Amy Coney Barrett refuses to commit to recusing herself from election cases

13 October 2020, 16:24

US Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett
Supreme Court Barrett. Picture: PA

Ms Barrett said she had not spoken to President Donald Trump about how she would handle any election-related challenges.

Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett has said she cannot commit to recusing herself from any cases involving disputes that may arise from the US presidential election.

Ms Barrett told the Senate Judiciary Committee: “I can’t offer an opinion on recusal without short-circuiting that entire process.”

The judge said she had not spoken to President Donald Trump or anyone else in the administration about how she would handle any election-related challenges. And she said she would have to confer with the other justices on the court before deciding.

Supporters of Donald Trump’s Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett
Supporters of Donald Trump’s Supreme Court nominee Amy Coney Barrett (AP/Jose Luis Magana)

Ms Barrett is on Capitol Hill for a second day of hearings. The mood is likely to shift to a more confrontational tone as Ms Barrett, an appellate court judge with very little trial court experience, is grilled in 30-minute segments by Democrats strongly opposed to Mr Trump’s nominee. Republicans are rushing her to confirmation before polling day in the US election.

The committee chairman, Lindsey Graham, opened the session under coronavirus protocols with a focus on healthcare, and ending the Affordable Care Act.

Mr Graham also quickly asked if the Catholic judge would be able to shelve her personal beliefs to adhere to law.

Senator Lindsey Graham questions Amy Coney Barrett
Senator Lindsey Graham questions Amy Coney Barrett (Brendan Smialowsi/Pool via AP)

“I can. I have done that,” she said. “I will do that still.”

Mr Graham praised her as a conservative woman of faith and the best possible nominee Mr Trump could have chosen.

“I will do everything I can to make sure that you have a seat at the table. And that table is the Supreme Court,” Mr Graham said.

The Senate, led by Mr Trump’s Republican allies, is pushing Ms Barrett’s nomination to a quick vote before November 3, and ahead of the the latest challenge to the “Obamacare” Affordable Care Act, which the Supreme Court is to hear a week after the election.

Republicans also hope to seat Ms Barrett quickly enough to hear any legal challenges after the election. Democrats are demanding that she pledge not to take part in any election case, but she has made no such commitment.

Amy Coney Barrett speaks during her confirmation hearing
Amy Coney Barrett speaks during her confirmation hearing (Shawn Thew/Pool via AP)

One of the two Republicans on the panel who tested positive for Covid-19, senator Thom Tillis, joined the committee for the first time on Tuesday, after ending quarantine.

Ms Barrett presented her approach to the law as conservative and fair on Monday at the start of fast-tracked confirmation hearings. Democrats cast her as a threat to Americans’ healthcare coverage during the coronavirus pandemic.

With her husband and six of their seven children behind her in a hearing room off-limits to the public and altered for Covid-19 risks, Ms Barrett delivered views at odds with the late Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the liberal icon whose seat Mr Trump nominated her to fill, laying out a judicial philosophy she has likened to that of her conservative mentor, the late Justice Antonin Scalia.

“Courts are not designed to solve every problem or right every wrong in our public life,” declared the 48-year-old federal appeals court judge, removing the protective mask she wore most of the day to read from a prepared statement.

Americans “deserve an independent Supreme Court that interprets our constitution and laws as they are written,” Ms Barrett told the committee.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Birthday Party Crash

Two children dead and 15 injured after truck crashes into child’s birthday party

United States Ukraine Weapons Explainer

US lawmakers approve multibillion-dollar aid package for Ukraine and Israel

Congress TikTok

US lawmakers pass legislation to ban TikTok within a year

Mideast Tensions Satellite

Iranian attack damaged taxiway at Israeli air base, satellite image shows

China Kite Festival Photo Gallery

In Pictures: Colourful creations fill sky at Chinese kite festival

People pass by a damaged electric pole caused by flooding due to heavy rains in Pakistan

Pakistani province issues flood alert and warns of heavy loss of life

Russian rockets are launched against Ukraine from Russia’s Belgorod region

Ukrainian drones targeting Russian power stations shot down, says Moscow

Speaker of the House of Representatives Mike Johnson

US House of Representatives on brink of approving aid for Ukraine and Israel

Nigeria Chess Education

Nigerian chess champion plays game for 60 hours in new global record bid

Nigeria Chess Education

Nigerian chess champion plays game for 60 hours in new global record bid

Palestinian medics carry a child hurt in the Israeli bombardment of the Gaza Strip to the Kuwaiti Hospital in Rafah refugee camp

Six children among nine Palestinians killed by Israeli air strike in Rafah

Bystanders react after witnessing the man lighting himself on fire

Man who set himself on fire outside Trump trial dies of injuries, police say

APTOPIX Indonesia Volcano

More than 2,100 people evacuated as Indonesian volcano spews clouds of ash

Iranian officials say the attacks, in the central province of Isfahan, were caused by small exploding drones

Israeli airstrike on Iran downplayed as tensions ease between Tel Aviv and Tehran

Azzarello was pictured outside the courthouse a day earlier with a conspiracy sign

'Conspiracy theorist' who set himself on fire outside Donald Trump's hush money trial has died, police confirm

Venezuela Ecuador Mexico

Venezuela’s main opposition bloc agrees on candidate to challenge Maduro