Nick Ferrari grilled SNP MP over likelihood of Scottish independence

17 December 2019, 14:19

SNP MP Alyn Smith has refused to say if there would be a border with Scotland if independence was achieved.

Speaking to LBC's Nick Ferrari, Mr Smith said it is "only right" that the people of Scotland should have the right to choose when it comes to membership of the EU.

When challenged about independence under Boris Johnson, who wants to keep Scotland part of the UK, Mr Smith questioned how committed the PM is to anything - citing his promise to get Brexit done by the 31st October.

"People in Scotland voted very clearly against Boris Johnson's government and for my party," he said.

"Event he labour politician is clearly on a pro-EU trajectory where Mr Johnson is very clearly trying to take Scotland out against its will.

Of course we need to keep independence on the table."

He added: "I think the extent to which Mr Johnson is committed to anything except Mr Johnson is an open question.

Mr Smith pictured with Nicola Sturgeon
Mr Smith pictured with Nicola Sturgeon. Picture: PA

"Of course we need to keep independence on the table."

"I think the extent to which Mr Johnson is committed to anything except Mr Johnson is an open question.

"He said lots of stuff about Northern Ireland and then ditched them. This is the man who said he would 'rather be dead in ditch' than not deliver Brexit on the 31st October and then he didn't."

Speaking on the topic of Independence, Mr Smith said the SNP would seek to join the EU as an independent country.

He added the type of border that would exist would depend on the 'resting point' of Brexit - what the UK's withdrawal agreement looks like when it is eventually implemented.

Mr Smith claimed that he and his colleagues at the SNP have talked the border situation through 'extensively' - but would not say if they would push for a hard border or not.

He said the SNP's standpoint that whatever happens, staying within the single market and the customs union is their top priority.

But ultimately admitted that at this time there is a lot of questions to be answered about the issue of the border, but they will not be answered until a new independence referendum is called.

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

Reform, racism and ‘a perverse Batman’ | LBC’s best callers of the week

Reform, racism and ‘a perverse Batman’: LBC’s best callers of the week

'Farage is a media-made man'

David and Nick debate whether 'tiny and ridiculous' Reform gets too much airtime

Tube worker John

Tube worker shares his close encounters with fare dodgers

LBC callers react to Netanyahu calling out Starmer for being on the 'wrong side of humanity'

LBC callers react to Netanyahu calling out Starmer for being on the 'wrong side of humanity'

LBC callers react as the UK suspends trade talks with Israel

LBC callers react as the UK suspends trade talks with Israel

LBC callers react: UK, France and Canada threaten Israel with sanctions

LBC callers react: UK, France and Canada threaten Israel with sanctions

LBC caller ‘annoyed’ by reaction to UK-EU deal

LBC caller ‘annoyed’ by reaction to UK-EU deal

LBC caller tells Nick Ferrari: "You've got everything wrong for the last decade"

LBC caller tells Nick Ferrari: "You've got everything wrong for the last decade"

Gary Lineker 'to quit the BBC this week' | LBC reaction

LBC reaction: Gary Lineker quits the BBC

LBC callers react as Keir Starmer signs off his 'Brexit reset'

LBC callers react as Keir Starmer signs off his 'Brexit reset'

'British people don't want to pick fruit...'

Nick Ferrari won't take this caller's reasoning for the '9m economically inactive' in the UK

LBC caller’s plan to fix the care home sector

LBC caller’s plan to fix the care home sector

Trade deals, conclave and Reform UK: LBC’s best callers of the week

Trade deals, conclave and Reform UK: LBC’s best callers of the week

'Kemi Badnoch needs to get over herself'

'Woo-hoo!’: LBC caller reacts to the US-UK trade deal

'We went from back of the queue with Obama, to this'

Scottish farmer Murdo says that the US-UK deal is 'a big win for prime beef'

'In the Middle East, you're a laughing stock"

Caller Stewart says UK migration policy is "stirring up trouble"