Jonathan Pie: Jimmy Carr's Holocaust joke 'technically very well written'

7 February 2022, 15:10 | Updated: 7 February 2022, 16:08

Jonathan Pie 'vehemently defends' Jimmy Carr Holocaust joke

By Seán Hickey

The comedian behind the comedy political reporter Jonathan Pie tells LBC that he will 'vehemently defend' Jimmy Carr's right to tell a joke about the Roma Genocide in the Holocaust.

Comedian Jimmy Carr has come under fire in recent days after a joke in his new comedy special His Dark Material divided opinion. In the show, Mr Carr tells a joke about the Holocaust and points out that Roma Gypsies were victims of the atrocities as well as Jews, stating that "nobody wants to talk about the positives".

Comedian Tom Walker, best known for his work under the moniker Jonathan Pie, joined Nick Ferrari to discuss the controversy.

Read more: Head Gypsy: Jimmy Carr's Holocaust joke 'struck fear into my heart'

"The line between offence and comedy is very thin, in Jimmy Carr's case they jump across that line gleefully" he began, explaining to listeners in this case that "you have to look at two things: context and intent."

"Are we seriously saying that Jimmy Carr actually condones the mass murder of Gypsies?" He asked, before making the case that Mr Carr doesn't in fact think this way.

Read more: Seething David Lammy calls on Netflix to 'abandon' Jimmy Carr over Holocaust joke

'As Gypsies, we've got bigger things to worry about than Jimmy Carr.'

Read more: Shelagh Fogarty condemns Jimmy Carr's 'cruel' Gypsy Holocaust joke

"Is it a tasteless joke? Yes. Is it a joke I found funny? No. But I would vehemently defend his right to tell that joke."

Mr Walker then went on to explain the skill behind Mr Carr's writing which produced such uproar: "He turns what sounds like is going to be a woke statement into the exact opposite."

"Technically its a very, very well-written joke."

The comedian then took a wider look at the implications for the art if Jimmy Carr is cancelled for his joke.

"If you've got lots of people judging your work who haven't even watched it and are looking at one joke out of context, then yes, comedy is in trouble."

"Comedians should be running screaming to Jimmy Carr's defence, even if they find the joke distasteful" he insisted, concluding that "this puts their careers in jeopardy."

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

Minister quizzed on tweet where he described Trump as 'cancer'

Minister Bim Afolami says tweet in which he referred to Donald Trump as 'a cancer' is appropriate

Lee Anderson

Police 'looking into hate speech complaint against Lee Anderson' after MP said Sadiq Khan was controlled by Islamists

Richard Tice said he turned down two Tories who tried to join the party

Reform UK leader Richard Tice says he rejected two Tory MPs who tried to defect in the last year

Michael Tomlinson repeatedly refused to answer Nick Ferrari's question

Nick Ferrari cuts off minister who refuses to answer his questions nine times over Lee Anderson's 'Islamophobic remarks'

Rishi Sunak is facing a revolt for sacking Lee Anderson

Lee Anderson refuses to apologise for 'Islamist' comments as he doubles down on criticism of Sadiq Khan

Rishi Sunak is facing a revolt for sacking Lee Anderson

PM denies Tories have 'Islamophobic tendencies' as minister says Lee Anderson's comments were 'profoundly wrong'

Dame Esther Rantzen has told LBC why she is campaigning to change the law on assisted dying

‘Dogs get treated better than humans’, Esther Rantzen says, as TV legend demands assisted dying law change

Rishi Sunak (l) puts on a brave face to the Tories by-election defeats on a visit to Harlow. New Kingswood MP Damien Egan (top r) and Wellingborough MP Gem Kitchen (bottom r)

Rishi Sunak begs frustrated Tories 'not to put Starmer in power' after party suffers double by-election disaster

New Labour MPs Damien Egan and Gen Kitchen

'They are not very good results': Tory chairman admits after double by-election drubbings as MPs call for tax cuts

The peer was speaking to LBC's Nick Ferrari at Breakfast

'It was known yesterday' Azhar Ali had made more Israel conspiracy theory comments, peer tells LBC

Scammers should be treated like violent criminals, a senior anti-fraud officer has said.

Scammers should be treated like violent criminals, senior anti-fraud officer tells LBC

The vessel is due to lead the largest Nato exercise since the Cold War, involving more than 40 vessels, after its sister ship was forced to cancel its deployment because of an 'issue' with its propeller shaft.

HMS Prince of Wales docked while it should be 'defending our interests abroad', Minister brands it 'not acceptable'

Lord Rose took aim at government quangos in the wake of the Post Office scandal

'They grow like multi-headed hydras': Asda chairman takes aim at government quangos after Post Office scandal

Exclusive
Lord Stuart Rose speaking to LBC's Nick Ferrari

Police 'not picking up the phone' to attend shoplifting 'endemic', Lord Stuart Rose tells LBC

Dentists who set up practice in areas of England with poor access to NHS care will be offered a £20,000 bonus

Health Secretary Victoria Atkins stumped on exact figure for new dentists as ministers plan £20,000 ‘golden hello’

When asked by Nick to sum up the Government in one word, Ms Keegan said: "Delivering."

Gillian Keegan rates the Government using Ofsted descriptions - and it's not 'Outstanding'