'There is a wealth of experience that we should be mining': Nick Ferrari defends an unelected upper chamber

23 June 2023, 13:39 | Updated: 23 June 2023, 13:43

Nick Ferrari and this caller debate creating an elected upper chamber

By Alice Bourne

Nick Ferrari debated with this caller the merits of an unelected second chamber, arguing that it wasn't right to put acclaimed individuals, there by "dint of what they know," through "the rigours of an election."

Claire in Edgware told Nick Ferrari at Breakfast why she felt the House of Lords should be elected, saying: "Everybody, no matter what role they have in public life, should be elected to it."

The call comes after it was announced that Labour is formulating strategies to nominate numerous peers to the House of Lords, aiming to effectively execute the objectives of a Keir Starmer-led government.

She continued: “Nobody should be appointed or have it by inheritance.”

Nick then countered this by saying: “Do you not see that in some instances, where they are debating legislation concerning policing affairs, isn’t it quite useful that you’ve got someone such as John Stevens, who was arguably the last really successful commissioner of the MET, so he can give his views?”

READ MORE: Labour will 'abolish the House of Lords' to 'restore trust in politics' under Sir Keir Starmer

Claire then argued that Nick was “looking at it from a situation in which these people wouldn’t put themselves forward”, and argued: “I mean if John Stevenson wanted to put himself forward he should.”

Nick then pointed out a flaw in Claire’s argument: “Ah you see, the fact you didn’t know his name means that he’s unlikely to get it, his name’s actually John Stevens, not Stevenson and he’s there by dint of what he knows, surely that is a benefit.”

Labour’s use of the ‘quasi-judicial process' will ‘come back to haunt them says Lord Stewart Jackson

He continued: “Why have we got to put them through the rigours of an election… there is a wealth of expertise that we should be mining.”

Claire then repeated her point: “You are still working on the assumption that these people wouldn’t put themselves forward... I think they should.”

Nick took issue with this again: “They’re not vain enough."

Claire then said: “You don’t have to be vain to represent your country.”

Nick disagreed: “To be a politician you have to be incredibly vain.”

While Keir Starmer has openly criticised Boris Johnson's honours list, which granted seven peerages, and expressed his long-term goal of abolishing the House of Lords, insiders within the party recognise the necessity of appointing a considerable number of peers.

This measure is intended to prevent a Labour government from getting entangled in disputes with the upper chamber.

READ MORE: 'Bring it on!': Sadiq Khan's three-word response to speculation Boris Johnson will run to be Mayor of London

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

Exclusive
Home Secretary James Cleverly (left) and shadow home secretary Yvette Cooper take part in a live immigration debate on LBC's Nick Ferrari at Breakfast at Global Studios in Leicester Square, London. Picture date: Tuesday June 25, 2024.

James Cleverly debates Yvette Cooper on immigration | Watch Again

Yvette Cooper slammed Just Stop Oil as 'pathetic'

Yvette Cooper slams 'pathetic' Just Stop Oil as she brands Stonehenge stunt a 'total disgrace'

Laura Saunders, the Conservative candidate for Bristol North West

Tory candidate being investigated over alleged election date bet is 'married to Conservative Director of Campaigns'

Gambling probes into two Tory candidates are a 'betrayal of trust' in Rishi Sunak, Michael Gove has said.

Gove says election bets are ‘betrayal of Prime Minister’s trust’ as second Tory candidate investigated by regulator

Keir Starmer came out on top after LBC’s two exclusive phone-ins

Keir Starmer comes out on top after LBC phone-ins – as Rishi Sunak seen as ‘overwhelmingly negative’

Labour Party leader Sir Keir Starmer during LBC's Nick Ferrari at Breakfast

'We would seek a better agreement' Keir Starmer tells LBC where he thinks "botched" Brexit deal can be improved

Exclusive
Sir Keir Starmer speaks to LBC

‘No magic wand’ to recruit more teachers as Starmer insists removing ‘tax breaks’ for private schools is ‘tough choice’

Tom Weatherall is still searching for his treasured medals which went missing in France

Renewed plea for missing medals lost in France as RAF veteran gifted with set of replicas

'Economically Brexit's working': Nigel Farage says but claims it has 'not been properly implimented'

'Economically Brexit's working': Nigel Farage says but claims it has 'not been properly implemented'

Nigel Farage says Germans should 'get a sense of humour' amid calls for football fans who chant 'Ten German Bombers' to be prosecuted

Nigel Farage says Germans need to 'get a sense of humour' if football fans sing Ten German Bombers chant

Nigel Farage in the LBC studio today and (right) on the Reform UK campaign bus in Barnsley, South Yorkshire this week

'This is how ordinary people speak': Farage defends Reform UK candidates after anti-Islam and far-right comments exposed

Exclusive
Tory Work and Pensions Secretary Mel Stride was put on the spot by an LBC listener from a "Blue Wall" constituency rained down a barrage of complaints about soaring mortgages, the NHS crisis, crumbling schools and roads, and dentist shortages.

'Why would anyone sane vote for the Tories?': Minister put on the spot with barrage of complaints from LBC listener

Mr Weatherall's lost medals

Nick Ferrari offers £500 reward for return of RAF veteran's medals lost yesterday in Ranville, France

Kemi Badenoch rules out serving alongside Nigel Farage after he hints at Tory takeover.

Nigel Farage 'wants to destroy the Conservative Party', Kemi Badenoch tells LBC

'We've got to give these people justice': Ministers vow to address any criminal wrongdoing in infected blood report

'We've got to give these people justice': Ministers vow to address any criminal wrongdoing in infected blood report

'Minuscule state' of RAF is 'utterly pathetic' meaning just one plane available for D-Day 80th anniversary parachute jumps

'Minuscule state' of RAF is 'utterly pathetic' with just one plane available for D-Day 80th anniversary parachute jumps