is currently in Falmouth, Cornwall, for checks, maintenance and refurbishment work.

On Monday June 5, the Home Secretary told the Commons "we will see an accommodation barge arrive in Portland within the next fortnight".

Liberal Democrat home affairs spokesman Alistair Carmichael said: "This seems to be another case of Home Office policy by press release that is failing to materialise.

"Braverman's plan for a barge on the Dorset coast is an unworkable plan that is wasting time and money, much like all of this Government's asylum policy."

The Home Secretary wants to use barges and sites including converted military bases to house asylum seekers and reduce the £6 million daily cost of hotel accommodation while people await a decision on their status.

The Bibby Stockholm was the first barge secured under the plan, but its journey to Portland will now take place in the coming weeks, according to the Home Office.

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

Home Secretary James Cleverly (left) and shadow home secretary Yvette Cooper take part in a live immigration debate on LBC's Nick Ferrari at Breakfast at Global Studios in Leicester Square, London. Picture date: Tuesday June 25, 2024.

James Cleverly debates Yvette Cooper on immigration | Watch Again

Yvette Cooper slammed Just Stop Oil as 'pathetic'

Yvette Cooper slams 'pathetic' Just Stop Oil as she brands Stonehenge stunt a 'total disgrace'

Laura Saunders, the Conservative candidate for Bristol North West

Tory candidate being investigated over alleged election date bet is 'married to Conservative Director of Campaigns'

Gambling probes into two Tory candidates are a 'betrayal of trust' in Rishi Sunak, Michael Gove has said.

Gove says election bets are ‘betrayal of Prime Minister’s trust’ as second Tory candidate investigated by regulator

Keir Starmer came out on top after LBC’s two exclusive phone-ins

Keir Starmer comes out on top after LBC phone-ins – as Rishi Sunak seen as ‘overwhelmingly negative’

Labour Party leader Sir Keir Starmer during LBC's Nick Ferrari at Breakfast

'We would seek a better agreement' Keir Starmer tells LBC where he thinks "botched" Brexit deal can be improved

Sir Keir Starmer speaks to LBC

‘No magic wand’ to recruit more teachers as Starmer insists removing ‘tax breaks’ for private schools is ‘tough choice’

Tom Weatherall is still searching for his treasured medals which went missing in France

Renewed plea for missing medals lost in France as RAF veteran gifted with set of replicas

'Economically Brexit's working': Nigel Farage says but claims it has 'not been properly implimented'

'Economically Brexit's working': Nigel Farage says but claims it has 'not been properly implemented'

Nigel Farage says Germans should 'get a sense of humour' amid calls for football fans who chant 'Ten German Bombers' to be prosecuted

Nigel Farage says Germans need to 'get a sense of humour' if football fans sing Ten German Bombers chant

Nigel Farage in the LBC studio today and (right) on the Reform UK campaign bus in Barnsley, South Yorkshire this week

'This is how ordinary people speak': Farage defends Reform UK candidates after anti-Islam and far-right comments exposed

Tory Work and Pensions Secretary Mel Stride was put on the spot by an LBC listener from a "Blue Wall" constituency rained down a barrage of complaints about soaring mortgages, the NHS crisis, crumbling schools and roads, and dentist shortages.

'Why would anyone sane vote for the Tories?': Minister put on the spot with barrage of complaints from LBC listener

Mr Weatherall's lost medals

Nick Ferrari offers £500 reward for return of RAF veteran's medals lost yesterday in Ranville, France

Kemi Badenoch rules out serving alongside Nigel Farage after he hints at Tory takeover.

Nigel Farage 'wants to destroy the Conservative Party', Kemi Badenoch tells LBC

'We've got to give these people justice': Ministers vow to address any criminal wrongdoing in infected blood report

'We've got to give these people justice': Ministers vow to address any criminal wrongdoing in infected blood report

'Minuscule state' of RAF is 'utterly pathetic' meaning just one plane available for D-Day 80th anniversary parachute jumps

'Minuscule state' of RAF is 'utterly pathetic' with just one plane available for D-Day 80th anniversary parachute jumps