Tax barrister brands HMRC loan charge 'completely against rule of law'

23 April 2021, 16:05

HMRC Loan Charge: Tax Barrister sets out the details

By Joe Cook

A top tax barrister has told Nick Ferrari he believes the HMRC are acting "completely against the concept of the rule of law" in attempting to claw back money from self-employed contractors.

Keith Gordon, from Temple Tax Chambers, told Nick "several hundred thousand people" may have been affected by the measure, which is designed to claw back unpaid taxes from people who HMRC says used "disguised remuneration" tax avoidance schemes.

The measures has proved controversial due to the size of sums being demanded by the government as well the length of time since and circumstances in which the schemes were entered into.

Read more: Nick Ferrari challenges Treasury Select Committee Chair on the loan charge

Mr Gordon said he believes HMRC's claim that they are trying to close a tax loophole is "clearly" wrong.

"The loophole that is suggested to have existed is still there, people are still selling these type of schemes, trying to turn taxable salary, taxable wages, into some sort of non-taxable receipts," he explained.

Nick Ferrari challenges Tory MP Mel Stride on the loan charge

"But secondly, the loan charge wasn't actually trying to close this down, it was trying to claw back the tax that HMRC would like to have received on these arrangements in the past but had missed the boat, had failed to take the right steps at the right time against the right people.

"The Revenue were faced with a bit of egg in their face, so what they decided to do was to invent a brand new tax charge so as to replicate the tax that they thought should have been paid at an earlier stage. That is the loan charge."

Loan charge victim tells all to LBC

Asked by Nick why he was so passionate about the issue, the barrister, who has blogged widely on the issue, said it was because the loan charge "works completely against the concept of the rule of law".

Read more: Sir Ed Davey accuses Treasury of 'attacking self-employed people'

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

Chancellor brands Labour plan to tackle small boat crossings 'absolute joke' which will 'encourage more people to come'

Chancellor brands Labour plan to tackle small boat crossings 'absolute joke' which will 'encourage more people to come'

Former immigration minister Robert Jenrick said Conservative voters were "on strike" and needed Rishi Sunak's government to be honest about the mistakes that have been made.

Tory voters are 'on strike' and Sunak needs to be 'honest' to keep them on side, Robert Jenrick says

The UK government is 'deeply concerned' about the assault on the Rafha crossing in Gaza and wants to see a 'credible military plan' from Israel.

UK government 'deeply concerned and need to see credible military plans' after Israeli offensive on Rafah crossing

Met chief Sir Mark Rowley has said that anyone using a 'swastika in the context of the Middle East crisis' will be arrested.

Met police chief pledges to arrest protesters using swastikas at Gaza protests

Sir Mark Rowley said filming interactions with police at protests had become "intrusive".

Filming police at protests is 'physically intrusive' and 'escalates situations', says Met Commissioner

Exclusive
Kemi Badenoch has launched a 'call for input'.

Gender-neutral toilets could lead to ‘schoolgirls getting UTIs because they don't want to share’, minister says

Exclusive
Met police commissioner Sir Mark Rowley spoke on LBC on Wednesday

Female officer’s hand reattached as Met chief reveals horror injuries suffered by police in Hainault sword attack

LBC observed how Scotland Yard manages to police divisive demonstrations in London

'It makes our job incredibly difficult': Police surrounded by cameras on protests as they make ‘on the hoof’ law changes

Nick Ferrari spent the day in the Met Police Operations Control Room

Nick Ferrari goes behind the scenes at the Met Police's massive efforts to keep the peace at heated protests

Exclusive
John Cleese has said he's 'all in favour of content warnings'.

‘I’m all in favour of trigger warnings’, John Cleese tells LBC as he says ‘society has changed’

Two of the Household Cavalry horses are 'in serious condition' and there are concerns they may never fully recover

'Seriously injured' horses undergo emergency operations after London rampage - as one recovers in equine hospital

Two Household Cavalry horses 'in serious condition' amid fears animals may not survive after London rampage

Two Household Cavalry horses 'in serious condition' amid fears animals may not survive after London rampage

This is the moment Nick Ferrari puts a government minister on the spot over the government's new plans to ban smoking.

'When will the Conservatives be banning alcohol?' Nick Ferrari puts minister on the spot after smoking ban vote passes

'I'm ashamed to say Nick, I started smoking when I was 12' Tory MP reveals

Minister who reveals she started smoking at 12 says she's not interested in freedom argument against ban

This guest told LBC he was against Rishi Sunak's smoking ban because 'everybody dies in the end' and the NHS should 'price in' the cost of dealing with sick Brits.

'The NHS is there to make you healthy' guest dismisses smoking ban as 'everybody dies in the end'

Speaking to LBC's Nick Ferrari at Breakfast, Lord Kim Darroch the former UK National Security Advisor for his assessment of the performance of "the current PM, the man who was PM and the man who wants to be PM"

Rishi Sunak has 'left the pitch free' for Lord Cameron to be Foreign Sec and 'toughen the line on Israel', says former diplomat