Anti-strike legislation ‘won’t work’ warns Tory peer, while callers oppose rail walkouts

20 January 2023, 10:42

Tory peer says anti-strike legislation won't work warning government will lose votes in the Lords

By Phoebe Dampare Osei

“Workers do have rights you know” Conservative Peer Lord Balfe told Nick Ferrari, adding the government would lose votes in the House of Lords unless they review their proposed legal clampdown on industrial action, while callers felt the rail strikes should not go ahead.

A Tory peer has told Nick Ferrari at Breakfast on LBC that the government’s proposed crackdown on the wave of industrial action “won’t work” and should be reviewed, otherwise votes would be lost in the House of Lords.

Nick began: “Lord Balfe, you talk about an industrial relations climate. How much is that helped - or otherwise - by the legislation this government is seeking to bring through to provide for a minimum service in matters such as education and rail?”

Lord Balfe replied: “As of the moment, it’s not helping at all frankly. The legislation won’t work, which is the worst thing about it.”

READ MORE: Government introduces anti-strike legislation to 'ensure basic level of service' during walkouts

“Why won’t it work, Lord Balfe?” Nick queried.

“Because how do you get minimum standards?” his guest countered. “Which children do you say will not be educated? Which ambulances do you say will not run?

“They’re barking up the wrong tree here, and the best thing they can do with that bit of legislation is to drop it because it won’t work.”

Passionate caller labels UK railway services 'shocking'

Nick Ferrari then suggested Grant Shapps, Jeremy Hunt or Rishi Sunak might justify the legislation by saying “people deserve to have some kind of train service, some kind of education for their children, some kind of delivery of parcels”.

“Workers do have rights, you know”, Lord Balfe replied, adding that “there is a bit of difference between a parcel and a man with a heart attack”.

“I don’t think the government has thought it out…they are going to lose votes in the House of Lords if they do not amend this legislation”, he added.

READ MORE: Plans to curb workers' rights to strike are 'poisonous' says former Labour leader Neil Kinnock

Rudy in Bristol said: “Until the members provide a reliable proper service they don’t deserve any money. In fact the services provided are so bad they deserve a pay cut! You don't reward someone for bad service, do you?”

After Nick said this is the very reason they are striking, his caller continued to complain of “absolutely shocking trains” which are “always late” and “cancelled last minute”.

Caller: 'Mick Lynch, he loves a picket line!'

Another caller, Charlie in Reigate said RMT General Secretary Mick Lynch “loves a picket line”, saying: “Even if the strike ends tomorrow I guarantee you by the end of this year the railways will be on strike again.”In his defence, Nick said that Mr Lynch had just ensured that there would be “no compulsory redundancies” for the next seven to eight months.

Charlie supported the nurses strikes, saying they “work really hard”, but felt the RMT chief reminded him of trade unionist Arthur Scargill, adding: “I don’t like the man, he stirs up a lot of trouble.”

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

Nick

Nick Ferrari callers react to new measures to control illegal migration

Exclusive
LBC Presenter Nick Ferrari visits Cromwell Hospital in West London.

Nick Ferrari shares his experience getting tested for prostate cancer amid calls for UK to ramp up routine screening

Exclusive
A report claims police should make people give their biological sex, rather than their self-ascribed gender.

Police should record biological sex after arrests, minister says, after report claims criminals can pick their own gender

Exclusive
Itay Kashti, a Jewish-Israeli music producer, was lured to what he believed was a musician retreat before being beaten and kidnapped for his race and religion.

Israeli music producer opens up about horrific anti-Semitic kidnapping as three men jailed for extortion plot

Exclusive
British military in 'sorry state' and needs 'well north of 3% of GDP for a decade', ex-Army chief warns

British military in 'sorry state' and needs 'well north of 3% of GDP for a decade', ex-Army chief warns

Exclusive
Speaking to LBC’s Nick Ferrari, Katharine Birbalsingh branded the Government’s plans for school uniforms “marxist” and warned they could seriously impact students’ ability to learn.

‘Britain’s strictest head’ lashes out at government plans to limit branded school uniform items

Fury as London Underground book exchange scrapped over 'fire risk' after two decades

'Why can’t we have nice things?': Fury as London Underground scraps book exchange over 'fire risk' after 20 years

Exclusive
Jordan North and Chris Stark's hilarious remix of Sian Welby reading kids' book on LBC.

'Who's digging up my nuts?': Jordan North and Chris Stark's hilarious remix of Sian Welby reading kids' book on LBC

Politicians 'must be able to question judicial decisions' amid row over 'activist judges,' Priti Patel tells LBC

Politicians 'must be able to question judicial decisions,' Priti Patel tells LBC amid row over 'activist judges'

Exclusive
Israel must 'square the circle to get hostages out' as Israeli President labels 500 day wait 'tormenting, aching and painful’.

Israel must 'square the circle to get hostages out' says President, labelling 500 day wait 'tormenting, aching and painful’

Nigel Farage 'reduced to tears' over ECHR rule which saw Albanian criminal's deportation 'halted over chicken nuggets'

Nigel Farage 'reduced to tears' over ECHR rule which saw Albanian criminal's deportation 'halted over chicken nuggets'

Reform UK leader Nigel Farage joins farmers and their tractors at Belmont Farm in north London

Farage urges farmers to 'keep the pressure up' as tractor protest hits Westminster over Labour’s ‘family farm tax’

Exclusive
Calls for police to reinvestigate parish councillor who 'blew up' neighbour's cat

Parish councillor resigns after being accused of trying to ‘blow up’ beloved pet cat

Exclusive
Calls for police to reinvestigate parish councillor who 'blew up' neighbour's cat

‘It made me feel physically sick’: Cat owner’s fury at parish councillor accused of trying to ‘blow up’ beloved pet

Nick Ferrari Reflects on an Unforgettable Journey to Auschwitz-Birkenau with Holocaust Survivor Arek Hersh

Nick Ferrari reflects on an unforgettable journey to Auschwitz-Birkenau with Holocaust survivor Arek Hersh

Actress and Writer Dame Maureen Lipman reads The Tale of Squirrel Nutkin

Actress and Writer Dame Maureen Lipman reads The Tale of Squirrel Nutkin