Conservative MSP Rachael Hamilton says SNP is 'completely out of touch'

1 March 2023, 09:07 | Updated: 1 March 2023, 12:23

Rachael Hamilton MSP says the SNP is 'completely out of touch'

By Alice Bourne

MSP Rachael Hamilton described the SNP's approach to gender reform surrounding rape and sexual assault cases as "unedifying", as she told Nick Ferrari that the reform bill has done immense damage.

Trans rapist Isla Bryson's case, MSP Rachael Hamilton said, "certainly contributed to Nicola Sturgeon's resignation".

Nicola Sturgeon, she argued, showed particular weakness in not being able to describe Isla Bryson, a double rapist, as a man. This is despite Scottish law stating that only a biological man can rape women.

The Scottish MP also told Nick Ferrari at Breakfast on LBC that the reality of the Scottish prison system means that, "a sex offender in Scotland could be back on the streets in 4 years" which is "stressful for the victims... to think that a double rapist could serve half the time" for their crimes.

READ MORE: Transgender rapist Isla Bryson will serve sentence at notorious men's prison which houses murders and paedophiles

This comes as Isla Bryson the transgender double rapist is jailed for eight years after attacking two women in Clydebank and Glasgow in 2016 and 2019 whilst known as Adam Graham.

During the verdict, the judge said Bryson posed a high risk of reoffending and would be supervised for three years after release.

Rachael Hamilton MSP says trans rapist case 'certainly contributed to Sturegon's resignation'.

She added: "we said this all along, that her self-ID system would remove safeguards and mean predatory men have access to vulnerable women and could essentially rape women."

Bryson is a prime example having changed his gender whilst in custody, "he didn't even hold a gender recognition certificate" Rachael Hamilton said.

Isla Bryson
Isla Bryson. Picture: Alamy

READ MORE: Overjoyed caller pokes fun at Rishi Sunak for ‘admitting that it’s better to be in the EU’

The case has sparked intense debate over whether Bryson should be housed in a male or a female prison after transitioning from a man to a woman. Bryson who was initially remanded to a women's jail after being found guilty has since been moved to a men's facility.

Ms Hamilton told Nick: "We have got a very mixed up situation" with a policy that is "so unpopular...putting vulnerable women in very difficult positions" and which "around 70% of the public disagree" has now predictably torn the SNP apart.

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

Nick Ferrari and caller Eve

Nick Ferrari and caller Eve go back and forth over the Middle East conflict

LBC caller Paula drives home the impact of PIP benefit cuts

LBC caller Paula drives home the impact of disability benefit cuts

'Iran has a democratic candidate, unlike Iraq...'

Iraqi caller explains why Iran-Iraq comparisons fall short

It's not fair

Nick Ferrari loses his patience with caller over ‘non-dom’ tax scheme

Caller Som has a warning from the past as the conflict between Israel and Iran escalates.

Caller Som has a warning from history as Israel and Iran conflict escalates

LBC callers react to Israel’s ‘risky’ strike on Iran

LBC callers react to Israel’s ‘risky’ strike on Iran

Caller in Israel warns against Iran becoming a nuclear-armed state

Caller in Israel warns against Iran becoming a nuclear-armed state

Caller points out that Israel denied entry to Labour MPs as UK comes under fire for new sanctions

Caller points out that Israel denied entry to Labour MPs as UK comes under fire for new sanctions

Caller Layla

Caller Layla fears for her daughters following Kemi Badenoch's Burqa comments

Caller Barry

LBC caller backs the government's reversal on the winter fuel allowence

Nick Ferrari is unsure about caller Bill's proposal to turn migrant hotels into prisons

Nick Ferrari is unsure about caller Bill's proposal to turn migrant hotels into prisons

Call the Cabinet: Nick Ferrari is joined by Environment Secretary Steve Reed to take your calls

Call the Cabinet: Nick Ferrari is joined by Environment Secretary Steve Reed to take your calls

LBC reaction: 1200 Channel migrants arrive in a single day

LBC reaction: 1200 Channel migrants arrive in a single day

Exclusive
'Elite mindset' and ‘left-wing opinion’ fuelling migrant crisis says Nick Ferrari as he slams government

'Elite mindset' and ‘left-wing opinion’ fuelling migrant crisis says Nick Ferrari as he slams the government

Reform, racism and ‘a perverse Batman’ | LBC’s best callers of the week

Reform, racism and ‘a perverse Batman’: LBC’s best callers of the week

'Farage is a media-made man'

David and Nick debate whether 'tiny and ridiculous' Reform gets too much airtime